I've looked at the proposed Apache License 2.0, and I'd like to suggest that 
you extend the patent defence clause to withdraw the license from anyone who 
tries to enforce a patent against *any* open source software.

Open source software can be defined as any software available under a license 
approved by the Open Source Institute.

If most open source software were licensed to include such clauses then anyone 
contemplating patent action against open source software would have to 
contemplate replacing open source software used anywhere in their organisation, 
and permanently losing the option of switching to open source solutions in the 
future.  This would be a mighty stick to beat potential litigants.  Individual 
defence clauses of the sort currently proposed (and common in Mozilla-style 
licenses) have the failing that only the package under attack is withdrawn.  So 
a patent holder could sue one project while still continuing to use all other 
open source software.

Paul.

Reply via email to