Well, I am NOT a lawyer :) I enjoyed very much reading the hot discussions
about copyright and so on lately. Well, let me add some fuel to the fire :)
It's a case study:
Mr. Xyz bought and owned a CD, he made a digital copy to his MD for
personal use. One year later, Xyz found that he is running out room and he
wanted to sell his CDs, including which were digitally copied to MD.
hmm....is it legal or illegal to sell those 2nd hand CDs?
Happy New Year to all!
warmest regards
Wailun Kwok
Steve wrote:
> I'm a lawyer. Magic's definition of "commercial" is silly. It is not
> commercial activity if I find a penny on the sidewalk. But really,
> that's just common sense isn't it? If you trade enough MDs for the
> wrong reasons it would be commercial activity. God only know how many
> it would take. It's like asking how many angels dance on the head of
> a pin.
>
> Otherwise, though, this has been an utterly fascinating thread. I was
> wondering why Eric The Man Woudenburg (honestly I do admire you) was
> holding back for so long. You've been scoring major blows to the
> opposition with your recent posts!!!! It's a delight to see you enter
> the frey, and on the right side too.
>
> Regards to the list, Steve
-----------------------------------------------------------------
To stop getting this list send a message containing just the word
"unsubscribe" to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
