Hello,

Am Sonntag, 12. Februar 2006 20:04 schrieb Henne Vogelsang:
> the last 2 days i was working on the new listserver trying out what
> we can use a archive software etc.
>
> I think im going to use MHonArc[1] with the following layout (hacked
> together by me influenced by macho[2])
>
> http://lists4.opensuse.org/opensuse/

looks nice ;-)

(I guess you'll make / nicer, too ;-)

> Some questions i have:
>
> Do we need year folders? Like opensuse/2006/monthindex
> Do we need month folders? Like opensuse/2006/01/mailindexes

I think: yes.

Currently, I see the newest messages on the first page and a link "next 
page". Imagine what happens if you want to see the list of messages 
sent some monts ago - "click click click click ..." ;-)
(You also can't cache the indexes on the server because they change with 
every new message.)

Additionally, the URL of the message list containing a specific thread 
will change all over the time because the newest one is numbered "1", 
the next "2" etc. - that's not a good thing.

Additionally, I don't like the restriction to 100 mails per page - 
people will loose much time by clicking "next".

Maybe for the low-traffic lists (*-announce) you don't need to separate 
the months, but if this would add more work, monthly lists aren't a 
problem ;-)

Another idea would be to have only the first mail of a thread displayed 
("thread start" view) - but I guess this isn't that easy ;-)


Some thoughts and possible enhancements when displaying a single 
message:
- can you show the Message-ID? It's very useful for searching for a 
  specific mail ;-)
- can you highlight the current mail in the "This thread" column?
- is quote highlighting possible?
- completely hiding mail adresses may be too hard. Also, hiding 
  everything that looks like a mail adress isn't a good idea.
  For example, a prompt like   [EMAIL PROTECTED]:~/test>   doesn't need to be 
  encrypted ;-)
  Unfortunately, in some cases the "xxx wrote" contains the mail adress,
  so not encrypting mail adresses at all isn't a good solution, too.


Regards,

Christian Boltz
-- 
>> Microsoft-Compatible Spongiforme Encephalitis?
> Setzt das nicht Hirn voraus?
Irgendwo müssen doch all die Beschwörungsformeln hin, die man als
MCSE auswendig lernen muß. Ein schwammförmiges Gehirn scheint mir
dafür durchaus geeignet ...
[Aran Kuntze, Gerhard Schromm und Martin Bienwald in dasr]

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to