Re: [agi] If aliens are monitoring us, our development of AGI might concern them

2008-11-26 Thread Bob Mottram
2008/11/26 Ed Porter [EMAIL PROTECTED]: As we learn just how common exoplanets are, the possibility that aliens have visited earth seems increasingly scientifically believable I'm not sure that alien visitation logically follows from the discovery of exoplanets. There have, in fact, been

Re: [agi] who is going to build the wittgenstein-ian AI filter to spot all the intellectual nonsense

2008-11-26 Thread Tudor Boloni
John, an impressive effort and wonderful direction, an analytical psychology of the Good in humans is sorely lacking and the focus on human sickness has had a monopoly for way too long and with untold negative consequences for society at large. assuming these meanings are correct (or will be fine

RE: [agi] If aliens are monitoring us, our development of AGI might concern them

2008-11-26 Thread Ed Porter
Bob, I share much of your skepticism, and many of your reasons for doubting. I have never experienced a UFO, but several people I have known and generally trusted, and who are not drug users or wackos, have claimed to have seen them directly. But I have a tremendous belief in the

[agi] The Future of AGI

2008-11-26 Thread Mike Tintner
You'll remember that I've been saying this for quite a while - now Kevin Kelly is saying it - and you'll be hearing a lot more of this http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/23/magazine/23wwln-future-t.html?_r=2sq=KEVIN%20KELLYst=csescp=1pagewanted=all Intelligence that is rationality without

Re: [agi] The Future of AGI

2008-11-26 Thread Ben Goertzel
Yes, but rationality without imagination and creativity is just a bogus straw man construct ... certainly, it is never what I mean when I talk about rationality ... Obsession with visual images is a whole other issue, though. It seems very obvious that an AI or alien organism with no visual

RE: [agi] The Future of AGI

2008-11-26 Thread Derek Zahn
Although a lot of AI-type research focuses on natural language interfaces between computer systems and their human users, computers have the ability to create visual images (which people can't do in real-time beyond gestures and facial expressions). Building computer systems that generate

Re: [agi] Re: JAGI submission

2008-11-26 Thread Matt Mahoney
--- On Tue, 11/25/08, Eliezer Yudkowsky [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Shane Legg, I don't mean to be harsh, but your attempt to link Kolmogorov complexity to intelligence is causing brain damage among impressionable youths. ( Link debunked here:

[agi] Re: If aliens are monitoring us, our development of AGI might concern them

2008-11-26 Thread Aleksei Riikonen
On Wed, Nov 26, 2008 at 5:07 PM, Ed Porter [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: In my own rather skeptical mind, if I were to make a wild guess I would currently put the probability of this at roughly at least one in ten, a large enough possibility that it should, at least, be considered in discussions of

RE: [agi] The Future of AGI

2008-11-26 Thread Robert Swaine
  Derek wrote: Building computer systems that generate pictures or videos as their way of communicating with us could be a very lucrative addition to computer applications that include cognitive models of their users (instead of focusing solely on generating natural language), because most of

Re: [agi] The Future of AGI

2008-11-26 Thread Mike Tintner
Ben, I should explain rationality - I mean it technically to cover (principally formal) language, logic and maths, including geometry. These are all the sign systems (inherited from the Greeks) which convert the world into more or less hard-edged, more or less abstract boxes - words, numbers,

Re: [agi] The Future of AGI

2008-11-26 Thread Trent Waddington
On Thu, Nov 27, 2008 at 1:43 AM, Mike Tintner [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Intelligence that is rationality without imagination, symbol manipulation without image manipulation, basically paper-based rather than screen-based (or consciousness-based), isn't intelligence at all. Although this may

Re: [agi] If aliens are monitoring us, our development of AGI might concern them

2008-11-26 Thread Bob Mottram
2008/11/26 Ed Porter [EMAIL PROTECTED]: I have never experienced a UFO, but several people I have known and generally trusted, and who are not drug users or wackos, have claimed to have seen them directly. belief (Y, foo) belief (X, credibility (Y) minimum credibility (X)) || dominance

RE: [agi] Re: If aliens are monitoring us, our development of AGI might concern them

2008-11-26 Thread Ed Porter
Aleksei Thanks for the link. It is interesting. Before I started hearing estimates for how common exoplanets were, I thought visits from aliens were a possibility, because I like to have an open mind, but an extremely small one. Now I believe it is a large enough probability that any

RE: [agi] If aliens are monitoring us, our development of AGI might concern them

2008-11-26 Thread Ed Porter
Translate into English, please. -Original Message- From: Bob Mottram [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, November 26, 2008 1:35 PM To: agi@v2.listbox.com Subject: Re: [agi] If aliens are monitoring us, our development of AGI might concern them 2008/11/26 Ed Porter [EMAIL

RE: [agi] The Future of AGI

2008-11-26 Thread Ed Porter
For decades I have always imagined that my dream machine would be able to not only talk to me in a conversational manner, but be able to generate real time video, like that in a coherent documentary or a movie, that is context appropriate to my discussion with it. I have always imagined that I

Re: [agi] The Future of AGI

2008-11-26 Thread Mark Waser
- Original Message - From: Mike Tintner [EMAIL PROTECTED] I should explain rationality No Mike, you *really* shouldn't. Repurposing words like you do merely leads to confusion not clarity . . . . Actual general intelligence in humans and animals is indisputably continuously

Re: [agi] The Future of AGI

2008-11-26 Thread Ben Goertzel
Hmmm... I don't think your conceptualization of rationality is particularly useful ... I do think formal reasoning is a useful category to distinguish, but this is much narrower than what you're somewhat arbitrarily lumping into the category of rationality I don't think it's sensible to say

Re: [agi] The Future of AGI

2008-11-26 Thread Vladimir Nesov
Formal reasoning can be thought of as medium, a canvas on which your imagination draws structures serving your goals best, that solve your problem or are simply aesthetically pleasing. There is an infinite number of possible formal derivations, theorems and proofs; limitations of formality of

Re: [agi] If aliens are monitoring us, our development of AGI might concern them

2008-11-26 Thread Eric Burton
What I want to emphasize is that our world is bathed in signals from superintelligent civilizations every day. The way you can put an antenna into the ground and use the Earth to conduct radio frequencies, these things are using the organization of space and time. The laws of physics and the

RE: [agi] If aliens are monitoring us, our development of AGI might concern them

2008-11-26 Thread Ed Porter
What evidence, other than your thoughts when using drugs, do you have for such statements? -Original Message- From: Eric Burton [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, November 26, 2008 5:22 PM To: agi@v2.listbox.com Subject: Re: [agi] If aliens are monitoring us, our development of

Re: [agi] If aliens are monitoring us, our development of AGI might concern them

2008-11-26 Thread Eric Burton
Thoughts are surely a subset of felt experience. The contact experiences reliably induced by committed doses of for instance psilocibin are objective, not subjective events! They are breaches in consensus reality, they mutate it. I don't know the source of the information I've received when