----- Original Message -----
From: Shaun Canning
Subject: RE: A 100/2.8 Macro on eBay


> And just how much better are the A-series 100mm than an FA
> 100mm for example?

If you prefer a manual focus lens (I do), then there is no
comparison. The AF lens just won't be a nice lens. I don't know
how good the FA 100mm macro is, reports on the list indicate it
isn't quite up to the A 100mm macro, which is superb. I am
pretty sure it is the sharpest lens I have used. The 77 may be
sharper.
I distrust the AF lenses (the Limited lenses are the exception)
on general principles. They have a really sloppy feel to them
that I find offensive. I don't believe lenses with that much
slop in them are as good as they could be, and I don't trust
them to not develop more slop over time. To me, a lens whose
mechanics feel imprecise is going to be an optically imprecise
lens.
The Limited lenses that I have handled don't share the
mechanical sloppiness of the other AF lenses I have handled.

William Robb


Reply via email to