Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

Hi all, Let me try to disable the pre-commit job in JIRA: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/HADOOP-17798 In the past discussion, I agreed with Masatake. Let's use JIRA for background and design discussion, and GitHub PR for code review. > My concern is that still leaves multiple places to

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

@Wei-Chiu Chuang looks this is not concluded yet... Can we move forward..? On Thu, Jul 15, 2021 at 11:09 PM Brahma Reddy Battula wrote: > > I agree with Ahmed Hussein…Jira should not be used for number generation.. > > We can always revisit the jira to see useful discussion at one place… > >

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

I agree with Ahmed Hussein…Jira should not be used for number generation.. We can always revisit the jira to see useful discussion at one place… @wei-chu, +1 on proposal for cleaning the PR’s.. On Thu, 15 Jul 2021 at 9:15 PM, epa...@apache.org wrote: > > I usually use PR comments to discuss

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

> I usually use PR comments to discuss about the patch submitted. My concern is that still leaves multiple places to look in order to get a full picture of an issue. -Eric On Wednesday, July 14, 2021, 7:07:30 PM CDT, Masatake Iwasaki wrote: > - recently, JIRA became some sort of a

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

- recently, JIRA became some sort of a "number generator" with insufficient description/details as the developers and the reviewers spending more time discussing in the PR. JIRA issues contain useful information in the fields. We are leveraging them in development and release process. *

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

+1 for a review of the backlog!-Eric On Wednesday, July 14, 2021, 10:02:39 AM CDT, Wei-Chiu Chuang wrote: We have more than 400 open PRs. I would be happy to find a way to reduce that number to a more manageable size. Otherwise it just becomes another JIRA where issues are filed and

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

Ahmed has pinpointed my main concern with both JIRA and PR for the same issue.I often go back to older issues to try to understand the reasons behind the designs.It is somewhat cumbersome to try and follow discussions between JIRA and PRs.Thanks,-Eric On Wednesday, July 14, 2021, 9:50:47

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

We have more than 400 open PRs. I would be happy to find a way to reduce that number to a more manageable size. Otherwise it just becomes another JIRA where issues are filed and sunk to the bottom of black hole. A review session is a good idea. We can (1) decide on a date (2) sign up. (3) decide

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

Do you consider migrating Jira issues to Github issues? I am a little bit concerned that there are some committers who still prefer Jira-precommits over GitHub PR (P.S. I am not a committer). Their point is that Github-PR confuses them with discussions/comments being in two places rather than

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

not sure about stale PR closing; when you've a patch which is still pending review it's not that fun to have it closed. maybe better to have review sessions. I recall many, many years ago attempts to try and catch up with all outstanding patch reviews. On Wed, 14 Jul 2021 at 03:00, Akira

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

Thank you Wei-Chiu for starting the discussion, > 3. JIRA security I'm +1 to use private JIRA issues to handle vulnerabilities. > 5. Doc update +1, I build the document daily and it helps me fixing documents: https://aajisaka.github.io/hadoop-document/ It's great if the latest document is built

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

One more idea that I forgot to mention: We can have the Dependabot to automatically create a pull request whenever a vulnerability is discovered. On Wed, Jul 14, 2021 at 8:42 AM Wei-Chiu Chuang wrote: > So this is just up for discussion and welcome more brainstorming. I'm not > saying I'll go

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

So this is just up for discussion and welcome more brainstorming. I'm not saying I'll go ahead with adding them immediately :) Appreciate comments especially from those who have already used those tools and had success with them. On the GitHub add-ons, There are a number of GitHub apps that

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

Hi Wei-Chu, Thanks for sharing your experience working on other projects. The Jira related suggestions sound very useful. The extra fields work very good for us in our internal Jira system at Yahoo. In addition to your suggestions, is it possible revisit the labels/components in Jira. If we can

Re: [DISCUSS] Tips for improving productivity, workflow in the Hadoop project?

Here's another one: We can update the JIRA workflow and add more state. For example, Cassandra has "Review in Progress" and "Need Reviewer" states. INFRA-22049 On Tue, Jul 13, 2021 at 11:34 AM Wei-Chiu Chuang wrote: > I work on multiple