Yeah, at one point I suggested getting her a cheap Netbook or something, new(ish) and running Win*, but the old man doesn't want to spend anything on it (except a little time). He has some computer equipment he doesn't need any more, and feels it's a shame to throw it away, and maybe can help an old friend in the process. Maybe I can persuade him to just donate it to some reuse/recycle outfit, and figure out something else for her, perhaps an older Wintel notebook or something.

On a Linux box, the friend would be locked out of the Admin (root) account, and could just do regular unprivileged user things. Email and Web surfing would be the only activities. She wouldn't be able to do much damage to the system, and would probably never even think about deleting files, much less try to install any new programs. She has no previous computer experience, so she isn't going to care if the screen looks like Windows or like Looney Tunes. The downside is that 7 months or so a year, the system has to be absolutely bulletproof and rock-solid, as there will be no one to help, or to do updates (at least, if it's Linux). It's almost like putting a system out in the middle of Antarctica (actually it's in the backwoods of Maine, which is almost the same).

It might be a good idea to get her some cheap Win box or Netbook, and let my father gain some experience in Linux first before trying to help others with it. He really isn't looking to take on another OS, and would be just as happy to let Linux drop, as Vista is sufficient for him. It would certainly make dealing with the (probable) WinModem and (probable) WinPrinters a non-issue.

On 7/30/2010 5:42 PM, Ed Nisley wrote:
trying to set up an old PC (10 or 12 year old Compaq
[opinion]

Kick that junker to the curb and get something from the
current millennium.

Having futzed with several PCs from that era, it simply
isn't worth the aggravation of trying to ram a contemporary
distro into not enough RAM with not enough CPU, then keep it
running with no connectivity.

For the price of three or four tanks of gas, get a perfectly
serviceable netbook / low-end desktop / off-lease Dell that
won't have any of those problems.

Yeah, as an intellectual exercise, you can use an old
junker, but *why* take on that much aggravation?

Oh, and the new box will come with Windows, which solves all
the compatibility problems, too...

[/opinion]


_______________________________________________
Mid-Hudson Valley Linux Users Group                  http://mhvlug.org
http://mhvlug.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/mhvlug

Upcoming Meetings (6pm - 8pm)                         MHVLS Auditorium
 Aug 4 - Samba
 Sep 1 - BOINC
 Oct 6 - Creating Firefox Extensions

Reply via email to