We believe this revision addresses the following DISCUSS comments: Jari Arkko Adrian Farrel Robert Sparks Peter Saint-Andre Dan Romascanu Russ Housley
Note: we did not address non-DISCUSS comments. We are planning to do that on a subsequent pass. Most of the changes are editorial/clarifying, however, a number were substantive (though generally not breaking). Here's a summary of what we believe the major ones are: * Changed the certificate enrollment protocol to remove the password from the URL. Note that this is a breaking change. * Globally renamed "private id" and "compressed id" to "opaque id" * Specified the details of the overlay name (S 5.3.2) * Nailed down the fragment semantics, harmonizing between the fragment field defn. and the rules for generating fragments. The high bit must always be set and unfragmented packets are represented as the last fragment with an offset of 0. * Specified new requirements for malicious loop prevention: - Configuration servers are supposed to set TTL based on overlay size. - Peers must check that TTL never exceeds the configured maximum. - Peers should check for duplicates in the destination list. * Added a new Error_Invalid_Message generic error code. In terms of schedule, we plan to spin a new draft before the draft deadline that addresses all the DISCUSS comments and as many of the comments as possible. Ekr, Bruce, & Cullen _______________________________________________ P2PSIP mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/p2psip
