Quoth Paul Ireland:

> I have said many times.  It's not force if you CHOOSE it.  The state
> absolutely has the legitimate authority to charge for the PRIVILEGE of
> bringing goods across national borders. 
>
> If the state charges a tariff for the PRIVILEGE of bringing goods
> across the borders, especially a fair and flat very low percentage
> tariff that can't be considered "protectionist" by any sane person,
> those wishing to bring goods know about the tariff before they CHOOSE
> to import the goods.  If they CHOOSE to do so anyway, they are
> CHOOSING to pay the tariff.  If they try to bring goods across without
> paying the tariff, they are committing an act of aggression...namely
> trespass and theft.

Nice argument -- except you've never given any good reason why
bringing goods across imaginary lines drawn by the strongest gang of
thugs in an area for the purpose of extorting a protection fee is a
"privilege." You're not even consistent, as you don't ascribe the same
magical powers to these imaginary lines when it is people, rather than
goods, crossing them.

Tom Knapp





ForumWebSiteAt  http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Libertarian



SPONSORED LINKS
Libertarian English language Political parties
Online dictionary American politics


YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS




Reply via email to