Re: [Gimp-developer] LIC-Plugin

2002-05-05 Thread Frank Lauterwald

On Friday 03 May 2002 23:05, Sven Neumann wrote:

   We should
   however provide a backward-compatible PDB interface if possible.
IMHO this should not be necessary as the old LIC does not support 
non-interactive mode. And for interactive mode the PDB interface should be 
the same anyway.

 - Decide if you want the plug-in to be kept and maintained in GIMP CVS.
   In the beginning you'd send patches but I think we could get you CVS
   commit access pretty soon.
If I have the choice, I'd prefer CVS. 

 - Change the user interface so it fits better into the look and feel of
   GIMP plug-ins.
Any more concrete suggestions? As I am not an experienced GIMP-user (I simply 
do not work with graphics too much) I have not been able to see the big 
standard yet. Anyway, UI design is not the thing I am best at , so I could 
use a helping hand here. Not at the coding stuff but at the question how 
should it look like?

Ok, gonna fetch Gtk2 and GIMP1.3 and start porting now ...

Frank



___
Gimp-developer mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.xcf.berkeley.edu/mailman/listinfo/gimp-developer



Re: [Gimp-developer] LIC-Plugin

2002-05-03 Thread Sven Neumann

Hi,

Frank Lauterwald [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

 a couple of months ago I stated I had rewritten the old LIC(Van Gogh)-plugin.
 Sven suggested replacing the old version in CVS with the new one but I felt 
 my version was too untested to do so.
 
 At the moment I am neither aware of any bugs nor do I plan to implement any 
 new features, so - unless there are severe objections -  now might be the 
 time to check it in.
 
 Is there anything I have to do? Or will you maintainers have a look at it and 
 do what must be done if it is accepted?

I had a quick look and I have to say that I'm impressed. However to get 
the plug-in into the GIMP-1.3 tree, there are a couple of things that
need to be done:

 - Decide if you want the plug-in to be kept and maintained in GIMP CVS.
   In the beginning you'd send patches but I think we could get you CVS
   commit access pretty soon.

 - Port it to GTK+-2.0 and GIMP-1.3. This task should be pretty
   straight-forward.

 - Change the code to be compliant to the GIMP coding style. A good start
   would be to use indent with default settings (GNU coding style). The
   GIMP coding style is described in the file HACKING in the GIMP source.
   Not all plug-ins comply to it but we don't want to accept new code
   that doesn't.

 - Change the user interface so it fits better into the look and feel of
   GIMP plug-ins.

We can certainly help you a lot but I'd like you to stay the
maintainer of the plug-in.

 btw.: it still lacks automake support and stuff (meaning it has a
 normal makefile ...) , but the makefile is quite straightforward so
 anybody who is comfortable with automake (not me, sorry ) should be
 able to do the necessary changes within a few minutes

if it gets integrated into the gimp source tree, you don't need to
worry about automake and autoconf. I'll write the Makefile.am for you.
If you decide to maintain it separately, I'd suggest to look at the
gimp-plugin-template on ftp.gimp.org. It should be easy to adapt it
to your needs.


Salut, Sven
___
Gimp-developer mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.xcf.berkeley.edu/mailman/listinfo/gimp-developer



Re: [Gimp-developer] LIC-Plugin

2002-05-03 Thread Sven Neumann

Hi again,

 I had a quick look and I have to say that I'm impressed. However to get 
 the plug-in into the GIMP-1.3 tree, there are a couple of things that
 need to be done:
 [...]

I forgot one more thing:

- We need to decide if we want the plug-in to replace the old LIC
  plug-in or if we want to keep the old one around. If the results are
  similar enough I'd vote for replacing the old one since exposing
  more choices to the user is not always the best solution. We should
  however provide a backward-compatible PDB interface if possible. We
  can then add a plug-in-lic2 PDB interface that exposes all the new
  features.


Salut, Sven
___
Gimp-developer mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.xcf.berkeley.edu/mailman/listinfo/gimp-developer