Re: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives, , Dryers

2012-08-02 Thread John Sessoms

Quoting John Coyle jco...@iinet.net.au:


My Maxtor also played up last month, and I too bought a WD MyBook
replacement!
Fortunately, I don't use any backup software that was mangled by the
WD software, so the
transfer of data was only painful in that about 10% of the image
files were showing bad
reads:  I used the old DOS command XCOPY to do the transfer, worked
very well in the
background.  I was also lucky (or well enough organised!) to have a
second copy of the
image files so that I was able to replace those that showed bad
reads - nothing lost in
the long run.
The only issue I have now is that another external HDD now gets lost
from My Computer
occasionally and has to be remounted every now and then - possibly
the firmware in the
MyBook is interfering with it, but it's no biggy.




That's started to happen with my 1.5 TB WD external drive.  My laptop
won't allocate it a drive letter on boot and I have to go into 'Disk
Management' to allocate a drive letter manually every time I need to
use it.

Not sure if its an OS issue (Vista) or a problem with the drive.


I've noticed that the older of my two WD MyBook's takes a long time to 
start up. I've learned not to be in a hurry.


It takes 5 - 10 minutes sometimes before it will finally appear in My 
Computer under XP and Vista. But it has, so far, eventually showed up.


I think the power supply problems are in the plug-in transformers 
supplied with the drive.


--
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the directions.


Re: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives , Dryers

2012-08-01 Thread Godfrey DiGiorgi
My experience with WD drives is not great either. But not the drives
themselves, the enclosures. Once I ditched the 2T RAID case and moved
the drives into a third party RAID case, they became completely
reliable.

I don't know what crapware comes on any drive. Any drive I buy I
immediately reformat without looking at what's on it. I have
everything I need to manage drives built into OS X, don't want any of
that junk.
-- 
Godfrey
  godfreydigiorgi.posterous.com

-- 
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the directions.


Re: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives , Dryers

2012-08-01 Thread Paul Sorenson
So...it sounds like the problem lies within the circuit board, not the 
platters.  Maybe you could just replace the PCB.


http://www.onepcbsolution.com/

-p

On 7/31/2012 10:00 PM, Anthony Farr wrote:

To all who've responded, thank you for the sympathetic comments.  I
guess I was correct to believe that PDMLers would find data backup to
be a topic close to their own hearts, and that a saga about it would
find interested readers.

Something that I should point out is that the failed drive wasn't the
WD MyBook 1TB, it was a Maxtor Basics Desktop 500GB which is about
three years old.

The WD MyBook is the unit I hold responsible for shutting down my
Clickfree Automatic Backup, thus initiating my descent into backup
hell.

I uncased the Maxtor and tested it in a hard drive dock, and although
spinning and free of any clicks it was absent from the drive list in
'My Computer'.  Disk Management couldn't find it either.  I took it to
a data recovery service for a quote (not worth $600 for two months of
uninspired unbacked-up work IMO) who said that many Maxtors Basics
have a firmware fault lying dormant within, just waiting for some
little stimulus like a bad shutdown to push them over the edge.  The
fault prevents them from initializing on startup.  Maxtor users be
warned.

This year is the first in my time as a computer user that I've had any
total hard drive failures, and now I've had two (the Maxtor and my
netbook).  In the past one or two of my drives had developed bad
sectors, but remained in service once I'd run error detection and
mapped the bad sectors out of use.

regards, Anthony



--
Being old doesn't seem so old now that I'm old.

--
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the directions.


Re: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives, , Dryers

2012-08-01 Thread John Sessoms

From: Godfrey DiGiorgi


My experience with WD drives is not great either. But not the drives
themselves, the enclosures. Once I ditched the 2T RAID case and moved
the drives into a third party RAID case, they became completely
reliable.

I don't know what crapware comes on any drive. Any drive I buy I
immediately reformat without looking at what's on it. I have
everything I need to manage drives built into OS X, don't want any of
that junk.



I have a stack of old failed IDE hard-drives waiting to go to the 
crusher. Wake County (where I live) has a collection point that takes 
old computer hardware  includes secure destruction for old hard-drives. 
This discussion prompted me to take a look at them.


Sure enough, all of them are Western Digital.

Plus, now I won't be able to rest until I've pulled out all of my older 
USB drives and exercised them, just to make sure none of them has failed 
since I last used them.


I've already found that I misplaced one of the power (mains) cords. 
Fortunately the cord from my D-BC50 battery charger fits.


--
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the directions.


Re: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives, , Dryers

2012-08-01 Thread Godfrey DiGiorgi
On Wed, Aug 1, 2012 at 10:23 AM, John Sessoms jsessoms...@nc.rr.com wrote:
 I have a stack of old failed IDE hard-drives waiting to go to the crusher.
 Wake County (where I live) has a collection point that takes old computer
 hardware  includes secure destruction for old hard-drives. This discussion
 prompted me to take a look at them.

 Sure enough, all of them are Western Digital.

 Plus, now I won't be able to rest until I've pulled out all of my older USB
 drives and exercised them, just to make sure none of them has failed since I
 last used them.

 I've already found that I misplaced one of the power (mains) cords.
 Fortunately the cord from my D-BC50 battery charger fits.

I went on a round of that stuff about two months ago, when my partner
asked if I had a small, spare drive that I could afford to give away.
After emptying the cabinet and finding I had 27 hard drives (!) with
capacities from 40G to 320G sitting untouched for at least two years,
I plugged in each one in turn to see if it would boot up. Every single
one of them did. (To keep from losing or mixing up power cords, I tag
and bag them, tagging the drives they go with identically. Happily, I
was sensible when buying all those drives: there are just four types
of power supplies that can interchange across all the drives.)

-- 
Godfrey
  godfreydigiorgi.posterous.com

-- 
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the directions.


RE: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives , Dryers

2012-08-01 Thread John Coyle
My Maxtor also played up last month, and I too bought a WD MyBook replacement!
Fortunately, I don't use any backup software that was mangled by the WD 
software, so the
transfer of data was only painful in that about 10% of the image files were 
showing bad
reads:  I used the old DOS command XCOPY to do the transfer, worked very well 
in the
background.  I was also lucky (or well enough organised!) to have a second copy 
of the
image files so that I was able to replace those that showed bad reads - nothing 
lost in
the long run.
The only issue I have now is that another external HDD now gets lost from My 
Computer
occasionally and has to be remounted every now and then - possibly the firmware 
in the
MyBook is interfering with it, but it's no biggy.
The Maxtor now seems to be Ok, and I will use it for temporary file creation 
where
necessary: can't rely on it for long term storage, of course.


John Coyle
Brisbane, Australia



-Original Message-
From: pdml-boun...@pdml.net [mailto:pdml-boun...@pdml.net] On Behalf Of Anthony 
Farr
Sent: Wednesday, 1 August 2012 1:01 PM
To: Pentax-Discuss Mail List
Subject: Re: OT - Backups  Cockups, Netbooks  MyBooks, Hard Drives , Dryers

To all who've responded, thank you for the sympathetic comments.  I guess I was 
correct to
believe that PDMLers would find data backup to be a topic close to their own 
hearts, and
that a saga about it would find interested readers.

Something that I should point out is that the failed drive wasn't the WD MyBook 
1TB, it
was a Maxtor Basics Desktop 500GB which is about three years old.

The WD MyBook is the unit I hold responsible for shutting down my Clickfree 
Automatic
Backup, thus initiating my descent into backup hell.

I uncased the Maxtor and tested it in a hard drive dock, and although spinning 
and free of
any clicks it was absent from the drive list in 'My Computer'.  Disk Management 
couldn't
find it either.  I took it to a data recovery service for a quote (not worth 
$600 for two
months of uninspired unbacked-up work IMO) who said that many Maxtors Basics 
have a
firmware fault lying dormant within, just waiting for some little stimulus like 
a bad
shutdown to push them over the edge.  The fault prevents them from initializing 
on
startup.  Maxtor users be warned.

This year is the first in my time as a computer user that I've had any total 
hard drive
failures, and now I've had two (the Maxtor and my netbook).  In the past one or 
two of my
drives had developed bad sectors, but remained in service once I'd run error 
detection and
mapped the bad sectors out of use.

regards, Anthony

--
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the
directions.


-- 
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the directions.


Re: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives , Dryers

2012-08-01 Thread Brian Walters

Quoting John Coyle jco...@iinet.net.au:

My Maxtor also played up last month, and I too bought a WD MyBook  
replacement!
Fortunately, I don't use any backup software that was mangled by the  
WD software, so the
transfer of data was only painful in that about 10% of the image  
files were showing bad
reads:  I used the old DOS command XCOPY to do the transfer, worked  
very well in the
background.  I was also lucky (or well enough organised!) to have a  
second copy of the
image files so that I was able to replace those that showed bad  
reads - nothing lost in

the long run.
The only issue I have now is that another external HDD now gets lost  
from My Computer
occasionally and has to be remounted every now and then - possibly  
the firmware in the

MyBook is interfering with it, but it's no biggy.




That's started to happen with my 1.5 TB WD external drive.  My laptop  
won't allocate it a drive letter on boot and I have to go into 'Disk  
Management' to allocate a drive letter manually every time I need to  
use it.


Not sure if its an OS issue (Vista) or a problem with the drive.



Cheers

Brian

++
Brian Walters
Western Sydney Australia
http://lyons-ryan.org/southernlight/


The Maxtor now seems to be Ok, and I will use it for temporary file  
creation where

necessary: can't rely on it for long term storage, of course.


John Coyle
Brisbane, Australia



-Original Message-
From: pdml-boun...@pdml.net [mailto:pdml-boun...@pdml.net] On Behalf  
Of Anthony Farr

Sent: Wednesday, 1 August 2012 1:01 PM
To: Pentax-Discuss Mail List
Subject: Re: OT - Backups  Cockups, Netbooks  MyBooks, Hard Drives  
, Dryers


To all who've responded, thank you for the sympathetic comments.  I  
guess I was correct to
believe that PDMLers would find data backup to be a topic close to  
their own hearts, and

that a saga about it would find interested readers.

Something that I should point out is that the failed drive wasn't  
the WD MyBook 1TB, it

was a Maxtor Basics Desktop 500GB which is about three years old.

The WD MyBook is the unit I hold responsible for shutting down my  
Clickfree Automatic

Backup, thus initiating my descent into backup hell.

I uncased the Maxtor and tested it in a hard drive dock, and  
although spinning and free of
any clicks it was absent from the drive list in 'My Computer'.  Disk  
Management couldn't
find it either.  I took it to a data recovery service for a quote  
(not worth $600 for two
months of uninspired unbacked-up work IMO) who said that many  
Maxtors Basics have a
firmware fault lying dormant within, just waiting for some little  
stimulus like a bad
shutdown to push them over the edge.  The fault prevents them from  
initializing on

startup.  Maxtor users be warned.

This year is the first in my time as a computer user that I've had  
any total hard drive
failures, and now I've had two (the Maxtor and my netbook).  In the  
past one or two of my
drives had developed bad sectors, but remained in service once I'd  
run error detection and

mapped the bad sectors out of use.

regards, Anthony

--
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above  
and follow the

directions.


--
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above  
and follow the directions.



--
Cheers

Brian

++
Brian Walters
Western Sydney Australia
http://lyons-ryan.org/southernlight/



--
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the directions.


RE: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives , Dryers

2012-07-31 Thread John Sessoms
This is such a heart-warming story for me. It makes me glad knowing that 
I'm not the only person on earth that computers hate.


I will never buy another Western digital hard-drive, and especially 
never another MyBook.


Several years ago, I bought a couple of MyBook drives (340GB  500GB) 
because they seemed to be really inexpensive. I found out instead that 
they're just really CHEAP (Of poor quality; inferior; Worthy of no 
respect; vulgar or contemptible). There just don't seem to be enough 
low, vulgar synonyms for *PIECE OF SHIT* to describe MyBook power supplies.


The only positive thing I can say about them is Windoze-XP didn't seem 
to have any problem blowing away the pre-installed CRAPWARE.


I wish I had an answer for making folders sharable in Vista, but the 
only Vista computer I have has only one shared folder  all of the 
contents/sub-folders were auto-magically shared as well.


From: Anthony Farr


Backups, to me, originally meant CDs, then DVDs.  But doubts were
raised about the permanence of optical media, and my backup load was
too large to periodically refresh everything, so I moved to hard
drives.  A couple of years ago I saw a product called Clickfree
Automatic Backup, which is a small device placed in the usb cable
between a computer on a wifi network and an external hard drive.  With
a little bit of software running on each computer in the network,
they'd all be periodically backed up with no attention required.
Great!  And in all honesty it worked a treat.  My son and I had all
our data secured across 3 computers.

But... and there's always a 'but', isn't there, the time came when my
500GB drive wasn't a big enough repository, so I got a 1TB WD MyBook,
and my troubles began.  Although there was nothing wrong with the
MyBook, it had its own backup software, didn't it.  No worries, thinks
I, I'll just delete it from the drive.  I don't want it, didn't ask
for it and won't ever use it, so why not?  The answer to 'why not?'
was that WD had put the backup software on a fixed partition, and all
my subsequent research on forum after forum informed me that the
partition resists every attempt at deletion or reformatting.
Bastards!

Never mind, thinks I, I'll just ignore it.

But... a week or two after the MyBook went into service I noticed that
backups had ceased to occur on schedule.  Then I noticed that the
Clickfree icon in 'My Computer' had gone plain, when it should appear
as a logo.  Uh oh.  Looking into it I found that the device, which
came filled with installation files and firmware and such, was empty.
The Clickfree help desk was great, I couldn't ask for better.  They
gave me a link to download the files needed to reflash the firmware,
but to no avail.  Then they emailed the files to me to ensure that I
had uncorrupted copies of them.  Still no success.  So without any
hesitation they sent me a new device.  And that's where the Clickfree
story ends for the moment, because it seemed to me that the MyBook had
killed the Clickfree, and I wasn't about to give it a second chance.

Now I was back to doing manual backups.  No way was I going to use the
WD backup software.  I would plug the Mybook into my netbook computer
and send to it, over my home network, the new files and changes from
each computer .  Even at 54Mb/sec it was quicker than doing a disk to
disk copy on one computer, because the source computer only had to
read the filefrom its disk, and the destination computer only had to
write the fileto its disk.  Doing the job on one computer leads to a
lot of disk swapping and appallingly slow copy and paste times.  It
was a perfect solution until about two months ago when I took the
netbook on a long car trip.  At the end of the journey I found that
I'd forgotten to shut it down, it was only on standby which doesn't
safely park the hard drive's read/write heads.  Soon afterwards it
developed the faintest of clicks.  Soon after that it crashed and has
been out of service since.  My backup strategy had been derailed.

Fast forward to last week.  It was cold, so our heaters were cranked
up to full power.  It was a wet, grey day so the family was inside
using televisions and Nintendo Wiis and computers and all the
accessories that go with those things.  The kettle was on to brew a
pot of tea.  The washing machine was in mid-load.  Then... my dear
wife, who knew not what she was about to do, started the clothes
dryer.  Everything went very quiet for half a second, then our son
complained about 'unsaved progress', but no harm was done, or so I
thought.

I was wrong.  The external hard drive on my computer, where I keep my
documents because they're safer there than in a laptop's internal
drive, was gone from the drive list in 'My Computer'.  The unexpected
shutdown had prematurely ended its life, and I'd lost all my new files
and changes of the last two months, because I hadn't put a new backup
process into place.  The only positive spin I can put on it is that
I've been in a 

Re: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives , Dryers

2012-07-31 Thread Joseph McAllister
Ditto on Macintosh computers.

Using one gig out of the box as a backup one finds out that attaching through a 
powered hub creates a hard drive that won't wake up for Retrospect, which makes 
for no backup. When asleep, if it doesn't wake up fast enough for Retrospect, 
which reports it to the OS as being missing, so it is unmounted by the OS. It's 
a faulty combination of firmware and non-erasable software that makes it 
unreliable for anything other than normal storage.

It still sits on the shelf, waiting for some day that I may want to use it for 
something else. All of my other drives are connected the same way, and work 
reliably, or as reliable as any hard drive. I keep 5 TB of unused spares on 
standby (2,2,1).


On Jul 31, 2012, at 03:17 , John Sessoms wrote:

 This is such a heart-warming story for me. It makes me glad knowing that I'm 
 not the only person on earth that computers hate.
 
 I will never buy another Western digital hard-drive, and especially never 
 another MyBook.
 
 Several years ago, I bought a couple of MyBook drives (340GB  500GB) because 
 they seemed to be really inexpensive. I found out instead that they're just 
 really CHEAP (Of poor quality; inferior; Worthy of no respect; vulgar or 
 contemptible). There just don't seem to be enough low, vulgar synonyms for 
 *PIECE OF SHIT* to describe MyBook power supplies.
 
 The only positive thing I can say about them is Windoze-XP didn't seem to 
 have any problem blowing away the pre-installed CRAPWARE.
 
 I wish I had an answer for making folders sharable in Vista, but the only 
 Vista computer I have has only one shared folder  all of the 
 contents/sub-folders were auto-magically shared as well.
 
 From: Anthony Farr
 
 Backups, to me, originally meant CDs, then DVDs.  But doubts were
 raised about the permanence of optical media, and my backup load was
 too large to periodically refresh everything, so I moved to hard
 drives.  A couple of years ago I saw a product called Clickfree
 Automatic Backup, which is a small device placed in the usb cable
 between a computer on a wifi network and an external hard drive.  With
 a little bit of software running on each computer in the network,
 they'd all be periodically backed up with no attention required.
 Great!  And in all honesty it worked a treat.  My son and I had all
 our data secured across 3 computers.
 
 But... and there's always a 'but', isn't there, the time came when my
 500GB drive wasn't a big enough repository, so I got a 1TB WD MyBook,
 and my troubles began.  Although there was nothing wrong with the
 MyBook, it had its own backup software, didn't it.  No worries, thinks
 I, I'll just delete it from the drive.  I don't want it, didn't ask
 for it and won't ever use it, so why not?  The answer to 'why not?'
 was that WD had put the backup software on a fixed partition, and all
 my subsequent research on forum after forum informed me that the
 partition resists every attempt at deletion or reformatting.
 Bastards!
 
 Never mind, thinks I, I'll just ignore it.


-- 
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the directions.


Re: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives , Dryers

2012-07-31 Thread Brian Walters

Quoting John Sessoms jsessoms...@nc.rr.com:

This is such a heart-warming story for me. It makes me glad knowing  
that I'm not the only person on earth that computers hate.


I will never buy another Western digital hard-drive, and especially  
never another MyBook.


Several years ago, I bought a couple of MyBook drives (340GB   
500GB) because they seemed to be really inexpensive. I found out  
instead that they're just really CHEAP (Of poor quality; inferior;  
Worthy of no respect; vulgar or contemptible). There just don't seem  
to be enough low, vulgar synonyms for *PIECE OF SHIT* to describe  
MyBook power supplies.





My experience with WD externals is similar.  The first MyBook died  
after about 2 years of service but I haven't thrown it out yet - I  
might rip the drive out of the casing and fit it into a powered drive  
case to see if there's any life left.  I then bought two WD  
Essentials.  The first one's power adapter died twice (replaced once  
under warranty) and it's currently working in a third party powered  
case after the built in power supply died.  The second one seems to  
work when it wants to, which doesn't always coincide with when I want  
it to.


I haven't any experience with other brands so maybe this behaviour is  
just par for the course.


Sorry I can't help with your problem, Anthony.


Cheers

Brian

++
Brian Walters
Western Sydney Australia
http://lyons-ryan.org/southernlight/




The only positive thing I can say about them is Windoze-XP didn't  
seem to have any problem blowing away the pre-installed CRAPWARE.


I wish I had an answer for making folders sharable in Vista, but  
the only Vista computer I have has only one shared folder  all of  
the contents/sub-folders were auto-magically shared as well.


From: Anthony Farr


Backups, to me, originally meant CDs, then DVDs.  But doubts were
raised about the permanence of optical media, and my backup load was
too large to periodically refresh everything, so I moved to hard
drives.  A couple of years ago I saw a product called Clickfree
Automatic Backup, which is a small device placed in the usb cable
between a computer on a wifi network and an external hard drive.  With
a little bit of software running on each computer in the network,
they'd all be periodically backed up with no attention required.
Great!  And in all honesty it worked a treat.  My son and I had all
our data secured across 3 computers.

But... and there's always a 'but', isn't there, the time came when my
500GB drive wasn't a big enough repository, so I got a 1TB WD MyBook,
and my troubles began.  Although there was nothing wrong with the
MyBook, it had its own backup software, didn't it.  No worries, thinks
I, I'll just delete it from the drive.  I don't want it, didn't ask
for it and won't ever use it, so why not?  The answer to 'why not?'
was that WD had put the backup software on a fixed partition, and all
my subsequent research on forum after forum informed me that the
partition resists every attempt at deletion or reformatting.
Bastards!

Never mind, thinks I, I'll just ignore it.

But... a week or two after the MyBook went into service I noticed that
backups had ceased to occur on schedule.  Then I noticed that the
Clickfree icon in 'My Computer' had gone plain, when it should appear
as a logo.  Uh oh.  Looking into it I found that the device, which
came filled with installation files and firmware and such, was empty.
The Clickfree help desk was great, I couldn't ask for better.  They
gave me a link to download the files needed to reflash the firmware,
but to no avail.  Then they emailed the files to me to ensure that I
had uncorrupted copies of them.  Still no success.  So without any
hesitation they sent me a new device.  And that's where the Clickfree
story ends for the moment, because it seemed to me that the MyBook had
killed the Clickfree, and I wasn't about to give it a second chance.

Now I was back to doing manual backups.  No way was I going to use the
WD backup software.  I would plug the Mybook into my netbook computer
and send to it, over my home network, the new files and changes from
each computer .  Even at 54Mb/sec it was quicker than doing a disk to
disk copy on one computer, because the source computer only had to
read the filefrom its disk, and the destination computer only had to
write the fileto its disk.  Doing the job on one computer leads to a
lot of disk swapping and appallingly slow copy and paste times.  It
was a perfect solution until about two months ago when I took the
netbook on a long car trip.  At the end of the journey I found that
I'd forgotten to shut it down, it was only on standby which doesn't
safely park the hard drive's read/write heads.  Soon afterwards it
developed the faintest of clicks.  Soon after that it crashed and has
been out of service since.  My backup strategy had been derailed.

Fast forward to last week.  It was cold, so our heaters were cranked
up to 

Re: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives , Dryers

2012-07-31 Thread steve harley

on 2012-07-31 15:40 Brian Walters wrote

My experience with WD externals is similar.


i have a 1GB WD dual drive RAID unit; it's still working, but it's noisy and 
RAID 0 performance rarely outweighs the potential for failure for me, so it 
sits idle; it was remarkably cheap for a fast Firewire 800 drive at the time, 
so it got past my dislike of manufacturer-packaged drives




--
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the directions.


Re: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives , Dryers

2012-07-31 Thread Anthony Farr
To all who've responded, thank you for the sympathetic comments.  I
guess I was correct to believe that PDMLers would find data backup to
be a topic close to their own hearts, and that a saga about it would
find interested readers.

Something that I should point out is that the failed drive wasn't the
WD MyBook 1TB, it was a Maxtor Basics Desktop 500GB which is about
three years old.

The WD MyBook is the unit I hold responsible for shutting down my
Clickfree Automatic Backup, thus initiating my descent into backup
hell.

I uncased the Maxtor and tested it in a hard drive dock, and although
spinning and free of any clicks it was absent from the drive list in
'My Computer'.  Disk Management couldn't find it either.  I took it to
a data recovery service for a quote (not worth $600 for two months of
uninspired unbacked-up work IMO) who said that many Maxtors Basics
have a firmware fault lying dormant within, just waiting for some
little stimulus like a bad shutdown to push them over the edge.  The
fault prevents them from initializing on startup.  Maxtor users be
warned.

This year is the first in my time as a computer user that I've had any
total hard drive failures, and now I've had two (the Maxtor and my
netbook).  In the past one or two of my drives had developed bad
sectors, but remained in service once I'd run error detection and
mapped the bad sectors out of use.

regards, Anthony

-- 
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the directions.


Re: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives , Dryers

2012-07-31 Thread Christine Aguila
hear, hear on the crapware on a WD external drive.  Had one drive with the 
smart ware and some how I found a way to by pass it.  Couldn't figure out how 
to get it to work--but that's because the smartware back-up software was really 
crapware.  Hope you get stuff up and running nicely, Anthony.  


Cheers, Christine


On Jul 31, 2012, at 4:48 PM, Joseph McAllister pentax...@mac.com wrote:

 Ditto on Macintosh computers.
 
 Using one gig out of the box as a backup one finds out that attaching through 
 a powered hub creates a hard drive that won't wake up for Retrospect, which 
 makes for no backup. When asleep, if it doesn't wake up fast enough for 
 Retrospect, which reports it to the OS as being missing, so it is unmounted 
 by the OS. It's a faulty combination of firmware and non-erasable software 
 that makes it unreliable for anything other than normal storage.
 
 It still sits on the shelf, waiting for some day that I may want to use it 
 for something else. All of my other drives are connected the same way, and 
 work reliably, or as reliable as any hard drive. I keep 5 TB of unused spares 
 on standby (2,2,1).
 
 
 On Jul 31, 2012, at 03:17 , John Sessoms wrote:
 
 This is such a heart-warming story for me. It makes me glad knowing that I'm 
 not the only person on earth that computers hate.
 
 I will never buy another Western digital hard-drive, and especially never 
 another MyBook.
 
 Several years ago, I bought a couple of MyBook drives (340GB  500GB) 
 because they seemed to be really inexpensive. I found out instead that 
 they're just really CHEAP (Of poor quality; inferior; Worthy of no respect; 
 vulgar or contemptible). There just don't seem to be enough low, vulgar 
 synonyms for *PIECE OF SHIT* to describe MyBook power supplies.
 
 The only positive thing I can say about them is Windoze-XP didn't seem to 
 have any problem blowing away the pre-installed CRAPWARE.
 
 I wish I had an answer for making folders sharable in Vista, but the only 
 Vista computer I have has only one shared folder  all of the 
 contents/sub-folders were auto-magically shared as well.
 
 From: Anthony Farr
 
 Backups, to me, originally meant CDs, then DVDs.  But doubts were
 raised about the permanence of optical media, and my backup load was
 too large to periodically refresh everything, so I moved to hard
 drives.  A couple of years ago I saw a product called Clickfree
 Automatic Backup, which is a small device placed in the usb cable
 between a computer on a wifi network and an external hard drive.  With
 a little bit of software running on each computer in the network,
 they'd all be periodically backed up with no attention required.
 Great!  And in all honesty it worked a treat.  My son and I had all
 our data secured across 3 computers.
 
 But... and there's always a 'but', isn't there, the time came when my
 500GB drive wasn't a big enough repository, so I got a 1TB WD MyBook,
 and my troubles began.  Although there was nothing wrong with the
 MyBook, it had its own backup software, didn't it.  No worries, thinks
 I, I'll just delete it from the drive.  I don't want it, didn't ask
 for it and won't ever use it, so why not?  The answer to 'why not?'
 was that WD had put the backup software on a fixed partition, and all
 my subsequent research on forum after forum informed me that the
 partition resists every attempt at deletion or reformatting.
 Bastards!
 
 Never mind, thinks I, I'll just ignore it.
 
 
 -- 
 PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
 PDML@pdml.net
 http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
 to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
 the directions.
 


-- 
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the directions.


Re: OT - Backups Cockups, Netbooks MyBooks, Hard Drives , Dryers

2012-07-31 Thread David Mann
On Jul 31, 2012, at 10:17 PM, John Sessoms wrote:

 This is such a heart-warming story for me. It makes me glad knowing that I'm 
 not the only person on earth that computers hate.

I think you'll find many friends in that club ;)  Although I managed to set up 
my new wireless router yesterday without too much gnashing.

 I will never buy another Western digital hard-drive, and especially never 
 another MyBook.

I have a couple of Seagate USB enclosures at the moment.  I've had one fail on 
me, which is why I now use two of them.  I haven't read anything into the 
failure as any brand will have failures occasionally so I need to be prepared 
for it.

 The only positive thing I can say about them is Windoze-XP didn't seem to 
 have any problem blowing away the pre-installed CRAPWARE.

First thing I did with my drives was reformat them to HFS+ (the Mac system) as 
I wanted to use them with Time Machine. All I want in a hard drive is bulk 
storage and I'd never allow them to install software on my computer.  If I 
couldn't prevent the installation I'd send the drive back.

 I wish I had an answer for making folders sharable in Vista, but the only 
 Vista computer I have has only one shared folder  all of the 
 contents/sub-folders were auto-magically shared as well.

I've had problems sharing in Windows, Mac and Linux.  I never seem to be able 
to get it to work consistently across multiple platforms so in the end I gave 
up and started using sneakernet.  It's pretty rare that I need to share 
anything these days.  Sharing printers was even worse.  The answer to that was 
to buy a laptop and carry it over to the printer :)

Cheers,
Dave


-- 
PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List
PDML@pdml.net
http://pdml.net/mailman/listinfo/pdml_pdml.net
to UNSUBSCRIBE from the PDML, please visit the link directly above and follow 
the directions.