-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA256 On 01/17/2012 06:43 PM, Cullen Jennings wrote: > > We believe this revision addresses the following DISCUSS comments: > > Jari Arkko Adrian Farrel Robert Sparks Peter Saint-Andre Dan Romascanu Russ > Housley > > Note: we did not address non-DISCUSS comments. We are planning to do that > on a subsequent pass. > > Most of the changes are editorial/clarifying, however, a number were > substantive (though generally not breaking). Here's a summary of what we > believe the major ones are: > > * Changed the certificate enrollment protocol to remove the password from > the URL. Note that this is a breaking change. > > * Globally renamed "private id" and "compressed id" to "opaque id" > > * Specified the details of the overlay name (S 5.3.2) > > * Nailed down the fragment semantics, harmonizing between the fragment > field defn. and the rules for generating fragments. The high bit must > always be set and unfragmented packets are represented as the last fragment > with an offset of 0. > > * Specified new requirements for malicious loop prevention: > > - Configuration servers are supposed to set TTL based on overlay size. - > Peers must check that TTL never exceeds the configured maximum. - Peers > should check for duplicates in the destination list. > > * Added a new Error_Invalid_Message generic error code. > > In terms of schedule, we plan to spin a new draft before the draft deadline > that addresses all the DISCUSS comments and as many of the comments as > possible. >
I hate to be the one complaining again, but because the "final" draft will be released around March 11th, there will be only 2 weeks to review, implement, and try to fix it before the P2PSIP meeting itself and we all know how busy these few weeks before a meeting are. My prediction is that the meeting will be simply a list of issues or fixes that people will have no time to analyze and understand and that this meeting will be, like the one in Taipei, a waste of time. Won't it be more efficient to finish this now, which would give two months to be sure that everything is OK, and declare victory in Paris? - -- Marc Petit-Huguenin Personal email: [email protected] Professional email: [email protected] Blog: http://blog.marc.petit-huguenin.org -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux) iQIcBAEBCAAGBQJPGeuOAAoJECnERZXWan7EIT0QAJz0gd7XjK861AKEpeDkDSd1 QMDlI6QXz+sseYGJozw+OJzrTvulDO1oEGT1m9fbrpHyAgTEOMf+tlf3G6mAMrfi t3+MRuRMp7713+4sgPZ7PDDB2FNxsfK2guzBBwyzVC1Cv5YByrxkhSw/4vnyD801 dwbRed25Nfw/eDKWQH2GjZypE8hFLClkAqjAZcCI49rjJhacePxVLBj3x9xutc4g U0Cfjqts9FFSAlhKL9vnOpzxxxxa/TjtGnuEHwUsPH/sV+pJ8YZzRsAobYWWG61p Lne/fvhGHX3AJkjCf2v88UMDhQDdV04zLt2T585WtjDKdM8PZHQ0yU3/+Ply/pYT 41H1co/Esl13RRLA9hxwp44QpA1LL1c2zTWg+YQAiOagom33RkZ+vShjhwuiqx0Y ak8S3NaFJMCN+qnvfJmxF3gX11sUkSu/PDicMpz1qiHPlh47eaWAjOSYS/Ejy7+I LIk8Tl3J1XOGC02dNAZ0kjsajcM/wseDVCc+ejrwtd1zlwHTU4SdiBVIdA8cZVaz ntQEtX3GJolikLfsmWXiyxR2IZvHVQYI7+wb75xcGadPQAjIIwH9T7dzVlkhPLQT NjbDe5wxghIe8QJ6XLytYmAji+fBtvfGy+rjS6x4SWCSJKojFjInTExcAoKIxpkV y2wRBChN2ghdFlRpnEQo =u8Fs -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- _______________________________________________ P2PSIP mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/p2psip
