RE: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ??

2014-07-01 Thread Sandell, Robert
Subject: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ?? Hi. We're in the process of creating a new icon in the hope of allowing more control over icons in the UI [1]. As part of that, we want to allow plugins that adopt this new tag to remain backward

Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ??

2014-07-01 Thread Tom Fennelly
Maybe there's a misunderstanding ... I created a jenkins-icon module (a simple java jar containing just the icon taglib). It doesn't depend on anything in Jenkins - it just depends on Stapler. Jenkins core depends on this module to get the icon tag. Plugins can also independently depend on

Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ??

2014-07-01 Thread Tom Fennelly
+ Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ?? Hi. We're in the process of creating a new icon in the hope of allowing more control over icons in the UI [1]. As part of that, we want to allow plugins that adopt this new tag to remain backward compatible with older versions of Jenkins. Up

Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ??

2014-07-01 Thread Stephen Connolly
Ah ok. Yeah that will work On Tuesday, 1 July 2014, Tom Fennelly tom.fenne...@gmail.com wrote: Maybe there's a misunderstanding ... I created a jenkins-icon module (a simple java jar containing just the icon taglib). It doesn't depend on anything in Jenkins - it just depends on Stapler.

RE: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ??

2014-07-01 Thread Sandell, Robert
-dev@googlegroups.com Subject: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ?? Hi. We're in the process of creating a new icon in the hope of allowing more control over icons in the UI [1]. As part of that, we want to allow plugins that adopt this new tag

Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ??

2014-07-01 Thread Tom Fennelly
@googlegroups.com] *On Behalf Of *Tom Fennelly *Sent:* den 1 juli 2014 12:41 *To:* jenkinsci-dev@googlegroups.com *Subject:* Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ?? But wouldn't that be the case anyway if we defined the base tag in the normal way inside

Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ??

2014-07-01 Thread Stephen Connolly
] *On Behalf Of *Tom Fennelly *Sent:* den 1 juli 2014 12:41 *To:* jenkinsci-dev@googlegroups.com *Subject:* Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ?? But wouldn't that be the case anyway if we defined the base tag in the normal way inside Jenkins

Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ??

2014-07-01 Thread Tom Fennelly
Fennelly *Sent:* den 1 juli 2014 12:41 *To:* jenkinsci-dev@googlegroups.com mailto:jenkinsci-dev@googlegroups.com *Subject:* Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ?? But wouldn't that be the case anyway if we defined the base tag

Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ??

2014-07-01 Thread Stephen Connolly
*To:* jenkinsci-dev@googlegroups.com *Subject:* New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ?? Hi. We're in the process of creating a new icon in the hope of allowing more control over icons in the UI [1]. As part of that, we want to allow plugins that adopt

Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ??

2014-07-01 Thread Tom Fennelly
*To:* jenkinsci-dev@googlegroups.com mailto:jenkinsci-dev@googlegroups.com *Subject:* Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ?? But wouldn't that be the case anyway if we defined the base tag in the normal way inside

Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ??

2014-06-30 Thread Stephen Connolly
You can't update core to use the plugin, as circular dependency... So as soon as you want to use your tag in core your plugin is... Oh look its a shim! Would a rose by any other name smell as sweet? On Monday, 30 June 2014, Tom Fennelly tom.fenne...@gmail.com wrote: Hi. We're in the process

Re: New Jelly tags - via Jenkins Core + Plugin shim, or via simple Java jar dependency ??

2014-06-30 Thread Stephen Connolly
Anyway you have over complicated yourself. Also you don't call the shim tag icon-shim you call it icon but in a different namespace. That makes migration simples We should chat tomorrow On Tuesday, 1 July 2014, Stephen Connolly stephen.alan.conno...@gmail.com wrote: You can't update core to