Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-10 Thread Tom Chiverton
On 09/12/14 23:53, Jesse Nicholson wrote: You made it clear you're in maintenance mode and that this project is actually for corporate interest when you told me to hush and not use words that might upset adobe customers. You can say what you like about Adobe. I've been out spoken about what I

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-10 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, Even if AS / Flex isn't as popular as it once was we do still get quite a bit of interest. The Flex web site gets 3/4 of a million visits a year. There's been 20,000+ users of TourDdFlex over the past few months, the last SDK version has had more than 10,000+ installs of the SDK via the

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-10 Thread Dany Dhondt
Hi All, I'm convinced that there are a lot of developers out there who are still committed to Flex. Many of us (as I am) aren't nearly as good as you committers so we rely on you to keep up the fantastic work you're doing! Respect!! Dany Op 10 dec 2014 om 10:51 uur uur schreef Justin Mclean

RE: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-10 Thread Kessler CTR Mark J
is fantastic. Flex will continue to evolve over the years as the industry changes. -Mark -Original Message- From: Dany Dhondt [mailto:archeme...@mac.com] Sent: Wednesday, December 10, 2014 6:07 AM To: dev@flex.apache.org Subject: Re: Let's talk about Flex 5 Hi All, I'm convinced

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-10 Thread Nicholas Kwiatkowski
Here's the thing. Since Adobe donated Flex to the Apache Project, I've made a lot of money on the excellent work of many of my colleagues here at Apache. I've made enough to pay my mortgage, utilities, buy a new car and be very comfortable. Sure, the number of web projects involving Flex is on

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-10 Thread Nick Collins
Personally, I would see a lot of value to re-engineering the MXML components we're familiar with using Angular Directives or custom Polymer tags, then make the other services, such as data binding, HTTP services, etc., additional libraries that can be included as needed using Bower or something

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Gary Yang
Sent: Thu, 05 Jun 2014 6:56 AM Subject: Re: Let's talk about Flex 5 I don’t think that’s correct. Unless I’m mistaken, the AIR iOS runtime is written in Objective C from the get-go. (Although it might be written in C++. Dunno…) Whether or not it makes sense to rewrite the AIR iOS runtime

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jesse Nicholson
Subject: Re: Let's talk about Flex 5 I don’t think that’s correct. Unless I’m mistaken, the AIR iOS runtime is written in Objective C from the get-go. (Although it might be written in C++. Dunno…) Whether or not it makes sense to rewrite the AIR iOS runtime in Swift is an entirely

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread flex
within the framework itself so that you could reuse a lot of the web standards code that's out there. David -Original Message- From: Jesse Nicholson ascensionsyst...@gmail.com To: dev@flex.apache.org Sent: Tue, 09 Dec 2014 1:44 PM Subject: Re: Let's talk about Flex 5 My 2 cents

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Nicholas Kwiatkowski
that's out there. David -Original Message- From: Jesse Nicholson ascensionsyst...@gmail.com To: dev@flex.apache.org Sent: Tue, 09 Dec 2014 1:44 PM Subject: Re: Let's talk about Flex 5 My 2 cents is that the project should be focusing on moving away from a third-party, proprietary

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Gary Yang
ascensionsyst...@gmail.com To: dev@flex.apache.org Sent: Tue, 09 Dec 2014 1:44 PM Subject: Re: Let's talk about Flex 5 My 2 cents is that the project should be focusing on moving away from a third-party, proprietary and frankly dead platform. I'm also not sure what actionscript 4 has

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jesse Nicholson
that you could reuse a lot of the web standards code that's out there. David -Original Message- From: Jesse Nicholson ascensionsyst...@gmail.com To: dev@flex.apache.org Sent: Tue, 09 Dec 2014 1:44 PM Subject: Re: Let's talk about Flex 5 My 2 cents

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jesse Nicholson
Like I said I'm new here, I respect everyone, I don't mean to be the armchair expert at flex and the apache-flex community. But, perhaps part of the issues faced here is a lack of a clear goal for the future and a lack of a clear, independent identity, as a product and a team.

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jesse Nicholson
I forgot to mention something that I think is worth mentioning with regard to the debate of can pure JS/HTML do what the flash runtime can. To answer that, just look at Mozilla Shumway, a full blown AVM2 virtual machine written in pure JS. Too bad it didn't have some kind of AOT functionality.:)

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread OmPrakash Muppirala
The beauty of open source is that we don't have to first agree on a direction before we start. Folks are free to post their ideas and start working on what they think is the right path forward. If they can prove that it is a feasible path, others will start following them. FlexJS is there for

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Gary Yang
I understand, maybe Javascript is the future, I am not against it, the problem is now it is not working now. when javascript is ready, what is the difference between actionscript and javascript? For complex UI system, it has to be based on OOP/Modularization, never the syntax of a particular

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jeffry Houser
On 12/9/2014 4:23 PM, Jesse Nicholson wrote: I also disagree that the value of flex is an extension of Flash. I believe that's actually it's curse. It is a desert topping and a floor wax. ( http://www.break.com/video/ugc/snl-new-shimmer-commercial-704661 ) My perception is that reliance

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jesse Nicholson
Didn't you just publish a book to help people migrate away from Flex, implying that it's dead because it's stuck on flash? On Tue, Dec 9, 2014 at 5:00 PM, Jeffry Houser jef...@dot-com-it.com wrote: On 12/9/2014 4:23 PM, Jesse Nicholson wrote: I also disagree that the value of flex is an

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jesse Nicholson
https://www.lifeafterflex.com/AngularJSForFlexDevelopers/ That is you, right? On Tue, Dec 9, 2014 at 5:03 PM, Jesse Nicholson ascensionsyst...@gmail.com wrote: Didn't you just publish a book to help people migrate away from Flex, implying that it's dead because it's stuck on flash? On Tue,

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Alex Harui
My 10 cents below... On 12/9/14, 1:23 PM, Jesse Nicholson ascensionsyst...@gmail.com wrote: With all due respect Gary, I just finished making a project management application for a client that is pure HTML/JS and runs on all browsers. The application looks like the latest version of office, that

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jesse Nicholson
It's a bit sad to see these (or rather any) truths dismissed as FUD. Adobe abandoned this project, pulled flash support for what few mobile platforms it had left, dropped updating the flex ide, and has publicly stated in their roadmap that their future focus is HTML5/JS. But yeah, my comment that

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jeffry Houser
On 12/9/2014 5:03 PM, Jesse Nicholson wrote: Didn't you just publish a book I call it a training course, but there are books that are part of it. to help people migrate away from Flex It was intended as a compare/contrast between Flex and AngularJS. I don't expect anyone will migrate

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread jude
Hi Jesse, Welcome to the group. You're perspective is welcome. But one thing I'm sick of hearing and have to disagree with is the Flash is dead argument. If it's in use it's not dead. It's used by over 2 billion people and used regularly to create mobile AIR apps. The browser can't compete yet and

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jeffry Houser
On 12/9/2014 5:05 PM, Jesse Nicholson wrote: Adobe abandoned this project, From my perspective, Adobe has been very supportive of this project. I don't think it gets the manpower that it did when Flex was part of Adobe's long-term commercial vision to get the Developer crowd, but I

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jesse Nicholson
@Jude, tbh I skimmed over half of your post. I didn't say plugins are bad, at all, ever. Did you click the links I posted here? Did you see a full blown actionscript virtual machine in pure JS that emulates everything flash does in the browser? I'm not really sure there is anything more to say

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Alex Harui
Like Jude said, welcome to the group. Since you are new, you may have missed folks who occasionally ask if, for example Flash Player version N is going to stop running their existing Flex apps. These folks can have significant investments in large code bases and it would be very stressful and

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Gary Yang
Face the reality, the majority will mark their resume HTML5 developer after Apple said No Flash on Ipad, even they do not know what it means. the way I see it, Flex should fight with its advantages which is Flash Platform. there are too many javascript frameworks already. You can say

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Harbs
There are lots of advantages to Flex beyond Flash, and FlexJS is leveraging those advantages. FWIW, here’s my perspective from a while back, but it’s still relevant. http://printui.com/blog/2013/01/flex-flash/ Harbs On Dec 10, 2014, at 12:43 AM, Gary Yang flashflex...@gmail.com wrote: Face

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread OmPrakash Muppirala
On Tue, Dec 9, 2014 at 2:25 PM, Jesse Nicholson ascensionsyst...@gmail.com wrote: @Jude, tbh I skimmed over half of your post. Not cool. I think you should go back and read it because he makes a lot of sense. I didn't say plugins are bad, at all, ever. Did you click the links I posted

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Alain Ekambi
@Gary Yang. Cant agree more. The first time i heard about FlexJS (no offense to the work of the people working on it) I knew Flex is in a really bad position. Why would one use ActionScript to cross compile to JS ? The time Flex JS is mature to be 10% usable things like GWT, TypeScript, Dart

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jesse Nicholson
Exactly. No one wants to use a dead language for a dead platform to compile to javascript, when especially with Typescript, it's nearly syntaticaly identical to AS, but not targetting a dusty old dead platform. A one-time compilation of course to source should take place to translate this to

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jesse Nicholson
Okay so, you may have missed folks who occasionally ask if, for example Flash Player version N is going to stop running their existing Flex apps. These folks can have significant investments in large code bases and it would be very stressful and expensive from them to have to rush to get off of

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jesse Nicholson
It works in Chrome as well. But that doesn't matter. It's not full blown because it's not a complete product. Besides, its a stupid toy project meant to demonstrate running a fast VM inside a fast VM. His post is retarded, he's a flash developer in denial that his career path is over. Apparently

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Héctor A
Why should an hypothetical Flex 5 only care about JS? I don't get it, there are a lot of us who don't use Flash for the web ever (I know, JS is not just for the web, but outside of it it loses a lot of power). If you want to move away from Flash I'd say Haxe is way more convenient. On Tue, Dec 9,

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jesse Nicholson
How do I unsubscribe from the apache morticians of private corporate interest list? On Tue, Dec 9, 2014 at 6:01 PM, Jesse Nicholson ascensionsyst...@gmail.com wrote: It works in Chrome as well. But that doesn't matter. It's not full blown because it's not a complete product. Besides, its a

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread OmPrakash Muppirala
On Tue, Dec 9, 2014 at 3:03 PM, Jesse Nicholson ascensionsyst...@gmail.com wrote: How do I unsubscribe from the apache morticians of private corporate interest list? Step by step instructions are here: http://flex.apache.org/community-mailinglists.html Thanks, Om On Tue, Dec 9, 2014 at

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Alex Harui
On 12/9/14, 2:54 PM, Alain Ekambi jazzmatad...@gmail.com wrote: @Gary Yang. Cant agree more. Why would one use ActionScript to cross compile to JS ? Because there are millions of lines of existing AS and MXML code out there and those who want to reduce the cost of getting that code to run in

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Alain Ekambi
@Alex. Like I said before No offense to the work you guys put into FlexJS. From a technical point of view a fascinating effort. But the question is how do you plan to compete against stuff like GWT, Typescript, Dart ? Feel free to get going on the things in your list. I think I showed my work

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Alex Harui
On 12/9/14, 2:56 PM, Jesse Nicholson ascensionsyst...@gmail.com wrote: Okay so, you may have missed folks who occasionally ask if, for example Flash Player version N is going to stop running their existing Flex apps. These folks can have significant investments in large code bases and it

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Jesse Nicholson
You made it clear you're in maintenance mode and that this project is actually for corporate interest when you told me to hush and not use words that might upset adobe customers. I think the broken piece of garbage mail unsubscribe function might work this time (3rd time), so I probably won't see

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread Alex Harui
On 12/9/14, 3:48 PM, Alain Ekambi jazzmatad...@gmail.com wrote: @Alex. Like I said before No offense to the work you guys put into FlexJS. From a technical point of view a fascinating effort. But the question is how do you plan to compete against stuff like GWT, Typescript, Dart ? I don’t

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-12-09 Thread jude
Judging by the levels of understanding I've witnessed here... I don't think you came here to contribute to the project. I think you came here to vent. Let it out... At the end of the day I just want to create cool websites, apps and experiences. I don't care if Flash or AIR is popular or not.

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-06 Thread Gary Yang
but I guess we'll have to wait and continue to ask Adobe to work on it. David -Original Message- From: Harbs harbs.li...@gmail.com To: dev@flex.apache.org Sent: Thu, 05 Jun 2014 6:56 AM Subject: Re: Let's talk about Flex 5 I don’t think that’s correct. Unless I’m mistaken

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-05 Thread Harbs
Really? The only way I know of outputting ActionScript for iOS is using AIR for iOS which is just a swf with an embedded runtime. On Jun 5, 2014, at 4:26 AM, f...@dfguy.us wrote: There's already the ability to cross compile to objective c for iOS

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-05 Thread flex
code is purely just a licensing and not a technical limitation that imposed by Apple. David -Original Message- From: Harbs harbs.li...@gmail.com To: dev@flex.apache.org Sent: Thu, 05 Jun 2014 1:17 AM Subject: Re: Let's talk about Flex 5 Really? The only way I know of outputting

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-05 Thread Harbs
2014 1:17 AM Subject: Re: Let's talk about Flex 5 Really? The only way I know of outputting ActionScript for iOS is using AIR for iOS which is just a swf with an embedded runtime. On Jun 5, 2014, at 4:26 AM, f...@dfguy.us wrote: There's already the ability to cross compile to objective c

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-05 Thread Erik de Bruin
features. The limitation on loading compiled byte code is purely just a licensing and not a technical limitation that imposed by Apple. As I understand it, it is mostly a security feature. They don't want any VMs that can potentially run 'arbitrary' (unsigned) code inside one big sandbox.

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-05 Thread flex
guess we'll have to wait and continue to ask Adobe to work on it. David -Original Message- From: Harbs harbs.li...@gmail.com To: dev@flex.apache.org Sent: Thu, 05 Jun 2014 6:56 AM Subject: Re: Let's talk about Flex 5 I don’t think that’s correct. Unless I’m mistaken, the AIR iOS runtime

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-04 Thread Nick Collins
Maybe we should do a FlexSwift and call that Flex 5 ;-) On Tue, Jun 3, 2014 at 1:13 PM, OmPrakash Muppirala bigosma...@gmail.com wrote: From my point of view, Flex mobile should be a big part of Flex 5. To that end, I am hoping that the Android 4.x and iOS7+ skins I am working on make it

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-04 Thread Nick Collins
In all honesty, what I would envision as Flex 5 would continue the work done for FlexJS with the compiler to allow us to write once and compile to multiple target runtimes. Unfortunately, right now we are pretty limited in viable runtime options for mass deployment, either to the Flash Player or

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-04 Thread flex
on the flex framework etc. David -Original Message- From: Nick Collins ndcoll...@gmail.com To: dev@flex.apache.org Sent: Wed, 04 Jun 2014 8:09 PM Subject: Re: Let's talk about Flex 5 Maybe we should do a FlexSwift and call that Flex 5 ;-) On Tue, Jun 3, 2014 at 1:13 PM, OmPrakash Muppirala

Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-03 Thread Gary Yang
Hi all, I am surprised that I have not seen any related topics. Flex has been there for almost 10 years. Flex4 has been there since 2009( right? before iOS )? What do you think about its future? What do you expect it to do? Best, -Gary

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-03 Thread Madhu Dutta
I have the same question.. On 3 Jun 2014 20:28, Gary Yang flashflex...@gmail.com wrote: Hi all, I am surprised that I have not seen any related topics. Flex has been there for almost 10 years. Flex4 has been there since 2009( right? before iOS )? What do you think about its future?

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-03 Thread Jeffry Houser
In the context of Apache and Open Source a better question to ask is: What do you want it to do? What effort are you willing to put in to make it so? On 6/3/2014 11:02 AM, Madhu Dutta wrote: I have the same question.. On 3 Jun 2014 20:28, Gary Yang flashflex...@gmail.com wrote: Hi all,

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-03 Thread Harbs
I think it’s called FlexJS… ;-) Harbs On Jun 3, 2014, at 5:58 PM, Gary Yang flashflex...@gmail.com wrote: Hi all, I am surprised that I have not seen any related topics. Flex has been there for almost 10 years. Flex4 has been there since 2009( right? before iOS )? What do you think

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-03 Thread Gary Yang
Come on!!! Websocket is ready! Workers will be ready soon! AGAL2 is coming! When you have a table of seafood, you don't want to rob the tramp any more! On Tue, Jun 3, 2014 at 11:21 AM, Harbs harbs.li...@gmail.com wrote: I think it’s called FlexJS… ;-) Harbs On Jun 3, 2014, at 5:58 PM,

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-03 Thread Harbs
So, I guess that’s the answer to Jeffery’s question. If you want to add those features to Flex, I don’t think you’d hear anyone complain! :-) Harbs On Jun 3, 2014, at 6:26 PM, Gary Yang flashflex...@gmail.com wrote: Come on!!! Websocket is ready! Workers will be ready soon! AGAL2 is

RE: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-03 Thread Kessler CTR Mark J
Subject: Re: Let's talk about Flex 5 I think it's called FlexJS... ;-) Harbs On Jun 3, 2014, at 5:58 PM, Gary Yang flashflex...@gmail.com wrote: Hi all, I am surprised that I have not seen any related topics. Flex has been there for almost 10 years. Flex4 has been there since 2009( right

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-03 Thread Roberto Cotrina
Code generator based on template, the template read from DB. 2014-06-03 9:58 GMT-05:00 Gary Yang flashflex...@gmail.com: Hi all, I am surprised that I have not seen any related topics. Flex has been there for almost 10 years. Flex4 has been there since 2009( right? before iOS )? What

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-03 Thread Carlos Velasco
I would expect it to run out of the flashplayer context, using its own free and open source virtual machine, far away from the Javascript rubbish. 2014-06-03 11:37 GMT-04:00 Roberto Cotrina rcotrina1...@gmail.com: Code generator based on template, the template read from DB. 2014-06-03 9:58

Re: Let's talk about Flex 5

2014-06-03 Thread OmPrakash Muppirala
From my point of view, Flex mobile should be a big part of Flex 5. To that end, I am hoping that the Android 4.x and iOS7+ skins I am working on make it into Flex 5. Thanks, Om On Tue, Jun 3, 2014 at 9:44 AM, Carlos Velasco carlos.velasco.bla...@gmail.com wrote: I would expect it to run out