On 23/09/06, Steve Vinoski <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
The claims that Confluence makes regarding their functionality "around the edges" vs. what actually works also seems to be somewhat in question. For example, they claim to be able to generate PDF, but over on the CeltiXfire list, there was a discussion about this recently and it turns out that the feature doesn't actually work. I personally don't know whether it does or doesn't,
Many people in JPMC use the PDF generation feature and it definitely does work. That is not to say there is not a bug in a specific case but a blanket "it does not work" is simply not true.
Obviously I'll conform to whatever our project ultimately chooses, but that's my 2 cents based on many years of completely positive experiences with MoinMoin as both a user and an admin.
I think it comes down to whether Confluence can help the project. If it makes it easier to generate an attractive project website then I support it. I don't think when comparing MoinMoin and Confluence in terms of wiki functionality there is much to choose between them. (Although Confluence has a WYSIWYG editor which has been around for nearly a year now so that might be seen as an advantage by some people). RG
