Sorry for the spam - Abner just filed their ICLA under "Abner Ferreira".
Hopefully that's the last thing to check off!
-David
On Mon, Jul 25, 2022, at 17:17, David Li wrote:
> Just to follow up quickly - the Dremio side is still trying to contact the
> contributor to re-file the ICLA (this
Just to follow up quickly - the Dremio side is still trying to contact the
contributor to re-file the ICLA (this time with the "notify Arrow PMC" option).
I was wondering, separately - if Dremio holds the rights to the code, is their
Software Grant sufficient, in case we can't track down the
Thanks Justin. I'll re-confirm with the Dremio side (unfortunately not everyone
remembered to check the "notify Arrow PMC" box at initial filing which was my
mistake).
-David
Hi,
There is no icla filed under that name that I can see.
Kind Regards,
Justin
On Tue, 19 July 2022, 7:06 am David Li, wrote:
> Also to follow up on one other question from Justin: Abner's ICLA should
> have been filed under "Abner Ferreira" as the public name, are they
> findable under that
Thanks, that email link satisfies my curiosity and any hint of concerns.
On 7/18/22, 7:43 AM, "David Li" wrote:
The contributors are all (sub)contractors of Dremio, who were retained to
work on this project. I checked with the lead author (Kyle Porter) and he
confirmed all IP is with
Also to follow up on one other question from Justin: Abner's ICLA should have
been filed under "Abner Ferreira" as the public name, are they findable under
that name?
-David
On Mon, Jul 18, 2022, at 10:42, David Li wrote:
> The contributors are all (sub)contractors of Dremio, who were retained
The contributors are all (sub)contractors of Dremio, who were retained to work
on this project. I checked with the lead author (Kyle Porter) and he confirmed
all IP is with Dremio, who filed the software grant - is that what we're
looking to confirm? A CCLA was not filed with Apache, as we
Thanks for the clarity, David.
Given the clear "commit trail" for individual committers and the ICLAs I don't
see a problem there. I think the only question that may need a bit more
clarity is the relationship of Dremio to the contributions. I know my own
employer has boilerplate legal
Hello,
Sorry for some of the confusion here, I'll try to explain. (Apologies if this
does not get linked back up correctly to the thread - Pony Mail does not let me
login and the mailto: link generates a URL which is too long).
I did preemptively ask the contributors to add the Apache license
> > Isn't developing on a fork of the project and submitting a PR
considered "developed inside the project”?
> Sure, but then you usually don’t need a software grant.
Ah, but I do. When submitting a PR to an ASF project (e.g., [1]) I have had to
either submit an ICLA (which I have)
Hi,
Do we have an ICLA on file for "Abner Eduardo Ferreira”? I can see we do for
the other people mentioned in the grant.
Kind Regards,
Justin
-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org
For additional
Hi,
> Isn't developing on a fork of the project and submitting a PR considered
> "developed inside the project”?
Sure, but then you usually don’t need a software grant.
> I never claim copyright as my own or use my own header. This is exactly what
> happened here.
Why you may not claim it
Isn't developing on a fork of the project and submitting a PR considered
"developed inside the project"?
When I contribute to Apache projects, I fork the project, write code using the
project's headers, and submit a PR from my fork. I never claim copyright as my
own or use my own header.
Hi,
Which is an issue as the header has "Licensed to the Apache Software Foundation
(ASF) under one or more contributor license agreements”. That is not really the
case yet. Normally wth a software grant you replace the headers and move the
original copyright line to the NOTICE file. I'm
To elaborate and be more specific, the proposal identifies this fork [5] as the
"source". [6] is an exhaustive list of the 1491 commits involved, constituting
the donated IP. A spot check of commits with "license header" in the
description shows ASF headers were used and there does not appear
Based on this blog post [1] it appears that the entire development was done in
a sequence of draft PRs on the Arrow site (and on a fork), with the intention
of donating it, and using ASF headers.
Proposal: [2]
Initial POC work: [3]
Experimental version: [4]
[1] -
Hi,
What were the original headers on the files and/or where did the original code
come from? The code pointed to has ASF headers which make determining the
origin a little difficult.
Kind Regards,.
Justin
-
To unsubscribe,
17 matches
Mail list logo
