Central Limit Therem Was: Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-24 Thread Herman Rubin
In article 3BAF09BF.1057.32F8FF@localhost, J.Russell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The requirement for the CLT to hold is that there should be a mean and st deviation for the background distribution. This I checked in Introduction to the Theory of Statistics by Mood, Graybill and Boes For a Cauchy

Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-23 Thread Rich Ulrich
On Fri, 21 Sep 2001 12:47:33 -0400, Joe Galenko [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The mean of a random sample of size 81 from a population of size 1 billion is going to be Normally distributed regardless of the distribution of the overall population (i.e., the 1 billion). Oftentimes the magic

Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-21 Thread Joe Galenko
The mean of a random sample of size 81 from a population of size 1 billion is going to be Normally distributed regardless of the distribution of the overall population (i.e., the 1 billion). Oftentimes the magic number of 30 is used to say that the mean will have a Normal distribution, although

Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-21 Thread Gus Gassmann
Joe Galenko wrote: The mean of a random sample of size 81 from a population of size 1 billion is going to be Normally distributed regardless of the distribution of the overall population (i.e., the 1 billion). Oftentimes the magic number of 30 is used to say that the mean will have a Normal

Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-21 Thread Gus Gassmann
Joe Galenko wrote: Just out of curiousity, I'd like to know what kind of population you could have such that a sample mean with N = 200 wouldn't be approximately Normally distributed. That would have to be a very, very strange distribution indeed. You can construct them easily as Bernoulli

Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-21 Thread Joe Galenko
Right, I meant to say _approximately_ Normal. If you're writing it down mathematically then the sample mean is only Normal if the larger population is also Normal. But in practice, nothing is ever exactly Normal anyway, so in that sense it's just a matter of when have you have enough to get a

RE: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-21 Thread David Heiser
-Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]On Behalf Of Joe Galenko Sent: Friday, September 21, 2001 12:30 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: what type of distribution on this sampling Just out of curiousity, I'd like to know what kind of population you

Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-21 Thread Jay Warner
Not to disagree with Randy Poe completely, but I think we can say something, especially if we make _some_ assumptions (mainly, that this comes from an intro class). @Home wrote: I am trying to solve a ? which basically gives the following facts: population of unknown number popu std dev of

Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-20 Thread @Home
what about if n is only 15 and the population distribution is heavily skewed? Isn't there a balancing here. Of course w/81 samples, it is hard to conceive anything but a normal distrib based on the CLT. Edward Dreyer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote in message [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]...

Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-20 Thread @Home
The sample mean is the average of your actual sample values. It isn't obviously 78 or anything else, though it might be close to 78. And how did you calculate the standard error? I stand corrected on this point. Thanks. Randy Poe [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote in message [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL

Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-20 Thread dennis roberts
normal populations result in normal sampling distributions of means ... if one considers all possible samples non normal populations never result in exactly normal sampling distributions regardless of sample sizes (though to the naked eye you might not be able to tell the difference) the

Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-20 Thread dennis roberts
At 06:28 PM 9/20/01 -0400, Stan Brown wrote: None that I know, in a formal sense. If you take 100 random samples of size 81, or 100,000 random samples of size 81, your histogram of sample means will have the same shape, though the curve will be a bit smoother with 100,000 samples. this is for

Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-20 Thread @Home
Stan, Thanks for the detailed explanation. I have one follwoup ?. You say, If the original population is normally distributed, the sample means will also be normally distributed. Even if the original population is skewed, the sample means will still be approximately normally distributed given

Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-20 Thread Randy Poe
@Home wrote: I am trying to solve a ? which basically gives the following facts: population of unknown number popu std dev of 27 pop mean of 78 With what underlying distribution? sample of size n=81 2000 random samples The ? is: what is the sample mean? what is the std error

Re: what type of distribution on this sampling

2001-09-20 Thread Edward Dreyer
At 05:48 PM 9/20/2001 +, you wrote: I am trying to solve a ? which basically gives the following facts: population of unknown number popu std dev of 27 pop mean of 78 sample of size n=81 2000 random samples The ? is: what is the sample mean? what is the std error (std dev of sample