We sure we can fix it and we know how. The only problem is to somehow
get a hand with reviewing and approvals speed? Is there any remedy for
this? I've asked Michael already above in the thread, but I don't
presume that it's possible even to allow one of us to become core
reviewer for EC2 part of the nova? Or is it?
On 1/30/15 10:57 PM, Tim Bell wrote:
Many thanks for the constructive approach. I've added an item to the
list for the Ops meetup in March to see who would be interested to help.
As discussed on the change, it is likely that there would need to be
some additional Nova APIs added to support the full EC2 semantics.
Thus, there would need to support from the Nova team to enable these
additional functions. Having tables in the EC2 layer which get out of
sync with those in the Nova layer would be a significant problem in
I think this would merit a good slot in the Vancouver design sessions
so we can also discuss documentation, migration, packaging,
configuration management, scaling, HA, etc.
*Sent:* 30 January 2015 20:44
*To:* Alexandre Levine
*Cc:* foundat...@lists.openstack.org; OpenStack Development Mailing
List (not for usage questions)
*Subject:* Re: [OpenStack Foundation] [openstack-dev] Finding people
to work on the EC2 API in Nova
+1 cloudscaling has been pretty involved in ec2 support for openstack
for a long while now.
On Fri, Jan 30, 2015 at 2:27 PM, Alexandre Levine
<alev...@cloudscaling.com <mailto:alev...@cloudscaling.com>> wrote:
Our team can take the effort. We're the ones doing the stackforge
EC2 API and we can maintain the nova's EC2 in acceptable state for
the time being as well.
If you can give us any permissions and leverage to not just
contribute fixes and tests but also have a say in approval of
those (maybe to just one of us) then it'll be fast. Otherwise
it'll happen in due time but our previous attempts to contribute
some fixes for EC2 API in nova took usually more than half a year
to get through.
On 1/30/15 3:01 AM, Michael Still wrote:
as you might have read on openstack-dev, the Nova EC2 API
implementation is in a pretty sad state. I wont repeat all of
details here -- you can read the thread on openstack-dev for
However, we got here because no one is maintaining the code in
for the EC2 API. This is despite repeated calls over the last 18
months (at least).
So, does the Foundation have a role here? The Nova team has
find someone to help us resolve these issues. Can the board
find resources as the representatives of some of the largest
contributors to OpenStack? Could the Foundation employ someone
us our here?
I suspect the correct plan is to work on getting the stackforge
replacement finished, and ensuring that it is feature
the Nova implementation. However, I don't want to preempt the
process -- there might be other ways forward here.
I feel that a continued discussion which just repeats the last 18
months wont actually fix the situation -- its time to "break
that mode and find other ways to try and get someone working
Foundation mailing list
OpenStack Development Mailing List (not for usage questions)