[Marsha]
Marsha processes all kinds of patterns. She processes millions of patterns in a single day, some intellectual, some not. I am not an intellectual; I am not a single definition of anything. I'm not even a grandmother. Can you even consider what it is not to attach to such superficial self-identification. I'm this. I'm that. What utter ridiculousness!

[Arlo]
This is quite a tangent from my point, but...

If you are not attached to "superficial self-identification", why do you sign all your posts "Marsha"?

I'd never say you are "one thing" and forever trapped in that definition. Even as a "son" or "father", that role changes over the course of a lifetime. But to claim that you are totally free from being "this" or "that" is utter ridiculousness. When you daughter calls you, do you tell her "I don't have a daughter, and I am not a mother"? What would the point of that be? I am not sure if your mother is still with you, but if she is or when she was, did you tell her "you are not my mother because I am not a daughter"? Do you tell your grandchildren you are not their grandmother because you are not this and not that? If they are not your grandchildren, why do you treat them differently than any other child that age you come across?

When you sign all your posts "Marsha", there is a stable pattern of identification, a desire to thread consistency through your posts, that is the pointer "Marsha". You are not an intellectual because you've been assigned that label, you are an intellectual because you enjoy the activity of philosophy, of thinking about metaphysical issues, of playing with patterns of thinking. It is not more derogatory a label than "mother", which you affirm every time you nurture and console and teach and support and raise and advise and love and provide for your child. "Grandmother" is not an artificial trap of some kind, it is a testament to your activity.


Moq_Discuss mailing list
Listinfo, Unsubscribing etc.
http://lists.moqtalk.org/listinfo.cgi/moq_discuss-moqtalk.org
Archives:
http://lists.moqtalk.org/pipermail/moq_discuss-moqtalk.org/
http://moq.org/md/archives.html

Reply via email to