Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-28 Thread Andrew McGlashan
Hi, Chris Jones wrote: While your brute force decryption is running, how do you determine you have found the one key and decide it's time to stop? Among trillions of trillions, when do you know you've hit the jackpot? And what if you encrypted the result multiple times with a number of

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-28 Thread Jochen Schulz
Chris Jones: On Fri, Feb 27, 2009 at 08:34:25AM EST, Jochen Schulz wrote: This is a valid question! Depending on the encryption system in use, it cannot be answered satisfactorily. I'm not sure it's related to the encryption/decryption process. What I had in mind when I wrote the

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-28 Thread Eduardo M KALINOWSKI
Andrew McGlashan wrote: And what if you encrypted the result multiple times with a number of different keys? Security does not improve so much, actually. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meet-in-the-middle_attack -- Unless you love someone, nothing else makes any sense. --

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-28 Thread Emanoil Kotsev
hello, the discussion is really interesting and informative. there's just something I don't understand. Jeff Soules wrote: good.) In any case, with EncFS we're talking about a technological solution in which the encryption key is stored alongside the encrypted media, so whatever the

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-27 Thread Jochen Schulz
Chris Jones: I have a naive question. While your brute force decryption is running, how do you determine you have found the one key and decide it's time to stop? This is a valid question! Depending on the encryption system in use, it cannot be answered satisfactorily. If a one-time pad is

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-27 Thread Chris Jones
On Fri, Feb 27, 2009 at 08:34:25AM EST, Jochen Schulz wrote: Chris Jones: I have a naive question. While your brute force decryption is running, how do you determine you have found the one key and decide it's time to stop? This is a valid question! Depending on the encryption system

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-26 Thread Chris Jones
On Tue, Feb 24, 2009 at 12:56:00AM EST, Ron Johnson wrote: On 02/23/2009 08:43 PM, Javier wrote: [snip] As I also have read in the Wikipedia, it is reseonable to crack a 56bits DES, a 64bits AES if you have online access to the machine, and probably in the future it might be possible to

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-26 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/26/2009 05:34 PM, Chris Jones wrote: [snip] Sorry to revive and already dead thread .. I have a naive question. While your brute force decryption is running, how do you determine you have found the one key and decide it's time to stop? Among trillions of trillions, when do you know

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-26 Thread Chris Jones
On Thu, Feb 26, 2009 at 07:11:43PM EST, Ron Johnson wrote: On 02/26/2009 05:34 PM, Chris Jones wrote: I have a naive question. While your brute force decryption is running, how do you determine you have found the one key and decide it's time to stop? Among trillions of trillions, when

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-26 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/26/2009 06:51 PM, Chris Jones wrote: On Thu, Feb 26, 2009 at 07:11:43PM EST, Ron Johnson wrote: On 02/26/2009 05:34 PM, Chris Jones wrote: I have a naive question. While your brute force decryption is running, how do you determine you have found the one key and decide it's time to

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-26 Thread Chris Jones
On 02/26/2009 06:51 PM, Chris Jones wrote: On Thu, Feb 26, 2009 at 07:11:43PM EST, Ron Johnson wrote: On 02/26/2009 05:34 PM, Chris Jones wrote: Among trillions of trillions, when do you know you've hit the jackpot? When you can decrypt the document with it? You don't have access to the

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-26 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/26/2009 08:32 PM, Chris Jones wrote: On 02/26/2009 06:51 PM, Chris Jones wrote: On Thu, Feb 26, 2009 at 07:11:43PM EST, Ron Johnson wrote: On 02/26/2009 05:34 PM, Chris Jones wrote: Among trillions of trillions, when do you know you've hit the jackpot? When you can decrypt the

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-26 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/26/2009 08:42 PM, Ron Johnson wrote: On 02/26/2009 08:32 PM, Chris Jones wrote: [snip] Depending on what was encrypted, and given the time, I'm sure I'd be able to determine, one tentative key at a time, whether the output is gobbledygook or not.. But even if the original data was in

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-26 Thread owens
Original Message From: cjns1...@gmail.com To: debian-user@lists.debian.org Subject: Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack? Date: Thu, 26 Feb 2009 18:34:40 -0500 On Tue, Feb 24, 2009 at 12:56:00AM EST, Ron Johnson wrote: On 02/23/2009 08:43 PM, Javier wrote:

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-25 Thread Chris Jones
On Mon, Feb 23, 2009 at 07:53:54PM EST, Ron Johnson wrote: On 02/23/2009 06:12 PM, Chris Jones wrote: On Mon, Feb 23, 2009 at 02:34:26PM EST, Ron Johnson wrote: Given enough time, and resources, *nothing* is untouchable. It's just a matter of whether They think that the time-effort is worth

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-24 Thread Tzafrir Cohen
On Mon, Feb 23, 2009 at 03:43:06PM -0500, Celejar wrote: On Sun, 22 Feb 2009 20:10:57 -0600 Ron Johnson ron.l.john...@cox.net wrote: On 02/22/2009 07:03 PM, Javier wrote: ... And which is better, Blowfish or AES? AES. Source? Wikipedia just says: Blowfish provides a good

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-24 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/24/2009 02:36 AM, Tzafrir Cohen wrote: [snip] Anyway, the AES cipher is one that is very well studied. It has been implemented all over. Just about anybody have tried to attack it and yet there's no known practical attack on it. It performs well. So it is ^ That's

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-24 Thread owens
Original Message From: javu...@gmail.com To: debian-user@lists.debian.org Subject: Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack? Date: Tue, 24 Feb 2009 03:31:51 +0100 ow...@netptc.net escribió: Original Message From: javu...@gmail.com To:

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-24 Thread owens
Original Message From: ron.l.john...@cox.net To: debian-user@lists.debian.org Subject: Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack? Date: Tue, 24 Feb 2009 04:27:31 -0600 On 02/24/2009 02:36 AM, Tzafrir Cohen wrote: [snip] Anyway, the AES cipher is one that is

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-24 Thread Jeff Soules
there's no known practical attack on it. It performs well. So it is ^ That's the word, of course... Any government that discovers a successful attack is going to keep quiet. Except in a certain side-channel sense -- any government that discovers a successful attack on

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-24 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/24/2009 09:50 AM, ow...@netptc.net wrote: [snip] And in fact there always has been suspicion in the crypto community that, in at least some of the ciphers (going back to the original DES) that the NSA had built in a trapdoor such that they could easily decrypt the message but anyone else,

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-24 Thread John Hasler
Ron Johnson writes: [An NSA backdoor in DES successors] would only be possible if The Government controlled the source code, or had an understanding with those who write closed-source code. The claim is stronger than that. It is that there are backdoors in the algorithms: weaknesses that

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-24 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/24/2009 12:59 PM, John Hasler wrote: Ron Johnson writes: [An NSA backdoor in DES successors] would only be possible if The Government controlled the source code, or had an understanding with those who write closed-source code. The claim is stronger than that. It is that there are

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-24 Thread owens
Original Message From: ron.l.john...@cox.net To: debian-user@lists.debian.org Subject: Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack? Date: Tue, 24 Feb 2009 12:47:15 -0600 On 02/24/2009 09:50 AM, ow...@netptc.net wrote: [snip] And in fact there always has been

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-24 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/24/2009 03:35 PM, ow...@netptc.net wrote: [snip] Ron et al Actually this was the case with the DES; the NSA put out a RFP and worked with the potential vendors quite closely during the development. IBM (Tuchman and Myers) eventually won the bid. I attended a week-long security seminar

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/23/2009 01:28 AM, Jordi Gutiérrez Hermoso wrote: 2009/2/21 Javier javu...@gmail.com: I'm actually using encfs to protect my sensitive data, Eh... http://xkcd.com/538/ That's known as Rubber Hose Decryption. -- Ron Johnson, Jr. Jefferson LA USA The feeling of disgust at

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Javier
Ron Johnson escribió: On 02/23/2009 01:28 AM, Jordi Gutiérrez Hermoso wrote: 2009/2/21 Javier javu...@gmail.com: I'm actually using encfs to protect my sensitive data, Eh... http://xkcd.com/538/ That's known as Rubber Hose Decryption. Oh yes, but if he had the chance to scape,

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Javier
Jeff Soules escribió: Hi Javier, Thank you for your reply. Given the hypothetical (but all too possible) situation you describe, there are different considerations. Now imagine the worst situation, that a friend wants to protect his data from his corrupt dictatorial government

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Barclay, Daniel
Jeff Soules wrote: ... The most intrusive attacks, where an attacker has complete control of the user's machine (and can therefor modify EncFS, or FUSE, or the kernel itself) are not guarded against. Do not assume that encrypted files will protect your sensitive data if you enter your

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Jordi Gutiérrez Hermoso
2009/2/23 Javier javu...@gmail.com: The main point here is: if he is lucky enough, no police would enter into his house. Since this has become a tinfoil hat thread more than an encryption thread... My own personal solution to the problem has been this: my hard drive decryption password is 25

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/23/2009 09:26 AM, Javier wrote: Ron Johnson escribió: On 02/23/2009 01:28 AM, Jordi Gutiérrez Hermoso wrote: 2009/2/21 Javier javu...@gmail.com: I'm actually using encfs to protect my sensitive data, Eh... http://xkcd.com/538/ That's known as Rubber Hose Decryption. Oh yes,

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Celejar
On Sun, 22 Feb 2009 20:10:57 -0600 Ron Johnson ron.l.john...@cox.net wrote: On 02/22/2009 07:03 PM, Javier wrote: ... And which is better, Blowfish or AES? AES. Source? Wikipedia just says: Blowfish provides a good encryption rate in software and no effective cryptanalysis of it has

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Celejar
On Mon, 23 Feb 2009 00:06:02 -0500 Jeff Soules sou...@gmail.com wrote: Hi Javier, Thank you for your reply. Given the hypothetical (but all too possible) situation you describe, there are different considerations. Now imagine the worst situation, that a friend wants to protect his data

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Javier
Ron Johnson escribió: On 02/23/2009 09:26 AM, Javier wrote: Ron Johnson escribió: On 02/23/2009 01:28 AM, Jordi Gutiérrez Hermoso wrote: 2009/2/21 Javier javu...@gmail.com: I'm actually using encfs to protect my sensitive data, Eh... http://xkcd.com/538/ That's known as Rubber Hose

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Javier
Jordi Gutiérrez Hermoso escribió: 2009/2/23 Javier javu...@gmail.com: The main point here is: if he is lucky enough, no police would enter into his house. Since this has become a tinfoil hat thread more than an encryption thread... My own personal solution to the problem has been this: my

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Chris Jones
On Mon, Feb 23, 2009 at 02:34:26PM EST, Ron Johnson wrote: Given enough time, and resources, *nothing* is untouchable. It's just a matter of whether They think that the time-effort is worth being spent on *you*. Like, twenty times the estimated life of the universe.. a thousand times its mass

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread owens
Original Message From: javu...@gmail.com To: debian-user@lists.debian.org Subject: Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack? Date: Mon, 23 Feb 2009 23:53:27 +0100 Ron Johnson escribió: On 02/23/2009 09:26 AM, Javier wrote: Ron Johnson escribió: On 02/23/2009

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/23/2009 06:12 PM, Chris Jones wrote: On Mon, Feb 23, 2009 at 02:34:26PM EST, Ron Johnson wrote: Given enough time, and resources, *nothing* is untouchable. It's just a matter of whether They think that the time-effort is worth being spent on *you*. Like, twenty times the estimated life

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/23/2009 02:43 PM, Celejar wrote: On Sun, 22 Feb 2009 20:10:57 -0600 Ron Johnson ron.l.john...@cox.net wrote: On 02/22/2009 07:03 PM, Javier wrote: ... And which is better, Blowfish or AES? AES. Source? Wikipedia just says: Blowfish provides a good encryption rate in software and

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Celejar
On Tue, 24 Feb 2009 00:10:54 +0100 Javier javu...@gmail.com wrote: ... I've discovered that the program apg is very nice, it can produce lengthy but pronounceable pass phrases like these (40 readable chars, probably equivalent to a 256bit random one): Or pwgen. Celejar --

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Celejar
On Mon, 23 Feb 2009 18:59:56 -0600 Ron Johnson ron.l.john...@cox.net wrote: On 02/23/2009 02:43 PM, Celejar wrote: On Sun, 22 Feb 2009 20:10:57 -0600 Ron Johnson ron.l.john...@cox.net wrote: On 02/22/2009 07:03 PM, Javier wrote: ... And which is better, Blowfish or AES? AES.

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/23/2009 07:12 PM, Celejar wrote: [snip] But it's not a concern for full 16-round Blowfish, so is that really a problem? There is no effective cryptanalysis on the full-round version of Where there's smoke, there might be fire. [snip] So as I said, anything wrong with Twofish?

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Javier
ow...@netptc.net escribió: Original Message From: javu...@gmail.com To: debian-user@lists.debian.org Subject: Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack? Date: Mon, 23 Feb 2009 23:53:27 +0100 Ron Johnson escribió: On 02/23/2009 09:26 AM, Javier wrote: Ron

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Javier
Ron Johnson escribió: On 02/23/2009 06:12 PM, Chris Jones wrote: On Mon, Feb 23, 2009 at 02:34:26PM EST, Ron Johnson wrote: Given enough time, and resources, *nothing* is untouchable. It's just a matter of whether They think that the time-effort is worth being spent on *you*. Like, twenty

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-23 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/23/2009 08:43 PM, Javier wrote: [snip] As I also have read in the Wikipedia, it is reseonable to crack a 56bits DES, a 64bits AES if you have online access to the machine, and probably in the future it might be possible to crack a 128bits, even offline. But, a 256 one? It seems

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-22 Thread Jeff Soules
As Ron said, the problem you're describing is a little bit different from the one the man page talks about. The most intrusive attacks, where an attacker has complete control of the user's machine (and can therefor modify EncFS, or FUSE, or the kernel itself) are not guarded against. Do not

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-22 Thread Javier
Jeff Soules escribió: As Ron said, the problem you're describing is a little bit different from the one the man page talks about. The most intrusive attacks, where an attacker has complete control of the user's machine (and can therefor modify EncFS, or FUSE, or the kernel itself) are not

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-22 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/22/2009 07:03 PM, Javier wrote: [snip] Now imagine the worst situation, that a friend wants to protect his data from his corrupt dictatorial government, and he doesn't want to directly make the question here, because he is afraid. From your name, we can reasonably narrow it down. I.e.,

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-22 Thread Jeff Soules
Hi Javier, Thank you for your reply. Given the hypothetical (but all too possible) situation you describe, there are different considerations. Now imagine the worst situation, that a friend wants to protect his data from his corrupt dictatorial government Absolutely a possibility. There are

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-22 Thread Jordi Gutiérrez Hermoso
2009/2/21 Javier javu...@gmail.com: I'm actually using encfs to protect my sensitive data, Eh... http://xkcd.com/538/ - Jordi G. H. -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-user-requ...@lists.debian.org with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact listmas...@lists.debian.org

How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-21 Thread Javier
Sorry for my ignorance in this respect, I hope you can help me. I'm actually using encfs to protect my sensitive data, but this is what is said in the manual: The most intrusive attacks, where an attacker has complete control of the user’s machine (and can therefor modify EncFS, or FUSE, or the

Re: How to protect an encrypted file system for off-line attack?

2009-02-21 Thread Ron Johnson
On 02/21/2009 10:16 AM, Javier wrote: Sorry for my ignorance in this respect, I hope you can help me. I'm actually using encfs to protect my sensitive data, but this is what is said in the manual: The most intrusive attacks, where an attacker has complete control of the user’s machine (and can