graid3 or graid5? with or without gjournal?

2011-07-26 Thread DA Forsyth
array. graid3 can only use 3 graid5 can use all 4, but is it production ready? any ideas? The advantage of using graid3 at this point is that the extra 1TB drive I have can then go into the backup server which needs more space anyway. Having suffered data loss on the previous raid5 (intel matrix

Re: graid3 or graid5? with or without gjournal?

2011-07-26 Thread Jerome Herman
1TB drives available for the main data array. graid3 can only use 3 graid5 can use all 4, but is it production ready? any ideas? Take everything I say with a grain of salt, I am still testing these kinds of setup. I do not know about graid5, but gvinum is very slow when used in a raid5 config

Re: graid3 or graid5? with or without gjournal?

2011-07-26 Thread Adam Vande More
On Tue, Jul 26, 2011 at 1:48 AM, DA Forsyth d.fors...@ru.ac.za wrote: The advantage of using graid3 at this point is that the extra 1TB drive I have can then go into the backup server which needs more space anyway. Having suffered data loss on the previous raid5 (intel matrix) array when

Re: graid3 or graid5? with or without gjournal?

2011-07-26 Thread Sergio de Almeida Lenzi
in some other box. I have 4x 1TB drives available for the main data array. graid3 can only use 3 graid5 can use all 4, but is it production ready? any ideas? The advantage of using graid3 at this point is that the extra 1TB drive I have can then go into the backup server which needs more

Is it possible to setup a graid3 on root?

2009-09-25 Thread Modulok
Just wondering if it is possible to setup a striped root partition (graid3) and still be able to boot from it. Logically, it doesn't sound promising, but has anyone tried this? Thanks! -Modulok- ___ freebsd-questions@freebsd.org mailing list http

Re: Is it possible to setup a graid3 on root?

2009-09-25 Thread Tim Judd
On 9/25/09, Modulok modu...@gmail.com wrote: Just wondering if it is possible to setup a striped root partition (graid3) and still be able to boot from it. Logically, it doesn't sound promising, but has anyone tried this? Thanks! -Modulok- Remember -- To boot off a distributed RAID

Re: growing a graid3 array and growfs not growing ....

2009-06-08 Thread Tim Judd
for the OP. On 5/29/09, Vikash Badal vikash.ba...@is.co.za wrote: Can someone please advise why growfs would return: growfs: we are not growing (8388607-4194303) ? I have a FreeBSD 7.2 server in a VM. I initially had 5 x 4G disks Created a raid graid3 label datavol da2 da3 da4 da5 da6 I

growing a graid3 array and growfs not growing ....

2009-05-29 Thread Vikash Badal
Can someone please advise why growfs would return: growfs: we are not growing (8388607-4194303) ? I have a FreeBSD 7.2 server in a VM. I initially had 5 x 4G disks Created a raid graid3 label datavol da2 da3 da4 da5 da6 I upgraded them to 5 x 8g disks swopped out the virtual disks one

Re: graid3

2008-07-27 Thread Wojciech Puchar
why it can't be say 5 disks+parity? The reason is in the definition on RAID 3, which says the updates to the RAID device must be atomic. In some ideal universe, RAID 3 is implemented in hardware and on individual bytes, but here we cannot write to the drives in units other than sectorsize

Re: graid3

2008-07-26 Thread Ivan Voras
Wojciech Puchar wrote: i read the graid3 manual and http://www.acnc.com/04_01_03.html to make sure i know what's RAID3 and i don't understand few things. 1) The number of components must be equal to 3, 5, 9, 17, etc. (2^n + 1). why it can't be say 5 disks+parity? The reason

graid3

2008-07-25 Thread Wojciech Puchar
i read the graid3 manual and http://www.acnc.com/04_01_03.html to make sure i know what's RAID3 and i don't understand few things. 1) The number of components must be equal to 3, 5, 9, 17, etc. (2^n + 1). why it can't be say 5 disks+parity? 2) -r Use parity component

Re: graid3

2008-07-25 Thread nicodache
the raid controler/software thing can reconstruct the data with only n-1 of the n drives in the array. in random IO this can be quite usefull, while in sequential read, the parity drive is not that much of use. On Fri, Jul 25, 2008 at 11:46 AM, Wojciech Puchar [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: i read the graid3

creating a broken graid3 array?

2006-11-23 Thread John Nielsen
Is it possible to create a (degraded) graid3 array with only two (or one less than the planned total) providers? I'm asking since I would like to move from my current one-disk setup to a three-disk raid3 array, but I'd like the disk currently in use to be a member of the array and I don't have

Re: creating a broken graid3 array?

2006-11-23 Thread Andrew Pantyukhin
On 11/23/06, John Nielsen [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is it possible to create a (degraded) graid3 array Maybe you'll be able to create graid3 with md0 as the third member (based on sparse file for example) and later emulate a failure (md0 disappears) and insert your hard drive

Re: creating a broken graid3 array?

2006-11-23 Thread usleepless
John, On 11/23/06, John Nielsen [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is it possible to create a (degraded) graid3 array with only two (or one less than the planned total) providers? I'm asking since I would like to move from my current one-disk setup to a three-disk raid3 array, but I'd like the disk

Re: creating a broken graid3 array?

2006-11-23 Thread usleepless
is the loss of your data worth less than the cost of an extra hd? if so, buy another hd. if not, make a clean install? should read: is the cost of an extra hd less than the value of your data/install? if so, buy another hd. if not, make a clean install? regards, usleep

Re: creating a broken graid3 array?

2006-11-23 Thread John Nielsen
as important are the goals of learning more about something I haven't used before (graid3) and getting a larger volume on a limited budget. Besides, trickery is where the fun comes in. :) I appreciate the response, though. It's a point I might have raised myself. JN

Re: creating a broken graid3 array?

2006-11-23 Thread John Nielsen
On Thursday 23 November 2006 16:00, Andrew Pantyukhin wrote: On 11/23/06, John Nielsen [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Is it possible to create a (degraded) graid3 array Maybe you'll be able to create graid3 with md0 as the third member (based on sparse file for example) and later emulate

graid3 lockups?

2005-12-14 Thread Neal Rigney
I've got a dual-proc machine with 3 ATA drives that I'd like to roll together in a graid3 configuration. 2 of the drives are 250G, and the third is 300G. I'm using the raw disk for the two 250G drives (ad4 and ad6) and the a partition (which is 250G) of the 300G disk (ad9). ad9 looks like