RE: BUG? Profile properties not used to resolve dependencies transitively. (was RE: Version property in root POM & multi-level dependency resolution)

2008-12-15 Thread De Smet Ringo
Brett, > -Original Message- > From: Brett Porter > Sent: maandag 15 december 2008 9:50 > To: Maven Developers List > Subject: Re: BUG? Profile properties not used to resolve > dependencies transitively. (was RE: Version property in root > POM & multi-le

Re: BUG? Profile properties not used to resolve dependencies transitively. (was RE: Version property in root POM & multi-level dependency resolution)

2008-12-15 Thread Brett Porter
On 15/12/2008, at 7:44 PM, De Smet Ringo wrote: Brett, -Original Message- From: Brett Porter Sent: donderdag 11 december 2008 17:23 To: Maven Developers List Subject: Re: BUG? Profile properties not used to resolve dependencies transitively. (was RE: Version property in root POM

RE: BUG? Profile properties not used to resolve dependencies transitively. (was RE: Version property in root POM & multi-level dependency resolution)

2008-12-15 Thread De Smet Ringo
Brett, > -Original Message- > From: Brett Porter > Sent: donderdag 11 december 2008 17:23 > To: Maven Developers List > Subject: Re: BUG? Profile properties not used to resolve > dependencies transitively. (was RE: Version property in root > POM & multi-le

Re: BUG? Profile properties not used to resolve dependencies transitively. (was RE: Version property in root POM & multi-level dependency resolution)

2008-12-11 Thread Brett Porter
On 12/12/2008, at 3:10 AM, De Smet Ringo wrote: Brett, -Original Message- From: Brett Porter Ok, I see what you mean. You illustrated the property in the project which should not work. But from settings.xml and the command line it should. Unfortunately, it doesn't, or again I'm mis

RE: BUG? Profile properties not used to resolve dependencies transitively. (was RE: Version property in root POM & multi-level dependency resolution)

2008-12-11 Thread De Smet Ringo
Brett, > -Original Message- > From: Brett Porter > > Ok, I see what you mean. You illustrated the property in the > project which should not work. But from settings.xml and the > command line it should. Unfortunately, it doesn't, or again I'm misinterpreting you. :-) The three attac

Re: BUG? Profile properties not used to resolve dependencies transitively. (was RE: Version property in root POM & multi-level dependency resolution)

2008-12-11 Thread Brett Porter
On 12/12/2008, at 12:39 AM, De Smet Ringo wrote: The value is overridden for the project under build, but not for the transitive dependencies. Are you surprised that I find this an inconsistent result? :-) Ok, I see what you mean. You illustrated the property in the project which should

RE: BUG? Profile properties not used to resolve dependencies transitively. (was RE: Version property in root POM & multi-level dependency resolution)

2008-12-11 Thread De Smet Ringo
Brett, > -Original Message- > From: Brett Porter > > It looks like the intended behaviour to me, the same as if > you pulled the properties out of the profile. Properties are > not transitively applied. Can you give me some more background on the why of this decision. If you re-read m

Re: BUG? Profile properties not used to resolve dependencies transitively. (was RE: Version property in root POM & multi-level dependency resolution)

2008-12-11 Thread Brett Porter
On 11/12/2008, at 11:54 PM, De Smet Ringo wrote: [INFO] The following files have been resolved: [INFO]be.atriso.test:a:pom:1.0-SNAPSHOT:compile [INFO]junit:junit:jar:3.8.1:compile Is this a bug, or is this intended behaviour? It looks like the intended behaviour to me, the same as i

BUG? Profile properties not used to resolve dependencies transitively. (was RE: Version property in root POM & multi-level dependency resolution)

2008-12-11 Thread De Smet Ringo
Hello, As a followup on my original mail, I also started debugging the Maven internals. I came to the conclusion that properties defined in profiles, are not injected into the Maven model of transitive dependencies, just before the interpolation is executed. Attached you can find 2 POM files t

RE: Version property in root POM & multi-level dependency resolution

2008-12-10 Thread De Smet Ringo
Stephen, > -Original Message- > From: Stephen Connolly [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: woensdag 10 december 2008 14:01 > To: Maven Developers List > Subject: Re: Version property in root POM & multi-level > dependency resolution > > I'm not sure wher

Re: Version property in root POM & multi-level dependency resolution

2008-12-10 Thread Stephen Connolly
2008/12/10 De Smet Ringo <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Stephen, > > > -Original Message- > > From: Stephen Connolly [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > Sent: woensdag 10 december 2008 13:12 > > To: Maven Developers List > > Subject: Re: Version propert

RE: Version property in root POM & multi-level dependency resolution

2008-12-10 Thread De Smet Ringo
Stephen, > -Original Message- > From: Stephen Connolly [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: woensdag 10 december 2008 13:12 > To: Maven Developers List > Subject: Re: Version property in root POM & multi-level > dependency resolution > > Have a look a

Re: Version property in root POM & multi-level dependency resolution

2008-12-10 Thread Stephen Connolly
Have a look at versions:update-properties... (you'd need version 1.0-alpha-2 or newer) I'd structure things a little differently... but it might help you achieve your end-goal. 2008/12/10 De Smet Ringo <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Hello, > > [Repost from users list, hoping to get more in-depth answer h