Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-07 Thread Julian Feinauer
Hi, thanks for the fast response Justin. Then I guess, we could start a vote, couldn't we? Julian Am 07.03.19, 12:13 schrieb "Justin Mclean" : Hi, > Having gone through Justin's link to the Apache maturity model [1] I guess we are on an extremely good path (Keep in mind this is

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-07 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, > Having gone through Justin's link to the Apache maturity model [1] I guess we > are on an extremely good path (Keep in mind this is not a maturity model for > incubator projects, but all Apache projects) Also keep in mind that a) the maturity model is not a requirement to graduation but

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-07 Thread Christofer Dutz
Well as far as I can see it we could address most pretty quickly ... it's just the: QU40 Is something we couldn't do immediately IMHO. Chris Am 07.03.19, 11:55 schrieb "Christofer Dutz" : Hi all, Having gone through Justin's link to the Apache maturity model [1] I guess we are

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-07 Thread Christofer Dutz
Hi all, Having gone through Justin's link to the Apache maturity model [1] I guess we are on an extremely good path (Keep in mind this is not a maturity model for incubator projects, but all Apache projects) As far as I can see it, we get 100% of the points for most categories. There are howev

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-04 Thread Julian Feinauer
Hi, thanks for the clarification. Then I'm fine with the doc : ) Julian Am 04.03.19, 13:09 schrieb "Christofer Dutz" : Hi Julian, I had an error in my table markup ... in a few minutes the footnotes should appear ... they're already in the adoc file, but not rendered. Th

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-04 Thread Christofer Dutz
Hi Julian, I had an error in my table markup ... in a few minutes the footnotes should appear ... they're already in the adoc file, but not rendered. The document is from a point of view of the to become TLP (Cause otherwise there would have been more to mention ... "IPMC approval of Releases,

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-04 Thread Julian Feinauer
Hi Chris, I read the document and I like it. A few findings / remarks: - is this document from the perspectiv of a incubating project or the (to become) TLP? - You always mention the PMC (should be (P)PMC for a podling) - For a podling the "Yes" is missing for board report approval - Do the 1) /

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-04 Thread Christofer Dutz
Hi all, so I just added [1] (will take a few minutes to be live) However I haven't linked it in the menu yet as we haven't discussed it's content. In general it describes what we have been doing so far (That's why I took the liberty to select Consensus Approval for electing new Committers as w

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-04 Thread Christofer Dutz
Hi all, I am currently creating a copy of the content on https://wiki.apache.org/incubator/DefaultProjectGuidelines This is generally agreed upon by the IPMC and I a really good summary. I think we shouldn't do anything different. The main idea of copying instead of linking is: If in the future

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-04 Thread Sebastian Rühl
Hi all, I agree to what Julian wrote and would also would vote to graduate. Currently im a bit involved in private projects but during this march I should find some more time for the project again. Sebastian On 2019/03/01 20:35:03, Julian Feinauer wrote: > Hi Chris, > > first, thanks for bri

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-01 Thread Julian Feinauer
Hi Chris, first, thanks for bringing this up and doing all necessary tedious work. As this is the first incubating project I'm that heavily involved I'm lacking the exact feeling but I do not feel "unready". I think we have achieved a lot since I joined the project and I'm very happy that we ha

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-01 Thread Christofer Dutz
Ok ... logo is uploaded ... so that should have been the last open task (Hopefully) Chris Am 01.03.19, 13:14 schrieb "Christofer Dutz" : Hi Justin, well most of the red lines were actually false positives: - We do have the image and link to the latest events on the page, howev

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-01 Thread Christofer Dutz
Hi Justin, well most of the red lines were actually false positives: - We do have the image and link to the latest events on the page, however we include it with CSS - Also was there a License link (Even if it was previously called "Apache License", I updated that in the menu and additionally le

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-01 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, > I'll work on the issues reported in [2] ... didn't know about that page … Nothing major from what I can see but IMO the trademark notice in the footer need updating. Thanks, Justin

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-03-01 Thread Christofer Dutz
Hi Justin, I'll work on the issues reported in [2] ... didn't know about that page ... Chris Am 28.02.19, 23:04 schrieb "Justin Mclean" : Hi, You may want to fill out this [1] it ’s not required but can give you a good idea if you are ready to graduate. I'd also check

Re: [DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-02-28 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, You may want to fill out this [1] it ’s not required but can give you a good idea if you are ready to graduate. I'd also check the the website re trademarks and branding and that it has all needed links. [2] Thanks, Justin 1. https://community.apache.org/apache-way/apache-project-maturity

[DISCUSS] Start voting on graduating?

2019-02-28 Thread Christofer Dutz
Hi all, I have done a little double-checking and to me it seems that we are in good shape regarding our homework for graduating. The only thing on our todo-list that isn’t done fully, is the subscription of all initial contributors. http://incubator.apache.org/projects/plc4x.html Here I would p