On Mon, 2012-07-23 at 13:31 -0500, Larry Garfield wrote:

> Sales tax isn't the point with SOPA/PIPA.  Thinks like the government 
> being able to force any site off the Internet at the ISP / DNS level on 
> the say-so of a private corporation are the point.  And no, that's not a 
> defensible or acceptable position.  Breaking the Internet to prop up 
> industries that don't like being disrupted is not a proper use of 
> governmental power.
> I'm quite happy to see PHP.net joining in with other defense-of-freedom 
> voices.
> --Larry Garfield
> On 7/21/12 1:56 PM, With No Name wrote:
> > On Fri, July 20, 2012 10:04, Lester Caine wrote:
> >> In Europe VAT is applied even on on-line sales. It is the likes of Amazon
> >>   shipping bulk stock from overseas 'clients' into European warehouses and
> >> then supplying them without VAT added directly in Europe that is the
> >> problem! How can I compete with someone who is also giving next day
> >> delivery, but 20% cheaper ... American sellers are one of the problems
> >> here.
> >
> > It depends, because in Europe (I live in Germany), VAT is only added if
> > the value + shiping exceeds 25 Euro and customs are only added, if the
> > value exceeds 150 Euro
> >
> > It does NOT discriminate American sellers, because German sellers have to
> > bill the VAT too
> >
> > Also I buy regulary in the USA and even with heavy USPS costs plus 
> > Import-VAT
> > I am mostly lesser expensive as if I buy in Germany...
> >
> > Greetings
> >

>From what I can gather is that it will break DNSSEC, which has been
designed to establish trusted connections with DNS calls. Essentially,
browsers will accept only signed responses from web servers, and SOPA
(and PROTECT IP) would be redirecting DNS requests for US citizens,
which is precisely the sort of thing DNSSEC is meant to prevent; silent
redirection of DNS requests.

I'm not normally very vocal about these sorts of things, but it will
have ripple effects that can't be predicted in the very industry we all
have our livelihoods in, so I'm glad there's resistance against it.


Reply via email to