On 2/16/06, demerphq <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> ps: I'll go out on a limb here and say that MB should NOT be made core
> until it makes Makefile.PL production mandatory. And until it can

My opinion : the functionality that's interesting to add in the core
is to be able to run Build.PL, not to produce distros.
On the other hand, if we begin to ship M::B with stable perls, a lot
of people will keep perl's M::B and not upgrade it. So we'd better be
sure it's pretty stable in terms of functionality and API. So I agree
with you here.

> install all of the core modules that are built with it on all of the
> main OS'es that use it. Actually id go even further and say that no
> core distro should use MB until that distro can be installed on all
> the main OS'es.

I agree for XS core modules; pure-perl core modules just don't use any
makefile during perl's compilation process, so it's less important.
But it might be important that people can upgrade core modules without
installing non-core modules. (That won't be always the case, since
sometimes new dependencies appear.)

Reply via email to