[android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-05 Thread dirk
Hold on a minute. I really don't care the least bit about underlying code, that is, the XML that's generated by a really good design tool. Saying you should have to learn the XML (in this case) is like saying you have to learn the bytecode that's generated from the java code. Sure, you always need

Re: [android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-05 Thread Daniel Drozdzewski
...with a small difference that XML was designed to be human readable but also for machines, while the bytecode never meant to be human readable. On Tue, Apr 5, 2011 at 7:19 AM, dirk dhaa...@gmail.com wrote: Hold on a minute. I really don't care the least bit about underlying code, that is, the

[android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-05 Thread Craigbtx
I agree with Dirk and others. After using Microsofts development environment, Visual Studio and asp.net for me, there is no reason to code database connections, html tables of data etc., sql update, delete and insert commands. If you know them that is great and it is helpful. But by having a full

[android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-05 Thread nation-x
I lol'd... On Apr 5, 8:25 am, Craigbtx craig...@austin.rr.com wrote: I agree with Dirk and others. After using Microsofts development environment, Visual Studio and asp.net for me, there is no reason to code database connections, html tables of data etc., sql update, delete and insert

Re: [android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-05 Thread Chris Stewart
I lol'd... +1 -- Chris Stewart http://chriswstewart.com On Tue, Apr 5, 2011 at 11:30 AM, nation-x shawn.payme...@gmail.com wrote: I lol'd... On Apr 5, 8:25 am, Craigbtx craig...@austin.rr.com wrote: I agree with Dirk and others. After using Microsofts development environment, Visual

Re: [android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-05 Thread Chris Stewart
At the end of the day, it comes down to an allocation of resources on Google's part. I'd much rather have them spending time innovating Android, it's APIs, the Android Market, and so forth, rather than building a better GUI editor because people don't want to put in the time to learn how to do

Re: [android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-05 Thread TreKing
Comparing ADT to Visual Studio is a little ridiculous. Using a .Net language like C# in VS to design a GUI is a thing of beauty, but it's gotten to its current point of sophistication after *a lot* of time, money, and engineering effort. This is one of Microsoft's premier products and they've been

[android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-05 Thread Leo
I agree with the sentiment of the post.There is definitely a lot of scope for improvment in layouts. If layout designing was on par with other technologies it would make life easy for a lot of developers. It is not just a matter of learning xml. I know xml fully well, and haven't used the gui

Re: [android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-05 Thread Dianne Hackborn
On Tue, Apr 5, 2011 at 10:15 AM, Leo allway...@gmail.com wrote: It is not just a matter of learning xml. I know xml fully well, and haven't used the gui tool yet. I only create layouts with handwritten xml. But when you encounter two attributes like gravity and layout_gravity you scratch your

[android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-05 Thread jsera
Having developed for Android since the launch of the G1, and having spent the last 10-11 months writing Android apps full-time, the layouts aren't actually that bad. Actually, RelativeLayout isn't that bad. I've never had a layout simple enough for LinearLayout or FrameLayout, and having spent a

Re: [android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-05 Thread Xavier Ducrohet
Our layout editors in Eclipse have been somewhat low priority for a long time but we are now focusing some effort on it. You may have seen that ADT 10 includes a lot of new features and we have more coming for the next versions. We are working on: - better interactivity in the editor itself. -

[android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-05 Thread Leo
Is it possible to address the lack of examples in samples section on layouts in future releases? I spent two days trying to figure how to put 4 large images into a 2x2 grid for option selection in my first app that I am working on. Granted my UI experience is next to NIL but such things should be

Re: [android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-05 Thread Xavier Ducrohet
I'm sure this is possible. We would also like have templates in Eclipse so that you can create a new layout with some pre-built items arranged in different ways. We know that sometimes it's not easy to make the layouts do what you want and we are working on making this easier. Xav On Tue, Apr

[android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-04 Thread Mike dg
Maybe you should try a ListView instead. On Apr 4, 1:01 am, grndvl1 grnd...@gmail.com wrote: Why is it I spend more time dealing with the layout of items than the actual coding of the program?  The Eclipse Graphical Layout tool really blows as it has a ton of errors and can't handle simple

[android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-04 Thread Stephen Lebed
I've actually been very happy with the progress Google has made to the layout tools. It took a little while to get used to, but now I'm finding it very easy to arrange and rearrange design elements. Best, Stephen On Apr 3, 10:01 pm, grndvl1 grnd...@gmail.com wrote: Why is it I spend more time

[android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-04 Thread dirk
Coming from the Windows world where the tools are really top notch, I have to agree with the sentiment (if not the presentation) of grndvl1 point. Really there should be no need to have to know the XML if you have a good designer tool. That tool is improving for sure, but it still has a long way

[android-developers] Re: Android Layouts Are Horrible

2011-04-04 Thread Robert
Layout is part of development. Having tools to help with that are aids but should not be used as an excuse not to learn the underlying code. THe designer tools only generate the structures based on the rules programmed into them. You will always have a more detailed level of control by going to