>>Wrong. PI is a subset of OGC. If it isnt mixed with >>OGC, there is no need to PI it. > > No. OGL Sec. 1 says: > > (e) "Product Identity" means [list omitted] and any > other trademark or > registered trademark clearly identified as Product > identity by the owner of > the Product Identity, and which specifically > excludes the Open Game Content; > > "Product Identity" is "non-OGC which is mixed in > with OGC. The definition > provides a way for identifying and specifically > excluding this material from > OGC.
We are actually saying the same thing. Maybe my list should be more detailed. 1. Non-OGC (whether designated as PI or not) 2. OGC that is not PI 3. OGC that is PI. When I say PI is a subset of OGC I guess I am not entirely being accurate. You can PI stuff that isnt mixed with OGC. As you can see in my previous example of OGC designations, I do just that with Necro tradmarks and logo etc, which are not contained in the part of the book that I desingate as OGC, but I PI them anyway. But for the purpose of the "clearly identify" discussion, there is no need to talk about the PI that is not mixed with OGC. Clark Clark ===== http://www.necromancergames.com "3rd Edition Rules, 1st Edition Feel" _______________________________________________ Ogf-l mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://mail.opengamingfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/ogf-l
