IF anyone was perplexed by gruff’s post that started out: ================================================== "... On Nov 2, 2:49 am, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote: ..." > “The key is to find what minimal structures would > ensure a nonetheless democratic and regulated form of life that > inspires peace, creativity and satisfying, shared work and > responsibility as far as possible.” *** ... to which archytas replied that ... =================================================== Please note that the words attributed to me were in fact a quotation of archytas’ earlier post and not my words.
On Nov 2, 1:19 pm, gruff <[email protected]> wrote: > "... On Nov 2, 2:49 am, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> > wrote: ..." > > > “The key is to find what minimal structures would > > ensure a nonetheless democratic and regulated form of life that > > inspires peace, creativity and satisfying, shared work and > > responsibility as far as possible.” *** > > ... to which archytas replied that ... > > > > > > > > In my view, Chomsky doesn't do much other than point to a form of > > > anarchy. This is old hat, if welcome. The key is to find what > > > minimal structures would ensure a nonetheless democratic and regulated > > > form of life that inspires peace, creativity and satisfying, shared > > > work and responsibility as far as possible. The problem with most > > > discussion in here is that most don't recognise what follows or is > > > implied in their positions. The deeper problematic, of course, is > > > that there are 'rules of argument' and varying abilities in it (or > > > rather various forms of it). More understanding of this needs to be > > > established, yet how do we do that without some arbiter becoming the > > > problem - or even the new Fuhrer. Also concealed in much we do are > > > the rules of mannered society (Norbert Elias) and the gatekeepers of > > > public air time. Frankly, we can't even lay out the argument and > > > start looking for evidence, theoretical help and so on - here > > > personal deceptions about our beliefs and experience are severely > > > limiting. > > > > It is easy enough to hide snide ad hominem behind assertions to argue > > > objectively - I've just seen our Home Secretary make an utter arse of > > > himself trying to say he sacked out drug's advisor over his behaviour > > > (at a time when all politicians are failing to address their own > > > thieving and lack of ability), when all the guy has done is be > > > truthful and reasonably scientific. I can only say we are very bad at > > > it in here (as most of my students remain, even after three years) - > > > but then we would be in such a short format. I'd like to see more > > > reasoned dialogue in here, but there are many other ways to take what > > > we do. In the end, I prefer the odd smile, jibe, swipe and laugh. We > > > miss something about being able to share in disagreement, perhaps > > > whilst thinking 'what the ****' even with the gun lobby - and what can > > > be done in wit and debunking the over-serious. > > That said and restated, I will try to elucidate my own view of > anarchism, which in a sense I do consider to be an ultimate form of > society much akin to the 'heaven' given much lip service by religious > types. > > As I have noted many times, my faith and belief is in our own species, > the human race, to eventually achieve a utopian form of society > wherein we will be at peace with each other, where there will be no > war nor the need for standing armies, arms, nor for law enforcement > nor the armies of police, security and mercenaries it requires. > However, barring some tremendous breakthrough on a global level, that > day and state of being is much further in the future than we have come > since we first crawled out of the primeval muck. We are still very > much infants in the scheme of things and at very best I would consider > us to be no more than adolescents in this game of civilized society. > > In the meantime, it requires a huge body of law, rules and regulations > for us to even survive with each other on a day-to-day basis and this > very body of law precludes anything remotely resembling freedom. > While in an ultimate sense we do have the liberty and freedom to obey > or disobey any part or all of this body of law but the latter > frequently results in an even more severe restriction of any liberty > or freedom (notwithstanding the very real fact that punishment is in > no way a preventative or deterrent except for the offending individual > and then even for only short periods of time.)- Hide quoted text - > > - Show quoted text - --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
