Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-02-05 Thread Ángel via mailop
On 2022-01-31 at 10:43 -0700, Geoff Mulligan wrote: > 1. If a recipient on an email message is both in the To: or Cc: and > on the mailing list, should the listserver send the message to the > recipient: > a) By default > b) Not by default (but configurable) > c) Never Yes, it

Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-02-01 Thread Jaroslaw Rafa via mailop
Dnia 31.01.2022 o godz. 19:46:25 Grant Taylor via mailop pisze: > Remember, SMTP servers operate on the SMTP envelope. > > As such, the first SMTP server would send one copy directly to the > recipient's SMTP server and another copy to the MLM's SMTP server. I was assuming that first SMTP server

Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-01-31 Thread John Levine via mailop
It appears that Geoff Mulligan via mailop said: >1. If a recipient on an email message is both in the To: or Cc: and on >the mailing list, should the listserver send the message to the recipient: > a) By default > b) Not by default (but configurable) > c) Never This is a

Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-01-31 Thread Grant Taylor via mailop
On 1/31/22 11:07 AM, Sebastian Nielsen via mailop wrote: 1: never, as the original email has already been sent to the recipient by the original server. I disagree. I /expressly/ want the copy of messages from the mailing list, /NOT/ the copy directly addressed to me. Mailman (2.x) has an

Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-01-31 Thread Grant Taylor via mailop
On 1/31/22 12:44 PM, Jaroslaw Rafa via mailop wrote: Ah, I did not assume that the mailing list server is different from the originating server. For me, the question *only* has sense when it is the same server. If they are different servers, then there is no problem at all. Remember, SMTP

Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-01-31 Thread Grant Taylor via mailop
On 1/31/22 11:31 AM, Jaroslaw Rafa via mailop wrote: The message should be delivered to list, There is a big difference in the message being delivered to the (mailing) list (manager) and the MLM re-distributing it to subscribers. The former should happen. The latter is dependent on MLM /

Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-01-31 Thread Bob Proulx via mailop
Geoff Mulligan via mailop wrote: > 1. If a recipient on an email message is both in the To: or Cc: and on the > mailing list, should the listserver send the message to the recipient: > a) By default > b) Not by default (but configurable) > c) Never If a message was sent to me

Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-01-31 Thread Mark Fletcher via mailop
On Mon, Jan 31, 2022 at 10:04 AM Geoff Mulligan via mailop < mailop@mailop.org> wrote: > 1. If a recipient on an email message is both in the To: or Cc: and on > the mailing list, should the listserver send the message to the recipient: > a) By default > b) Not by default (but

Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-01-31 Thread Jaroslaw Rafa via mailop
Dnia 31.01.2022 o godz. 20:16:11 Sebastian Nielsen via mailop pisze: > >>I would say a). > > Why? Then you end up with 3 copies of the email. > > Remember this: > You have sender's server, which we can call ServerA. > > If recipient is yourn...@example.org and list is

Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-01-31 Thread Dave Crocker via mailop
On 1/31/2022 9:43 AM, Geoff Mulligan via mailop wrote: 1. If a recipient on an email message is both in the To: or Cc: and on the mailing list, should the listserver send the message to the recipient: a) By default b) Not by default (but configurable) c) Never by default.

Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-01-31 Thread Sebastian Nielsen via mailop
>>I would say a). Why? Then you end up with 3 copies of the email. Remember this: You have sender's server, which we can call ServerA. If recipient is yourn...@example.org and list is mailingl...@examplelist.org ServerA (sender's server) will now send the email to yourn...@example.org AND

Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-01-31 Thread Jaroslaw Rafa via mailop
Dnia 31.01.2022 o godz. 10:43:52 Geoff Mulligan via mailop pisze: > 1. If a recipient on an email message is both in the To: or Cc: and > on the mailing list, should the listserver send the message to the > recipient: > a) By default > b) Not by default (but configurable) > c) Never

Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-01-31 Thread Alessandro Vesely via mailop
On Mon 31/Jan/2022 18:43:52 +0100 Geoff Mulligan via mailop wrote: 1. If a recipient on an email message is both in the To: or Cc: and on the mailing list, should the listserver send the message to the recipient: a) By default Send it by default, but let it be configurable. The

Re: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-01-31 Thread Sebastian Nielsen via mailop
:53 Till: mailop@mailop.org Ämne: [mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists 1. If a recipient on an email message is both in the To: or Cc: and on the mailing list, should the listserver send the message to the recipient: a) By default b) Not by default (but configurable) c

[mailop] 2 questions about BCC and mailing lists

2022-01-31 Thread Geoff Mulligan via mailop
1. If a recipient on an email message is both in the To: or Cc: and on the mailing list, should the listserver send the message to the recipient: a) By default b) Not by default (but configurable) c) Never 2. If a mailing list is in the BCC: should a message be delivered to the