So, thanks to the mail of Leonid Solovyov (referring to the GSAS manual for
the so call "subcell/supercell" broadening) I found out what I was not able
to understand from the Kirk and from the Bergmann mails (and searching on
my books, literature).
The subcell is only a way to simulate in part broadening due to faulting.
I wonder to know why people use criptic words for what was described 50
years ago in a clear way (for example by Warren). The result is that, when
I asked if the strange broadening is due to faulting or other things I got
a reply that it's subcell instead. Have people lost this way what is the
origin of these effects? Are we going to a future where we will not read
any more the old literature and renaming and rediscovering any sort of
physical phenomena?
Just to end, broadening due to faulting (unless is very poor) need not only
to model anisotropic peak width but also asymmetry, peak shift and
splitting. See Warren book for more..... or try Maud.
Best regards,
Luca Lutterotti
>> >>
>> >> Dear All,
>> >>
>> >> I am trying to carry out Rietveld refinement on a sample that has
>> >> very obvious peak shape variation; probably due to subcell and
>> >> supercell peaks. I believe there is a way to deal with this in GSAS,
>> >> but I can't quite work out the best way.
>> >>
>> >> I'd be grateful for any tips
>> >>
>> >> Caroline
>> >>
>> >>
>> >> Caroline Kirk
>> >
>> ........
>> >This may not be helpful to your specified query but if you have a Bruker
>> >XRD with Topas Rietveld software - Topas has an option to apply spherical
>> >harmonics not only to Preferred orientation, but also anisotropic
>> >peak broadening, peak displacements (e.g., due to stress/strain) and
>> >some other parameters as well.
>> >
>> > http://www.bruker-axs.com
>> >
>> ...............
>> >
>> >(I am not sure what other Rietveld programs allow this as well?)
>> >Lachlan M. D. Cranswick
>>
>>
>> The program Maud (see my web pages) also models anisotropic peak broadening
>> using the Popa (see on J. Appl. Cryst. of 1998, May-June?) model. It's an
>> advanced harmonic expansion method were the Laue group of the phase imposes
>> some obvious constraints on the harmonics to respect symmetries.
>>
>> There is another problem to know. Is the observed strange peak shape
>> simply anisotropy or there are other effects, like superstructure peak
>> broadening, asymmetry and peak displacement by faulting etc.?
>> In that case you need some special treatments (a.k.a Warren theories for
>> twin, stacking faults and/or antiphase boundary). Maud can be used in this
>> case but the actual general model only works for bcc, fcc, hcp structures.
>> No general approach available up to now.
>>
>> Probably you may give some more information about the material and what
>> kind of strange peak shape you are observing.
>>
>> Best regards,
>> Luca Lutterotti
>
>As Caroline has described, the peak shape is anisotropic due to
>subcell/supercell behaviour. I will explain, how I have solved
>this problem with BGMN:
>
>PARAM=b1sub=0_0^0.1 PARAM=supfactor=1_0^1 b1sup=supfactor*b1sub //
>B1=ifthenelse(mod(h+k+l,2),b1sub,b1sup)
>
>This text is part of the structure description input file.
>It is for the case of cubic bodycentered subcell/cubic primitive
>supercell. Of course, BGMN may handle (positiv definite) broadenings
>according to a Tensor of stage 4 (spheric harmonics of 4th order),
>too. See ANISO4 at www.bgmn.de. Of course, each value may declared to be
>ANISO4.
>
>J"org Bergmann, Dresden
>[EMAIL PROTECTED]
-----------------------Luca Lutterotti----------------------------
Dipartimento di Ingegneria dei Materiali, Universita' di Trento,
via Mesiano 77, 38050 Trento, Italy
e-mail address : [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Home page : http://www.ing.unitn.it/~luttero
Mirror: http://www.ccp14.ac.uk/ccp/web-mirrors/lutterotti/~luttero/
Phone number :+39-0461-88-2414
-Fax : +39-0461-88-1977-----------------------------------------