The Takumars are outstanding in their own right. But keep in mind that they
pre-date the advent of APO lenses, internal focusing, and other techniques
now commonly used to provide apochromatic correction on lenses above 200mm
and close focus.

Pentax never made a fast (f/2.8-class) screwmount 200mm lens. Soligor made a
200/2.8, but it's probably not as good as the Tak 200/4 (58mm filter). The
best screwmount 200 may be the Vivitar Series One 200/3, which focuses to 4
feet (1.2 m), and magnifies 1:4. Unfortunately, it was only single-coated in
the screwmount version.

In 300mm, The Carl Zeiss Jena Sonnar Auto Electric 300/4 (86mm filter) is
probably the Takumar's only true rival. Its owners rave about its sharpness
and color rendition. Hard to find in the States; look at German Ebay. In
January 2002 you could buy one $375 (US) reconditioned with a 3-year
warranty from Hans Roskam in the Netherlands at
http://rulsfb.Leidenuniv.nl/~roskam/index.html .

For prime lenses longer than 300, the Takumar 400/5.6 is "OK" but cannot
focus closer than 8 m. For what it lets you do--add a K-mount 1.4X TC and
get a K-mount 700/6.3--the Takumar 500/4.5 is a steal at $400 to $500. But
it cannot focus closer than 10m, and you must be prepared to support it with
a heavy-duty tripod and ballhead. I think there were three versions. The
first had a simpler lens formula and is best avoided. The second was single
coated. The third (SMC or Super Takumar) is multicoated.

[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 


Reply via email to