Doug Franklin wrote:

On Wed, 15 Jun 2005 16:38:13 +0200, Toralf Lund wrote:

I'm not sure the traditional JPEG files support this kind of
compression [lossless] even in theory.

According to my "Encyclopedia of Graphic File Formats" (Murray and van
Ryper, 1996) it did.

   "The JPEG standard does offer a separate lossless mode.
   This mode has nothing in common with the regular DCT-
   [Discrete Cosine Transform] based algorithms, and it is
   currently implemented only in a few commercial
   applications." [page 200]
Yes, but isn't that "the JPEG standard" as in the *compression standard*, as opposed to the file format? The fact that a compression scheme is defined by the JPEG does not necessarily imply that it is allowed in a format described by the same group. In fact, at least some of the work on lossless compression was done after the file format was defined.

- Toralf

Reply via email to