[MCN-L] Different Copyrights / Different Image Resolutions

2014-03-12 Thread Kate Blanch
Hello MCN, This may be a rather dense question regarding copyright law...but as it's outside my area of expertise I figured this community could provide a great reference point. My own research is not turning up an good answers/examples either! Do any institutions assign different copyright

[MCN-L] Different Copyrights / Different Image Resolutions

2014-03-12 Thread Amalyah Keshet
Kate: If an image is a protected (copyrighted) work, it doesn't matter what size or format it's in. It's protected, and the copyright holder has the exclusive right to reproduce and distribute it and to make derivatives of it. (Thumbnail images for purposes of identification, for example in

[MCN-L] Different Copyrights / Different Image Resolutions

2014-03-12 Thread Shana West
Technically, if your institution holds the copyright, you can license derivative works however you like (and cropping, resolution changes are technically derivations). BUT, I think it would be difficult to enforce resolution as a derivative work if you are putting both out on the web. I don't

[MCN-L] FW: Different Copyrights / Different Image Resolutions

2014-03-12 Thread Amalyah Keshet
I should clarify that I am referring to the museum-created photograph/digital image only, ignoring for the moment the copyright status of the underlying work of art appearing in the photograph. Amalyah -Original Message- From: mcn-l-bounces at mcn.edu

[MCN-L] Different Copyrights / Different Image Resolutions

2014-03-12 Thread Edson, Michael
It's a great question and a fascinating topic, Kate. I've cross-posted this question over to the Open Knowledge Foundation's Open-GLAM mailing list. (I'm pretty sure the discussions are available in a public archive, I just can't put my finger on the link right now. D'oh!) As a point of

[MCN-L] Different Copyrights / Different Image Resolutions

2014-03-12 Thread Peter B. Hirtle
I think I see two possible misunderstandings in your original question. First, there is only one copyright here: the copyright in the photograph of the urn. (I am going to assume, like Amalyah, that the Greek urn itself is ancient and now in the public domain.) A medium resolution version is

[MCN-L] Different Copyrights / Different Image Resolutions

2014-03-12 Thread Virginia Rutledge
Hello All -- It's always worth noting that a fair use can be made of any image, no matter theresolution or size. Whether and how an institution chooses to control access to images of works in its care is of course a different question. Michael points to some great examples of institutions