Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-25 Thread Al Poulin
On Mar 23, 4:10 pm, Dan dantear...@gmail.com wrote: At 3:04 PM -0400 3/23/2009, insightinmind wrote: The answer then seemed to be yes ... zeroing a partition would cause the controller to map out any bad sectors. Not seems - is.  Yes.  The controller ALWAYS maps out bad blocks whenever

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-25 Thread Dan
At 9:17 AM -0700 3/25/2009, Al Poulin wrote: If I may summarize the discussion about bad sectors. Bad sectors (blocks) get mapped out on the fly during normal read/write operations. Bad sectors (blocks) get mapped out within a volume/partition when you zero the volume/partition in Disk

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-25 Thread Al Poulin
On Mar 25, 12:51 pm, Dan dantear...@gmail.com wrote: At 9:17 AM -0700 3/25/2009, Al Poulin wrote: Bad sectors (blocks) get mapped out on the fly during normal read/write operations. Correct. So, unlike the advice of 5 -10 years ago, we no longer need to map out bad blocks in an entire

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-25 Thread Dan
At 10:47 AM -0700 3/25/2009, Al Poulin wrote: On Mar 25, 12:51 pm, Dan dantear...@gmail.com wrote: At 9:17 AM -0700 3/25/2009, Al Poulin wrote: Bad sectors (blocks) get mapped out on the fly during normal read/write operations. Correct. So, unlike the advice of 5 -10 years ago Drives

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-23 Thread insightinmind
On Mar 22, 2009, at 10:58 PM, tortoise wrote: I'd like the thank the originator of this tip. I had a few drives reporting bad spots (in the full SMART report which you get only when you download the source and build it; and also when I tried to secure erase I got write errors *sometimes*

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-23 Thread gifutiger
Greetings ( + )!( + ) Checking with Western Digital and Seagate, they have an application that runs on a WINTEL PCEE that will do the low-level format which will mark, i.e. remove the bad sectors from the drive but fortunately I haven't own a WinTel (DOS) computer for more than 30 years. Cheers

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-23 Thread Dan
At 8:54 AM -0400 3/23/2009, insightinmind wrote: I believe the bad sectors are mapped out, even when zeroing the partitions ... as someone said, the controller doesn't function around partition boundaries (my paraphrasing). Still not sure of the answer here. Not sure what controller doesn't

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-22 Thread tortoise
I'd like the thank the originator of this tip. I had a few drives reporting bad spots (in the full SMART report which you get only when you download the source and build it; and also when I tried to secure erase I got write errors *sometimes* w/ hangs, noted in apple console logs) Yes, erasing

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-21 Thread Bruce Johnson
On Mar 20, 2009, at 5:39 PM, insightinmind wrote: On Mar 20, 2009, at 8:15 PM, Charles Davis wrote: Please note, I'm talking about the 'Write Zeros' operation, NOT just 'Erasing' ---[ Which is just Zeroing out the directory data, not elimination the 'bit patterns' on the platter

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-20 Thread Aaron
What about SMART (S.M.A.R.T.) status and functionality? Shouldn't the drive's built-in SMART routines map out bad blocks? If they do, will the Surface Scan still try to read those blocks? BTW, is Tech Tools Deluxe really TechTool Pro, or is it a different program I haven't encoountered yet?

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-20 Thread insightinmind
On Mar 20, 2009, at 6:36 AM, Aaron wrote: What about SMART (S.M.A.R.T.) status and functionality? Shouldn't the drive's built-in SMART routines map out bad blocks? If they do, will the Surface Scan still try to read those blocks? AFAIK, original S.M.A.R.T. Status didn't do any disk

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-20 Thread insightinmind
On Mar 20, 2009, at 7:12 PM, Charles Davis wrote: On Mar 20, 2009, at 11:57 AM, Dan wrote: That's re-initializing a drive. You cannot reformat modern drives. The process of zeroing it -- writing zeros to each sector on the drive causes the hardware's bad block replacement mechanism to

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-20 Thread Charles Davis
On Mar 20, 2009, at 8:06 PM, insightinmind wrote: On Mar 20, 2009, at 7:12 PM, Charles Davis wrote: On Mar 20, 2009, at 11:57 AM, Dan wrote: That's re-initializing a drive. You cannot reformat modern drives. The process of zeroing it -- writing zeros to each sector on the drive

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-20 Thread insightinmind
On Mar 20, 2009, at 8:15 PM, Charles Davis wrote: Please note, I'm talking about the 'Write Zeros' operation, NOT just 'Erasing' ---[ Which is just Zeroing out the directory data, not elimination the 'bit patterns' on the platter surface.] Same meaning here ... sometimes called Secure Erase

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-20 Thread Dan
At 7:12 PM -0400 3/20/2009, Charles Davis wrote: The process of zeroing it -- writing zeros to each sector on the drive causes the hardware's bad block replacement mechanism to trigger as needed. What isn't being said here, is whether the 'bad block' mechanism is operational when

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-20 Thread Dan
At 8:11 PM -0400 3/20/2009, Charles Davis wrote: I've always assumed partitions were being treated like a separate volume, and was being re-mapped. That's the way I'd like it to be, which means that the 'Bad Blocks' routines probably only work when Zeroing the complete Hard Disk. No. The

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-19 Thread gifutiger
Greetings ( + )!( + ) What you describe is exatly the same that I was having. Used Tech Tools Deluxe Surface Scan on my 320Gb drive (took about 12 Hrs.) and the report was Failed - Bad Blocks so I've laid that disk to rest RIP and have ordered a new drive. If you have Tech Tools Deluxe run the

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-18 Thread Janine
Hi All - thanks for your advice. I think it's definitely a corrupted system problem. Tried to do an Archive and Install and the problem got worse, to the point where Disk First Aid has gone from saying there is nothing wrong with the disk, to saying it cannot be repaired! Yuck! From the OS X

Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-17 Thread Janine Cheung
As I said, I need help! I have a 1 Ghz Dual Processor Quick Silver with 1.5 GB ram, running OS 10.4.11 I had two harddrives installed. My main drive is 150 GB but shows up as being 120 gb. The other harddrive was about 80 GB. Anyway... I turned the computer on today and heard a persistant

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-17 Thread dc
You may need to change the jumper setting and/or cable position on your boot drive. The easiest way to see if this is the problem is to put the old dead drive back in place, just as it was before. Your Mac should boot normally and you will be able to use Disk Utility to check the disk and

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-17 Thread insightinmind
On Mar 17, 6:39 am, Janine Cheung hbbst...@gmail.com wrote: As I said, I need help! I have a 1 Ghz Dual Processor Quick Silver with 1.5 GB ram, running OS 10.4.11 I have a QS 2002 Dual 1GHz ... nice machine. I believe your HD settings are CS or Cable Select. Make sure you didn't

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-17 Thread Charles Davis
First things First Remove, or at least disconnect the second HD - leave out of the mix until you get the first HD working. [That way THOSE files will be safe from further damage, and probably recoverable later.] [Treat that HDs problems as a separate problem.] On Mar 17, 2009, at

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-17 Thread insightinmind
On Mar 17, 2009, at 6:39 AM, Janine Cheung wrote: As I said, I need help! I have a 1 Ghz Dual Processor Quick Silver with 1.5 GB ram, running OS 10.4.11 I had two harddrives installed. My main drive is 150 GB but shows up as being 120 gb. You must have a pre-2002 Quicksilver if

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-17 Thread John Musbach
On Tue, Mar 17, 2009 at 6:39 AM, Janine Cheung hbbst...@gmail.com wrote: Then I rebooted using the main drive, and that's when it gets stuck (as detailed above) My files are still on the boot drive, but how can I get the harddrive to mount? snip! Any other suggestions?

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-17 Thread Cyrus Griffin
You might try an Archive and Install, I had this happen on my G4 iBook, but that was due to a bad DVD drive, that didn't install all the system files... Sounds like a similar problem. (System files corrupted) (Archive and install keeps all your files safe.) To get your files off, you could

Re: Help! I've lost one harddrive and now the main harddrive won't boot!

2009-03-17 Thread joe
On Mar 17, 2009, at 5:39 AM, Janine Cheung wrote: My files are still on the boot drive, but how can I get the harddrive to mount? I don't have an up-to-date version of Disk Warrior. if I got the appropriate version and ran it, building a new volume directory for the disk, would that