Re: [DISCUSS] Change the format of the S7 Adresses

2018-08-11 Thread Julian Feinauer
Hi all, For the implementation of the feature discussed I see two open questions: * How are Markers, In/Outs adressed in TIA? * If we have the {width-identifier} it would be sufficient to use only INT, UNIT, REAL, ... because a LINT is just an INT with width D. Is it easier for the user

Re: [DISCUSS] Change the format of the S7 Adresses

2018-08-11 Thread Julian Feinauer
Hi Chris, thanks for the clarification, as you see I've never been that deeply involved with an apache project, yet (up to now just small fixes and commits). And in that case I agree with you to keep "conceptual" discussions here. Best Julian Am 11.08.18, 10:58 schrieb "Christofer Dutz

Re: [DISCUSS] Change the format of the S7 Adresses

2018-08-11 Thread Christofer Dutz
Hi all, Well the thing is, that if we take discussions to the issue, people on the list aren't included in this. So if there are usage aspects, they should be discussed here, I think. Otherwise we would require folks to automatically monitor other sources too. However I'm fine with implementati

Re: [DISCUSS] Change the format of the S7 Adresses

2018-08-11 Thread Julian Feinauer
Hi all, as it seems like everybody agreed on the proposed API Change / extension I allowed myself to create an Issue for this to coordinate the work on that under https://issues.apache.org/jira/projects/PLC4X/issues/PLC4X-43 I suggest that we move further discussion there. Is this okay for