Re: Jigsaw / multi module / dependencies

2020-06-19 Thread fannin...@apache.org
Hi Andi, I might have time to pair with you. Email me if you want to arrange a time. Regards, PJ On Friday 19 June 2020, 18:20:40 GMT+2, Andreas Beeker wrote: Hi devs, I finally pull myself together and have a working version of XmlBeans and POI with the xmlschema files moved

Re: Jigsaw / multi module / dependencies

2020-06-19 Thread Andreas Beeker
Hi devs, I finally pull myself together and have a working version of XmlBeans and POI with the xmlschema files moved away from schemaorg_apache_xmlbeans to module specific directories like org.apache.xmlbeans.metadata for the internal XmlBeans schemas and org.apache.poi.schemas.ooxml /

Re: Jigsaw / multi module / dependencies

2020-05-07 Thread Andreas Beeker
Hi, I haven't yet committed too much, which can't be reverted again. Currently the trunk builds ok in the Ant build, but I regard it as unstable, because there are some smaller things to change in POI and some bigger changes to XmlBeans as far as I can see now. If we want to push out a 4.1.3, I

Re: Jigsaw / multi module / dependencies

2020-05-07 Thread Dominik Stadler
Hi, Thanks for the work, good to progress towards that! I would like to see a version 4.1.3 as there were some important regressions fixed since 4.1.2. We can technically release from a branch, right? I don't remember us doing it until now... Thanks... Dominik.

Re: Jigsaw / multi module / dependencies

2020-05-05 Thread Andreas Beeker
Hi, I think its OK to commit it now and release the next major version for POI / XmlBeans when we are ready with trunk. When one of our remaining non-jigsaw dependencies switches we have to adapt, but I don't think we need to push that. What bugs me a bit is the way our modules (main,

Re: Jigsaw / multi module / dependencies

2020-05-05 Thread Axel Howind
Hi Andy, That’s great news! I think changing the module names makes this is breaking change, so will the release containing these changes be version 5.0 or a 4.x? I think I would go for 5.0 on the assumption that module and package names will stay stable for the foreseeable future. But I

Re: Jigsaw / multi module / dependencies

2020-05-05 Thread PJ Fanning
Thanks Andi, Seems like the right way to go. I'd like to see us update to XMLBeans 4 and POI 5 if the changes mean there is a user impact. We could release XMLBeans 3 and POI 4 bug fix releases if the changes take a while to complete and test. On Tuesday 5 May 2020, 12:44:35 GMT+2,

Jigsaw / multi module / dependencies

2020-05-05 Thread Andreas Beeker
Hi, I'm currently reworking our dependencies and try to provide multi module [1] jars. Currently I have the following: - multi module xml schemas - the merged and lite schema is tbd - removed the jaxb dependencies from the main module and provided my own XMLStreamReader based parser for