Re: Idea feedback request: Project mailing list specifically for upstream users

2018-09-26 Thread Johan Corveleyn
We've had a similar idea / discussion on dev@subversion.a.o a year ago, w.r.t. downstream from Subversion [1]. The idea was to set up a dedicated mailinglist waterway@s.a.o for them, where topics could be discussed that would be of interest to downstreamers (packagers / distributors, integrators,

Re: Idea feedback request: Project mailing list specifically for upstream users

2018-09-26 Thread Dmitriy Pavlov
Hi Alex, I'm sure you know your project specific better, and probably separate list is the best/only solution. I don't see any problems if the community agrees about it and a new list is well documented. But uniformity of mailing lists between Apache projects helps a lot to contribute to

Re: Idea feedback request: Project mailing list specifically for upstream users

2018-09-25 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
In my mind, there are three differentiation: 1) The Solr Users mailing list traffic is quite large and diverse. So, it can be both overwhelming (for everybody) and hard to notice messages that are possibly of much higher impact than others. An upstream framework that is suddenly broken or wants to

Re: Idea feedback request: Project mailing list specifically for upstream users

2018-09-25 Thread Luciano Resende
On Tue, Sep 25, 2018 at 5:30 PM Alexandre Rafalovitch wrote: > > Hi, > > I have an idea that I would love to get feedback on to see if it makes > sense, feasible, has been tried, is currently being done by somebody, > etc. > > My example is based on Apache Solr, but I think it may affect a lot of

Idea feedback request: Project mailing list specifically for upstream users

2018-09-25 Thread Alexandre Rafalovitch
Hi, I have an idea that I would love to get feedback on to see if it makes sense, feasible, has been tried, is currently being done by somebody, etc. My example is based on Apache Solr, but I think it may affect a lot of Apache projects. We are all giants offering shoulders to somebody else