Re: Fw: Quinn and Buck's articles

2003-09-07 Thread David Friedman
Dear Susan, The statements in this case are mostly oral talks, in other words, pilgrim notes in which case they don't have authority. The following authentic passage might be read to indicate that the Manifestation has always come from the East, but maybe it doesn't say that. It depends

Re: Fw: Quinn and Buck's articles

2003-09-06 Thread David Friedman
I thought there was a passage in Gleanings which states that all of the Prophets have come from the Holy Land. Of course, this may not preclude Messengers. Dear Matt, What's the Holy Land? Dear Susan, I think the piece from TDP p. 85 that Sandra just quoted answers this: THE BLESSED state of

Re: Fw: Quinn and Buck's articles

2003-09-05 Thread David Friedman
Dear Susan, I thought all Manifestations were supposed to come from the East. Am I misled about this? I think that is pretty much a Baha'i myth. The Qur'an says there is no people to whom a Prophet has not been sent. I presume that means the West as well as the East. Obviously 'Abdu'l-Baha's

Re: Fw: Quinn and Buck's articles

2003-09-05 Thread Smaneck
In a message dated 9/5/03 6:02:18 AM Pacific Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Obviously 'Abdu'l-Baha's statements should have authority, and I'm having difficulty seeing why His statements shouldn't be read to indicate that all Manifestations have come from the East. Dear David,

Re: Fw: Quinn and Buck's articles

2003-09-04 Thread Susan Maneck
I thought there was a passage in Gleanings which states that all of the Prophets have come from the Holy Land. Of course, this may not preclude Messengers. Dear Matt, What's the Holy Land? warmest, Susan -- You are subscribed to Baha'i Studies as: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] To