[LUTE] Re: Thomas Campion

2009-08-27 Thread Taco Walstra
On Wed, 2009-08-26 at 16:51 +0200, Matteo Turri wrote:

Thanks! That's the second wonderful link in one week! Not just dowland
and campion facsimiles but also wilson, rosseter etc. etc. Very nice. \
Unfortunately you can only create a pdf of one page and not the whole
book.
Taco

 A great resource to retrieve this kind of documents is the EEBO, Early 
 English 
 Books Online:
 
 http://eebo.chadwyck.com/home
 
 You can only access it via a Library or an Academic Institution, but is 
 should 
 be pretty easy to register at you local library and gain access to it through 
 their online services - this means that you don't have to go to the library 
 to 
 access EEBo, but you can access it through the site of the library.
 
 Just to give you an idea: you can access - and download in pdf format - any 
 music book of the Elizabethan era: Dowland, Byrd, Campion, Tomkins, you name 
 it ...
 
 Hope it helps
 
 
 Matteo
 
 
 
 
 On Wednesday 26 August 2009 15:53:28 ariel abramovich wrote:
  Dear friends,
 
 
 
  I'm desperately looking for Thomas Campion 4th books, in any digital
  format.
 
  I bought all others, but the 4th seems to be a bit of a problem to find.
 
 
  Any link to some library files?
 
 
  Thanks in advance!
 
  all best,
 
 
  ariel.
 
 
 
  To get on or off this list see list information at
  http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
 
 




[LUTE] Re: Thomas Campion

2009-08-27 Thread Matteo Turri
   Taco,
   you can download the whole documents in pdf.
   At the moment I cannot access EEBO form my office. I will do it later
   from home and explain you the steps.
   M.

   2009/8/27 Taco Walstra [1]wals...@science.uva.nl

 On Wed, 2009-08-26 at 16:51 +0200, Matteo Turri wrote:
 Thanks! That's the second wonderful link in one week! Not just
 dowland
 and campion facsimiles but also wilson, rosseter etc. etc. Very
 nice. \
 Unfortunately you can only create a pdf of one page and not the
 whole
 book.
 Taco

A great resource to retrieve this kind of documents is the EEBO,
   Early English
Books Online:
   
[2]http://eebo.chadwyck.com/home
   
You can only access it via a Library or an Academic Institution, but
   is should
be pretty easy to register at you local library and gain access to it
   through
their online services - this means that you don't have to go to the
   library to
access EEBo, but you can access it through the site of the library.
   
Just to give you an idea: you can access - and download in pdf format
   - any
music book of the Elizabethan era: Dowland, Byrd, Campion, Tomkins,
   you name
it ...
   
Hope it helps
   
   
Matteo
   
   
   
   

On Wednesday 26 August 2009 15:53:28 ariel abramovich wrote:
 Dear friends,



 I'm desperately looking for Thomas Campion 4th books, in any
   digital
 format.

 I bought all others, but the 4th seems to be a bit of a problem to
   find.


 Any link to some library files?


 Thanks in advance!

 all best,


 ariel.



 To get on or off this list see list information at
 [3]http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
   
   

   --

References

   1. mailto:wals...@science.uva.nl
   2. http://eebo.chadwyck.com/home
   3. http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/%7Ewbc/lute-admin/index.html



[LUTE] Re: Thomas Campion

2009-08-27 Thread Taco Walstra
On Thu, 2009-08-27 at 09:59 +0200, Matteo Turri wrote:
 Taco,
 
 you can download the whole documents in pdf.
 
 At the moment I cannot access EEBO form my office. I will do it later
 from home and explain you the steps.
 
 M.
 
Ah, I figured it out: you select the document and in the marked list
there is a possibility to download the whole document. 

Very impressing list of manuscripts:  Purcell (57 items), alison,
dowland, campion, rosseter, wilson, playford (xxx manuscripts),
robinson, bartlet, coprario, canvendish, danyel, ferrabosco, ford, john
gamble (never heard of him before), thomas greaves (lutenist of some
henri pierrefont..), pierre guedron, thomas hume., jones, lawes, le roy,
mace, maynard, morley, pilkington,...





To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html


[LUTE] Re: pacoloni on youtube

2009-08-27 Thread Stuart Walsh



The Bacheler Consort plays Pacoloni :

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OJa0byWuhpU


Very stylish playing. Is the cittern part derived from a lute part?



Stuart




To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html



No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com 
Version: 8.5.409 / Virus Database: 270.13.67/2326 - Release Date: 08/25/09 18:07:00


  





[LUTE] Re: Edward Martin/who knows?

2009-08-27 Thread demery

Quite right, Dana, but if memory serves Milan introduces the 6 Pavanas
by saying that the next six fantasias are pavanas. The there's the
problem of pavans being generally in duple and some of the Milan
pavanas are in triple.

I am away from my copy of milan, so I cant confirm your memorys yea or
nay; but no matter, the issue is one of performance practice.  All
renaissance 'artists' had to contend with the conservative nature of the
church; anything 'new' was risque (just ask copernicus or galileo).  The
natural result was constant references to antiquity, and thematic
borrowing from the works of your contemporaries to an extent that startles
moderns who are used to the constrictions of copyright.  The quodlibet
form seen at the end of the 15c takes this to an absurd level which is
seen in many of the works of PDQ Bach and also in musical medleys.

Pavanna are dances, they are slow dances with the steps taken on the
tactus, typically one step per modern measure.  Lots of time for slow
graceful showing off by the strutting peacocks.  No matter if the tactus
is subdivided triply or duply.

Fantasias can work as pavannas, but when new, they lose a bit of
allusional power.  A piece well known as the king of spain evokes an
expectation of his appearance when the shalms and sackbuts blare it out. 
Decades later we see the like in the elizabethan court music with its many
pieces dedicated to court personages such as the Earl of Essex (his pavan,
his galliarde).

Fantasias in various forms are to be expected, forms are a useful
compositional restriction, guidelines to work within. But the essencial
freedom of a Fantasia lies in its theme(s), original matter, treated
whimsically; showing all the the art of the composer (hopefully sufficient
art to leave room for the performers art).

Dances often have structure, with sections needing repeat here, but not
there because of the choreography.  The use of the bar is very irregular
in this music from its inception, section marking is often unclear, even
well into the editions of Playford; having a choreography is an immense
help to decideing what sections need repeats; sometimes a lyric will serve
the same purpose.  Accidents of history deny us complete knowledge of the
choreographies for all dance music, in some cases we have worthy
choreographies begging for suitable music (eg, Mdm Sosilias Allemande). 
In some cases we have the challenge of reconciling music to choreography
where typos are suspect (Arbeau Bransle de la guerre, over the page turn
an obvious pick-up note is not composited on the preceding page where is
should have been but instead leads off the next and produces one-too-many
notes and much confusion for all).
--
Dana Emery



To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html


[LUTE] Re: Any hints on how to develop improvisational ability?

2009-08-27 Thread demery

There are specific skills you need to be a professional

yes, but, what kind of professional?

even if you could, as some of
the great cornetto players can, improvise in the style of Bassano and
others, this would definitely not land you a job.

In itself, perhaps not, but one doesnt get to that level of performance
without other skills developing too.  Would you have this young lady (or
any player for that matter) be less rounded musically?  Luckily, improv is
a skill one can practice in the mind, with the ever-present voice as well
as when other instruments come to hand.

Further, there is work for soloists as well as the regular players in an
orchestra, band, or ensemble; I note the work of George Weigand and
consorts he has played with, also the Baltimore Consort and others. 
Lutenists are not limited to careers playing continuo, there is other
work; and artful improv (playing 'new musicke' as well as olde) was
respected and considered for appointments.  How can it help to scant a
long-acknowledged historical performance practice?

I am thinking of the several Mozart Concertos with empty staves needing
cadenzas; also dixieland and jazz where improv is expected of soloists. 
Consider that that particular skill didnt hurt Mozarts reputation any.

Improv is lots of fun and a reward in itself that one needs no job to
enjoy; the technical work that leads to such facility as allows
experimentation as one plays should also be a part of the workout for
anyone, pro or amateur, aspiring to mastery of an instrument.
--
Dana Emery



To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html


[LUTE] Re: Any hints on how to develop improvisational ability?

2009-08-27 Thread Daniel Winheld
  However, her lute teacher recently pointed out to her that if she 
hopes to play the lute professionally in the future she will need to 
become much more proficient in playing improvisationally.

Interesting; the unquestioned linkage to a professional lutenist's 
career with improvisational skills. As was  pointed out by David 
Tayler- one of the very high functioning professionals on this list- 
improv skills are not the first requirement for a professional 
career- but sight reading ability is. STEP AWAY FROM THE TABULATURE! 
Tab is a monumentally ingenious  indispensable system for notating  
preserving lute SOLOS, but dependence on it will cripple your 
daughter for working with our fellow musicians. Absolute comfort  
ease with the notational systems is a must; start with G lute, two 
staves, move on to A lute- (which gets a foot in the door for later A 
theorbo reading  a step to Baroque guitar), figured  unfigured 
bass, learn some of the C clefs, and perhaps also D lute tuning- each 
new step strengthens the previous abilities and enables the next, 
which extends the transpositional abilities- extremely useful for 
song accompaniments with different singers as well as various 
ensembles up to orchestral levels. I would advise getting a theorbo 
and/or archlute as soon as practically possible; the pros on here can 
certainly weigh in here on that step.

Now about improvisation- a very loaded term- ranging from inserting a 
few passing notes  cadential figures here and there to on-the-spot 
wholly decorated and divisioned repeats of pavans  galliards where 
such repeats are not already written out, and other abilities up to 
freely improvised fantasias. Improvisational skills are learned 
skills- but of course some people learn them faster and more 
easily/consciously than others. But anyone who loves and plays music 
can learn them, and how far one goes is as dependent on time and hard 
work as talent. Immersion helps. Pick the passamezzo antico, for 
example- say Adrien LeRoy's well known one- play it over and over, 
perhaps with other musicians. Study his more shorter ornamented 
version. Eventually one can't help doing little bits like breaking 
chords, adding some passing notes, etc. Treat it like the 12 bar 
blues of the Renaissance.  Now take these basic passamezzo chord 
changes- as well the Folia, moderno, and others- memorize those basic 
chord changes and learn them in all keys and positions, until the 
whole fingerboard comes under control.

For more advanced work, and more sophisticated music, the books are 
out there- Diego Ortiz, Sylvestro Ganassi (Fontegara- enough recorder 
divisions to make your head spin; and the Regola Rubertino- viol and 
some lute material). A superb course of study is Christopher 
Simpson's The Division Viol. Other important works are Thomas 
Morely's book- forget the exact title wording Plaine  Easie 
Introduction to Practical Musick.

I'm losing focus  rambling- others will no doubt submit more  
better suggestions- but your daughter has a world of fun  hard work 
ahead of her.

Dan



















-- 



To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html


[LUTE] Re: Any hints on how to develop improvisational ability?

2009-08-27 Thread howard posner
On Aug 26, 2009, at 6:17 AM, Christopher Witmer wrote:

 s improvisational ability something that you either have or you
 don't? Or is it something that can be learned? Are there any tips
 concerning how my daughter could most effectively approach this?

I'm assuming the skills we're talking about involve ornamenting or
creating an accompaniment, rather than inventing music out of whole
cloth.  A lot of this amounts to connecting dots -- recognizing
harmonic and melodic patterns and adding a few notes to get from one
point to another.  Eventually the short bridge patterns can turn into
longer improvisations, of course.

What it takes to develop the skill depends on what the student
already knows.  Does she recognize ornamentation when she sees it?
Or are all notes created equal for her?

Here are some things she can do:

1.  Compare different ornamented versions of a melodies (e.g.
Elslein, Innsbruck, Lord Willoughby, Ruggero, Light My Fire)

2.  Learn or listen to different versions of variations on ground
basses: the Bergamasca is a a good place to start because it's so
harmonically simple, and there are lots of them out there, so a
student can learn a hundred ways of getting from I to IV to V to 1,
but there are enough passamezzos and Greensleeves to a Ground and
similar things to keep someone busy for a long time.

3.  One of the more valuable exercises, though more difficult, is to
take an ornamented ornamented or florid line and simplify it to a
basic melody.

4.  Learn to read figures and play continuo.  Looking at editorial
realizations of continuo parts can give ideas, both good and (very
often) bad, about connecting dots.


--

To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html


[LUTE] Re: Any hints on how to develop improvisational ability?

2009-08-27 Thread Nedmast2
   In the current (August 31) issue of The New Yorker, Alex Ross has an
   article called Taking Liberties: Reviving the art of classical
   improvisation.  He points out that while modern musicians specializing
   in the Renaissance and the Baroque have been leaders in improvisation,
   the idea of adding unwritten material to Classical and Romantic works
   is becoming more common.  Perhaps conservatories will begin giving more
   emphasis to this skill in their curriculae.



   Ned
 __

   --


To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html


[LUTE] Re: Edward Martin/who knows?

2009-08-27 Thread Antonio Corona
Dear Friends,

Quite right, Dana, but if memory serves Milan introduces the 6 Pavanas
by saying that the next six fantasias are pavanas. The there's the
problem of pavans being generally in duple and some of the Milan
pavanas are in triple.



Dana: I am away from my copy of milan, so I cant confirm your memorys yea or 
nay; but no matter, the issue is one of performance practice.  

I can confirm that Milan states in quite certain terms that the six following 
fantasias, as I said above, in their air and composition  are alike to the same 
pavans that are played in Italy, and, since they resemble them in everything, 
let's call them pavans. (Estas seis fantasias que se siguen, como arriba os 
dije, parecen en su aire y compostura a las mismas pavanas que en Italia se 
tañen, y pues en todo remedan a ellas, digamosles pavanas).  I believe we 
should be wary of considering these pieces as typical examples of pavans just 
from Milan's loose quotation which, besides, makes it clear that, in his view, 
they were first and foremost fantasias, to which we can add the fact that the 
sixth one (whose tune is not by him: las dos que se siguen [i.e. the last two] 
la sonada de ellas se hizo en Italia ) cannot be construed in any way as 
responding to the structure of a pavan (it has, in fact, the typical structure 
of a galliard).




Dana: All renaissance 'artists' had to contend with the conservative nature of 
the church; anything 'new' was risque (just ask copernicus or galileo).  The 
natural result was constant references to antiquity, and thematic borrowing 
from the works of your contemporaries to an extent that startles moderns who 
are used to the constrictions of copyright.  The quodlibet form seen at the end 
of the 15c takes this to an absurd level which is seen in many of the works of 
PDQ Bach and also in musical medleys.

This is not the case with Milan, he was a self-recognized amateur player and 
composer, moving in the circle of the court of Germaine de Foix, widow of 
Ferdinand, and composing and playing strictly within this aristocratic 
entourage, as it can be shown by his autobiographical book Libro del 
Cortesano (nothing to do with Castigione's).




Dana: Pavanna are dances, they are slow dances with the steps taken on the 
tactus, typically one step per modern measure.  Lots of time for slow graceful 
showing off by the strutting peacocks.  No matter if the tactus
is subdivided triply or duply.

As I stated above, the sixth pavan is by no means such a dance. As far as I 
can recall, I have never seen a pavan in triple time with the characteristic 
hemiola of the galliard. Speed has nothing to do with rythmic structure.




Dana: Fantasias in various forms are to be expected, forms are a useful 
compositional restriction, guidelines to work within. But the essencial freedom 
of a Fantasia lies in its theme(s), original matter, treated whimsically; 
showing all the the art of the composer (hopefully sufficient art to leave room 
for the performers art).

Not necessarily for Milan, who stated that fantasias are called thus because 
they proceed from the author's fancy. From this perspective, if Milan composed 
the pieces in question, they indeed proceed from his fancy, including the 
polemic sixth pavan, whose tune is not by him, but the composition over it 
(la compostura sobre la sonada de ellas es mia).




Dana: Dances often have structure, with sections needing repeat here, but not 
there because of the choreography.  The use of the bar is very irregular in 
this music from its inception, section marking is often unclear, even well into 
the editions of Playford; having a choreography is an immense help to decideing 
what sections need repeats; sometimes a lyric will serve the same purpose.  

Again, Milan´s indications leave no room for doubt: They must be played with a 
somewhat fast air [so much for the slow pavan] and it is required that they be 
played twice or thrice (Debense tañer con el compas algo apresurado, y 
requierense tañer dos o tres veces). Milan does not say you may, he states 
you must. 




Dana: Accidents of history deny us complete knowledge of the choreographies for 
all dance music, in some cases we have worthy choreographies begging for 
suitable music (eg, Mdm Sosilias Allemande).  In some cases we have the 
challenge of reconciling music to choreography where typos are suspect (Arbeau 
Bransle de la guerre, over the page turn an obvious pick-up note is not 
composited on the preceding page where is should have been but instead leads 
off the next and produces one-too-many notes and much confusion for all). Dana 
Emery

Again, I must stress that we cannot be too dogmatic and should consider each 
case from the point of view of the available evidence concerning each piece, 
composer, etc. In this particular case, I would be hard pressed to explain how 
slow pavans with the structure of a galliard could be played somewhat fast in 
general usage. 

[LUTE] Flying with lutes

2009-08-27 Thread Peter Martin
   Harking back to a recent thread about airline travel with lutes, has
   anyone ever tried Ryanair's -L-30 musical instrument transportation
   scheme?   I would love to know that it works, although frankly I'm
   deeply sceptical.  Here's what their website says:

   Sporting or musical equipment including but not limited to large
   fishing rods, golf clubs, bicycles, scooters, fencing equipment,
   surfboards, bodyboards, snowboards and skis and large musical
   instruments including but not limited to harps, double bass and drums
   are inherently unsuitable for carriage by airlines operating fast
   turnarounds such as Ryanair. However these items may be carried in the
   hold of the aircraft in addition to your personal checked baggage
   allowance upon payment of an additional charge of -L-30/30 per item,
   per one way flight via [1]www.ryanair.com or -L-40/40 per item, per one
   way flight at the airport or through a Ryanair call centre.

   Smaller musical items such as a guitar, violin or viola which exceed
   our cabin baggage dimensions may be carried in the cabin if a seat for
   it has been reserved and the appropriate fare paid. There is no checked
   baggage allowance associated with the purchase of an extra seat.
   [2]http://www.ryanair.com/site/EN/faqs.php?sect=bagquest=musicalinstru
   mentsxtmc=baggagextcr=24
   All best
   Peter
   --

References

   1. http://www.ryanair.com/
   2. 
http://www.ryanair.com/site/EN/faqs.php?sect=bagquest=musicalinstrumentsxtmc=baggagextcr=24


To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html


[LUTE] Re: Edward Martin/who nose?

2009-08-27 Thread howard posner

On Aug 27, 2009, at 12:21 PM, Antonio Corona wrote:

 They must be played with a somewhat fast air [so much for the slow  
 pavan] and it is required that they be played twice or  
 thrice (Debense tañer con el compas algo apresurado, y requierense  
 tañer dos o tres veces). Milan does not say you may, he states  
 you must.

Or  you should or you ought

 In this particular case, I would be hard pressed to explain how  
 slow pavans with the structure of a galliard could be played  
 somewhat fast in general usage.

Three beats to one step works rather like a more modern march in 6/8  
(you do have to assume that pavana really means pavana and not  
play the last two bars as a hemiola, or not care about it); the notes  
go by quite quickly but the steps are slow.
--

To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html


[LUTE] T Merula

2009-08-27 Thread Jerzy Zak

Dear All,

I'm looking for a collection of vocal music with continuo : Il Curtio  
precipitato... of 1638 by Tarquinio MERULA. Seams that the net is  
full of CD recordings but no edition, either modern score or a  
facsimile. Do you know where to get it from?


Thanks in advance,
Jurek
___



To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html


[LUTE] Temperament on the lute

2009-08-27 Thread Leonard Williams
Thank you, Richard Kolb, for the article on tempered tuning for lute
players in the latest LSA Quarterly!  I've recently read two books on the
subject of temperament:  Duffin's How Equal Temperament Ruined Harmony and
Isacoff's Temperament.  The former was fun and informative; the latter
informative but oddly insistent on the notion that fretted instuments like
the lute were always in ET because they had fretted fingerboards and there
was nothing else to be done (!).  I didn't like the latter, though he
confesses to loving the sound of pure intervals.  But (my point) neither
volume, being keyboard oriented, really gets to the point of how to do it on
a lute, so thanks again Richard, for explaining how it works with frets.
Oddly enough, perhaps synchronistically, just days before I received
the Quarterly I discovered on my own that the good and bad intervals on
my 1/6 comma meantone ren lute can be visually spotted.  [I'll use (course
#/fret letter) to designate fingerboard positions]  The major third g-b
(2f-1e) is a narrow (more pure) third: a raised fret up to a lowered fret.
The g flat-b flat (2e-1d) goes from a lowered fret to a raised one: a wide
and unpleasant third.  Similarly, one can spot good/bad minor thirds and any
other tricky intervals and adjust as needed for key.
I've found that once I have my frets set, I can tune courses 1 and 6
right on; 2 and 3 a tiny bit flat; 4 and 5 a tiny bit sharp (compared to
ET).  I test with some octaves, and, for some reason the following works for
me as a test for those strings that cross the third (3,4,5): I play the
chord 5f 4e 3d (f major) and it should sound pretty good (in my limited
experience).

Regards,
Leonard Williams
  
   /[ ]
   /   \
  |  *  |
  \_=_/




To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html


[LUTE] Re: pacoloni on youtube

2009-08-27 Thread Sean Smith


From http://tinyurl.com/nxmee2

NOVA ET ELEGANTISSIMA
IN CYTHARA LUDENDA CARMINA QUAE
VIDELICET IN SOLA CYTHARA VEL ETIAM CUM
tribus Testudinibus exhibita, mira dulcedina auiditorum possunt
oblectare, eaque omnia facilitate quam fieri potuit
summa in tyronum usum composita.
Et Primo quidem libro Passomezi, Padoani, Saltarelli, ad Joannis  
Pacoloni tabulaturas
(ut vocant) trium Testudinum, apprime congruentes, ut etiam sola  
Cythara ex

hibendi. Deinde etiam Alemandae Branles  similia. Et Secondo quidem
libro habes Cantiones Musicales quantum Cythara rei admittit
Musicae habes  iam non minus jucundas.
AUTORE FREDERICO VIAERA FRISIO.
[Fleuret]
LOVANII.
Apud Petrum Phalesium Bibliopol. Jurat. Anno 1564.
Cum Gratia  Privilegio.

Contains cittern accompaniment to the Pacaloni followed by cittern  
solos.


s




On Aug 27, 2009, at 8:50 AM, Stuart Walsh wrote:




The Bacheler Consort plays Pacoloni :

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OJa0byWuhpU


Very stylish playing. Is the cittern part derived from a lute part?



Stuart




To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html



No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 8.5.409 / Virus Database:  
270.13.67/2326 - Release Date: 08/25/09 18:07:00











[LUTE] Re: Edward Marvin/who nose?

2009-08-27 Thread howard posner
On Aug 27, 2009, at 9:29 PM, Antonio Corona wrote:

 You are quite right, but that was not the point I was trying to
 make. Rather than questioning how to manipulate the piece, I was
 trying to show the inconsistency of forcing a historic category
 into a context that contradicts it explicitly.

Maybe I'm missing the context.  By forcing a historic category etc.
do you mean playing a pavana as if it's a pavana because it's called
a pavana?  Or something else?


--

To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html


[LUTE] Re: Edward Martin/who nose?

2009-08-27 Thread Antonio Corona
Dear Howard,

You are quite right, but that was not the point I was trying to make. Rather 
than questioning how to manipulate the piece, I was trying to show the 
inconsistency of forcing a historic category into a context that contradicts it 
explicitly.

With best wishes,
Antonio



- Original Message 
From: howard posner howardpos...@ca.rr.com
To: Lute mailing list lute@cs.dartmouth.edu
Sent: Thursday, 27 August, 2009 14:40:11
Subject: [LUTE] Re: Edward Martin/who nose?


On Aug 27, 2009, at 12:21 PM, Antonio Corona wrote:

 They must be played with a somewhat fast air [so much for the slow  
 pavan] and it is required that they be played twice or  
 thrice (Debense tañer con el compas algo apresurado, y requierense  
 tañer dos o tres veces). Milan does not say you may, he states  
 you must.

Or  you should or you ought

 In this particular case, I would be hard pressed to explain how  
 slow pavans with the structure of a galliard could be played  
 somewhat fast in general usage.

Three beats to one step works rather like a more modern march in 6/8  
(you do have to assume that pavana really means pavana and not  
play the last two bars as a hemiola, or not care about it); the notes  
go by quite quickly but the steps are slow.
--

To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html