snazy commented on PR #3207: URL: https://github.com/apache/polaris/pull/3207#issuecomment-3629240864
@singhpk234 I appreciate you taking the time to review the code! I totally understand that everybody has a ton of things on his plate and time is an extremely rare resource for everybody. Regarding the two points you and @collado-mike mentioned, may I refer you both to @pingtimeout's [email to the dev-ML from March 20th this year](https://lists.apache.org/thread/ljz98v5wgmbfk82tj8wnlgz9lxm360yj), where he mentioned this [doc](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1RLYaAtNUkgNW3Ef7-BWfF_8RkSK7B7oR/) with a _very_ detailed performance analysis? I admit, that it's been quite a while since that email was sent. Let me note, that the benchmark was a very important foundational piece and that a bunch of optimizations addressing his findings were implemented in the (NoSQL) code base since then. If you have different, reproducible results for such benchmarks, I would be glad to collaborate on the findings! Let me also reply to your other point about "having to support all backends": I think this is driven by demand from the whole community, for example #844 from January this year, recently gotten even some more interest. In the recording you mentioned (I assume it is the one from Adam's presentation) I clearly stated that there is no intent to implement support for _all thinkable_ database. What I clarified is that it is _doable_. We have been discussing the whole NoSQL approach for quite a while, mentioning it repeatedly on the dev-ML, in community syncs and docs including [this one from last year](https://docs.google.com/document/d/1POUWe0xMZOBoaJ6Rgiw35ziEoc6OEYCiW7Zk6bR9H6M/), which is open for comments since then. There were also a public presentations held by @adam-christian-software quite some time ago, which he repeated recently. The "big illustrative PR #1189", open for review for ~266 days, was explicitly intended to collect feedback. But it hasn't got many comments, despite asking continuously and repeatedly for it. Any feedback is more than welcome! I apologize that I fail to see what else we could have done beside all the things that were already mentioned. Everybody's open for suggestions to streamline the process for such big changes! -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: [email protected]
