On Sat, 2005-12-17 at 13:34 +0000, Chris Cannam wrote: > I had some of these as well, but I never got around to writing them down > either... sorry (sigh). I'm not at a proper computer at the moment and I'm > awful busy for the next week at least, too. Off the top of my head, the main > things I had doubts about were: > > - the selector window has (or had) an editable text field for aliases
Fixed in cvs. I needed to call setReadOnly (true) on the QTextEdit. > - neither dialog has a cancel button. It needs to be possible to > (and clear how to) back out without changing anything. Apply/cancel > or some action buttons (e.g. Save) and close, but not just close. Fixed in cvs. Now it will abort editing or selecting a chord. > - need "are you sure?" when changing an existing chord? Added a quick questionYesNo in the guitar chord editor before adding a chord to the ChordMap. > - editor dialog not resizeable and dodgy layout - looks like the > selector is a nice KDialogBase subclass but the editor is straight > outta Designer. New layout changes should be much more user friendly. Please double check this since UIs are quite subjective as to their usability. > - I had trouble removing barres (and sometimes fingerings too I > think) - you may have mentioned that At this time I have no clear way on what is the best way to remove Note or Barre objects from the FingeringConstructor. Perhaps I will need to have two modes: Insert and Delete. Any ideas or design patterns I could use here? > - there were two symbols (O and X?) used at the top of the fretboard > to represent something or other to guitarists - I never worked out how > to get one of them (can't remember which) in my own fretboards X is used by engraving programs like Lilypond to denote when a string should be muted. O is used to denote an string that should be played without using a finger. Again let me know how I have done to be assured that I have really fixed the problems you gave. Stephen
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part
