On Monday 21 June 2010 16:34:25 slamberton wrote:
> 1.  Unacceptable activity: in this instance its the use of this mailing
> list--which is to discuss LPI program and activities, or on a wider note,
> Linux and Open Source Software, to use this list as a personal recruitment
> vehicle for social networking tools e.g. sending a blanket invitation to
> the entire community to a particular social network app (e.g. facebook,
> linkedin, etc.).  Its happened before and people didn't like it.  Its
> misuse of the lists' intentions--and I don't know of any mailing list that
> would permit this kind of activity. 

Scott,

This is correct, but consider how these annoying things happen:

User signs up for some social service and it tells him if he gives it his 
gmail account, it will invite all his friends so we can all have FUN!!!!

And the user does it, not realising mailing lists are in his gmail contacts.

So there are 3 flaws:

- the user is just being thick and unobservant
- mailing lists seldom have a means to discard these invites
- social network sites don't care and just blast every address

Punishing the first one heavily is probably too big a hammer (especially as 
pranksters can abuse it). We can't really influence #3 much, which leaves #2.

I haven't run a Mailman instance for a while but the logic to get it to 
recognize invites shouldn't be too hard to implement so I feel one's efforts 
should be directed there. It fits nicely into a sysadmin's job of "protect the 
users from crap".

As far repeat offenders - for those you must do what you must.


-- 
alan dot mckinnon at gmail dot com
_______________________________________________
lpi-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://list.lpi.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/lpi-discuss

Reply via email to