dindin;522787 Wrote: 
> Hi, I tried setting security to Low, but that didn't help. Outbound
> policy is set to 'accept' on Medium as well.
> 
> I certainly don't want to accept all inbound requests by keeping the
> setting on 'Low'.
> 
> Also when I run diagnostics on the radio it does say OK on all the
> ports, see my first post. Which should indicate that the ports are not
> blocked.
> 
> So this remains a mystery to me.

Yeeks that's actaully a pretty confusing sucky setup.  Guess someone in
sales said "make it look secure, add three levels for them to choose! 
Who cares if it makes sense!"

A cheapo generic (ie Linksys/Belkin/etc) router doesn't usually have
that setup and doesn't worry about 'Incoming connections: reject' type
settings.

They do 'address translation' from the internal network to the real
internet.

So if you have a real IP on the internet of 172.16.2.3, say, machines
behind the router will have numbers like 192.168.1.48.  When a machine
inside starts a connection to outside, the router changes the 'source'
from 192.168.1.48 to 172.16.2.3.  It also remembers this, so packets
coming back to 172.16.2.3 that are on the same ports as the original
request get forwarded back to 192.168.1.48.

In addition (and this is why the settings are weird), packets that come
to 172.16.2.3 that do NOT have an entry in the address translation table
are discarded: the router has no idea which machine on your local
network they should go to, so it will discard them.  This is why, for a
server of some sort behind such a router, you need to set up portforward
rules, so if someone tries to connect to port 80, it knows to forward it
on to the machine you told it to...

So, it does effectively block -unsolicited- packets.  Solicited replies
come through just fine.

Which is why those settings are very confusing: you shouldn't need to
tell it to reject things, it should just do it.


-- 
snarlydwarf
------------------------------------------------------------------------
snarlydwarf's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=1179
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=75835

_______________________________________________
Radio mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/radio

Reply via email to