“…So from my point of view…” – gruff

Gruff, it is clear that we start with quite different tenets when it
comes to many topics. I accept that you do not accept what I present.


On Nov 2, 12:57 pm, gruff <[email protected]> wrote:
> As I stated earlier, I know little of Chomsky but I did read the link
> you posted regarding the interview with him.  Since you recommended
> that link I am obliged to assume that you consider it to be a
> substantial statement of his view on anarchy.  However Chomsky himself
> states that he has no confidence in his own views about the "right
> way" to achieve it (i.e., his ideal state of anarchy.)
>
> He then agrees with the interviewer that anarchism is formless and
> utopian and counters that it is hardly more so than what he considers
> other inane doctrines.  He begins to give any interested readers hope
> by saying that anarchism is in his view an expression of an idea ...
> but then wanders off into saying that the burden of proof thereof is
> always on those who argue that authority and domination are
> necessary.
>
> He then goes on to state that -- as he understands it -- anarchism is
> based on hope that some sentiments of human nature include what is
> generally referred to in everday society as civilized behavior all of
> which I have referred to in numerous posts over the last year.  He
> then makes the self-contradicting statement that the absense of
> government might allow the strong to dominate the weak which he
> insists would require some form of organization to overcome that
> domination.  Would that not be government?
>
> Chomsky also seems pretty well convinced that capitalism cannot
> comport with his idea of freedom from oppression.  He seems unable to
> understand that capitalism when reasonably and properly regulated
> would enable people to achieve the greatest amount of personal
> freedom.  I beleive you have said somewhere in one of your posts that
> freedom cannot exist under capitalism but ignore the freedom that
> having wealth can give individuals.  Of course I have to admit that
> the form of capitalism that would best grant these freedoms is an idea
> and an ideal that it can be rationally regulated so as to overcome
> individual greed.
>
> His ideas regarding anarchist education -- that is, if I am
> understanding him correctly -- would lead a child to indulge his own
> unique bent.  That seems to me not much different from the bent taken
> by the children in Lord of The Flies.
>
> When asked how an ideal anarchist society would function on a day-to-
> day basis he blithly refuses by saying he wouldn't dream about trying
> to do this.  Say what?
>
> I'm sorry if this offends, but to me Chomsky is merely indulging his
> own ego with the tools of linguistics thus leading him around in
> circles of his own making, which also reminds me strongly of your own
> circular propositions and questionable arguments sans any substantial
> evidence or even credible logic and rationale.
>
> As regards the Declaration of Independence, I have always been at odds
> with a number of ambiguous statements therein, most especially those
> which require some form of natural evidence which is not defined to
> prove the contention that all men are created equal, then goes on to
> require a god to have allegedly endowed us with certin unalienable
> rights.  This is gross error and may have worked on old George but
> have little meaning in secular life.
>
> We are born by virtue of natural causes have no "rights" whatsoever,
> not even the right to life which can be extinguished even before we
> emerge from the womb.  Throughout our infancy and early childhood we
> maintain life and limb at the discretion and good will of our parents
> and/or guardians.
>
> Only when we have achieved a certain stage of growth where we can
> begin to make decisions and act on them through individual volition
> can it be said we begin to have rights.  This is because a right is
> taken and held by virtue of our own power and lost by the lack
> thereof.  This is why, in the sense we speak of, power and right are
> synonymous.  No matter how many times you say it, rights are not
> innate and never will be.
>
> The Declaration is also self-contradictory in that it continues after
> it's false claim that we have certain inalienable rights that these
> rights must be secured by government which derives it's power to
> secure these rights from the consent of the governed.  If they were
> inalienable rights they would not need to be secured.  They would be
> forever so, thus they are not only alienable but must be held by the
> force of power which I believe stands as evidence from your own pen of
> my point.
>
> Regarding the rest of your argumentative contentions and demands for
> evidence thereof, the evidence lies in your own words in your earlier
> post.  I will leave it to you to discern that evidence.
>
> I don't think that the phrase "peace on earth" necessitates a new
> topic.  It very much belongs here in this discussion of rights, powers
> and anarchy.  We are discussing a potential form of civilization and
> how to attain it.  I submit that peace is an apt characterization of
> the ideal civilization.
>
> Again I apologize for contradicting you but you very much did, in so
> many words, state and imply that we should disband our military and
> lay down our arms ... and unilaterally as well.
>
> Then you go into a lengthy argument about the fallacy of
> argumentation, citing of all things, a Canadian politician in support
> of your points of view.  I have read Lindsays explanations and agree
> with very few of them and could easily tear most of the apart with
> little difficulty.
>
> Much has been written about argumenation and evidence although I admit
> that most of my knowledge thereof comes from law, which is based on
> argument and evidence.  There are volumes written on evidence and the
> body of law regarding it is very explicit on what is evidence and what
> is not, what is acceptable and what is not, what is valid and what is
> not.
>
> My direct questions to you are only disingenuous in that they stem
> from statements you have made or strongly implied.  Regarding the use
> of questions in law, questions are the most frequently used method of
> arriving at the truth and uncovering falsehood and mistake.
>
> While it is true there would be more freedom in the example you lay
> before me regarding the use of motorcycle helmets, the results would
> be far more disastrous and devestating given that most bikers would
> likely choose to not wear a helmet, thus dying or being permanently
> disabled in many cases which would in turn result in the removal of
> their producitve participation in society and the likelihood that
> society would end up supporting them.
>
> As regards Franklin, just because he was a respected statesman does
> not make his every utterance absolute truth and I contend that he is
> in grievous error when he said that those who seek security over
> freedom deserve neither.
>
> So from my point of view you have no only not put forth a good
> argument for anarchism you have also failed to present any good
> evidence for your point of view.  Again, my apologies.
>
> On Nov 1, 3:59 am, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> > (continuation of discussion with gruff from topic: "Her",
> > Objectification.)
>
> <not restated since it would be repetitious and use up bandwidth>
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
""Minds Eye"" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to