On Tue, 30 Mar 2010, Chris Adams wrote:

Is there any value in the redhat-lsb package - does anything actually
need it?

redhat-lsb has always pulled in cups on servers, and now with RHEL5.5,
cups pulls in poppler, which pulls in gtk2, some X libraries, and an
icon theme.  Just what I wanted on a mail server or a DNS/RADIUS server.

The LSB package is a 'keystone' to ensure that services through defined API's are available, so that a third-party ISV might be able to ship a single binary (that used only those defined interfaces) and know that it will work on may distributions. Think: high end statistical and engineering packages.

Why would a server be installing packages oriented to ensure a workstatation environment for ISV applications? That is the usual use case for 'redhat-lsb' being installed. It may appear to be a leaf node within a closed distribution view where such API guarantees are solved other ways, but it is ** not ** a leaf node when one expands the forest to include third-party ISV content, but rather a branch across to such binaries

-- Russ herrold

_______________________________________________
rhelv5-list mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/rhelv5-list

Reply via email to