+1
On 27 February 2014 17:36, jan i <j...@apache.org> wrote: > Hi. > > This proposal is identical to the 2 earlier proposals, which failed to get > enough votes. > > This change in the bylaws [2] requires 2/3 vote +1 of the PMC members. > > VOTE runs until 15 march 2014, and can be extended if deemed necessary. > > Vote +1 if you agree to to following > > - Every ASF committer can ask for one or more labs. The lab creation > requires PMC lazy concensus, if no PMC sends a mail with -1 > tol...@labs.apache.org within the lazy consensus period (72hours), the lab > request is > accepted. > > from/replacing > > - Every ASF committer can ask for one or more labs. The creation of > the lab requires a PMC lazy consensus vote > (at least three +1 and no -1, 72 hours). > > > Reasoning: > > The charter [1] and homepage [2] for labs says: > > - Every ASF committer can ask for one or more labs. The creation of > the lab requires a PMC lazy consensus vote > (at least three +1 and no -1, 72 hours). > > However the foundations glossary [3] defines lazy consensus today as: > > *Lazy consensus*(Also called 'lazy approval'.) A decision-making policy > which assumes general consent if no responses are posted within a defined > period. For example, "I'm going to commit this by lazy consensus if no-one > objects within the next three days." Also see Consensus > Approval<http://www.apache.org/foundation/glossary.html#ConsensusApproval>, > Majority > Approval <http://www.apache.org/foundation/glossary.html#MajorityApproval>, > and the description of the voting > process <http://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html>. > > Due a lazy consensus decision among PMC, earlier +1 votes are considered > valid (of course a change in vote is fully acceptable): > > Danny Angus +1 > Geir Magnusson Jr +1 > J Aaron Farr +1 > Niall Pemberton +1 > Santiago Gala +1 > Simone Gianny +1 > Simone Tripodi +1 > Tim Williams +1 > > We need binding votes from: > > Erik Abele > Gregor Rothfuss > Jan Iversen > Noel J. Bergman > Graham Leggett > Reinhard Poetz > Garrett Rooney > Scott Sanders > Sander Temme > > How we manage to succeed this time. > > rgds > jan I >
