Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-09 Thread Marshall Booth
John Freer wrote: On the VMI for my 92 W140, there is the following entry which takes this particular MB way out of the original warranty time/mileage. I always wondered about this. Wiring Harness $2,800.00 90K May-01 Mercedes often extended the warranty to ORIGINAL

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-09 Thread LarryT
://members.rennlist.com/webercarbs Porsche Road Test http://members.rennlist.com/roadtest/ . - Original Message - From: dave walton [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Mercedes Discussion List mercedes@okiebenz.com Sent: Friday, June 08, 2007 5:50 PM Subject: Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-09 Thread tom savage
John Freer wrote: On the VMI for my 92 W140, there is the following entry which takes this particular MB way out of the original warranty time/mileage. I always wondered about this. Didn't Rick have an aftermarket warranty on that car, with coverage beyond 100k miles? Tom

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-09 Thread John Freer
Yes, but it wasn't with MB. It was one of those insurance type deals underwritten by First Extended Service Corporation. The VMI only shows work done under the MB warranty or recalls. On 6/8/07, tom savage [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: John Freer wrote: On the VMI for my 92 W140, there is the

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-09 Thread Jim Cathey
It didn't seem to be a problem anywhere else, only on wiring under the hood. I believe it was the heat of the engine compartment that triggered the self-destruction. Probably the insulation was designed to degrade in the sunlight (UV light) Consider how accelerated life testing is conducted:

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-09 Thread Jim Cathey
self-destruction. Probably the insulation was designed to degrade in the sunlight (UV light) like trash bags are now, I'm glad they did this, those piles of automotive wiring harnesses strewn along the roadsides were getting pretty bad. The copper takes on a pretty verdigris and blends in

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-09 Thread John Freer
One other point that was of interest to me. An MB salesperson in Houston told me that MB had always tested for high heat in CA in places such as Death Valley, etc. While temps can run upwards of 115 degrees, it is a dry heat with very little humidity. He said that he began seeing test mules

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-09 Thread dave walton
/webercarbs Porsche Road Test http://members.rennlist.com/roadtest/ . - Original Message - From: dave walton [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Mercedes Discussion List mercedes@okiebenz.com Sent: Friday, June 08, 2007 5:50 PM Subject: Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost I had to replace

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-09 Thread OK Don
Which is why my (current) cut-off year is '93. I don't plan to even look at anything more recent than that. It's time to start stocking up on these cars for the future --- BUT when it comes to corporate responsibility and dedication to their customers, MB let the shit roll downhill and their

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-09 Thread Marshall Booth
John Freer wrote: One other point that was of interest to me. An MB salesperson in Houston told me that MB had always tested for high heat in CA in places such as Death Valley, etc. While temps can run upwards of 115 degrees, it is a dry heat with very little humidity. He said that he began

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Tarek Elshenawy
To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost Let us just hope that they did a good job of it. I had a Chevy tranny rebuilt to the tune of $1200 (incl r r) and it didn't last 50K miles before it needed it again. I don't mind paying good money for something

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread LarryT
A Bennell [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Mercedes Discussion List mercedes@okiebenz.com Sent: Thursday, June 07, 2007 5:38 PM Subject: Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost Let us just hope that they did a good job of it. I had a Chevy tranny rebuilt to the tune of $1200 (incl r r

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Allan Streib
LarryT [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Am I being unreasonable? Shouldn't the transmission on a $50,000 car (new price) last for 300K or 500K without being opened for work? And of course, the W140s cost twice that much when new - and they have things like wiring harnesses that self-destruct?

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Jim Cathey
miles. Afterall, wire is not something that *wears out*. How many of us have wiring in our house that 30,50 or 80 years old? Except for a poor choice of materials at some times, it lasts and lasts. Blame the eco-nazis for this one. They _had_ good wire that lasted and lasted, but somebody

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Allan Streib
Jim Cathey [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Blame the eco-nazis for this one. They _had_ good wire that lasted and lasted, but somebody legislated a biodegradable wiring harness. Same problem with paints, and, I'm told, galvanization. Good point -- when environmental laws are passed by people who

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread LarryT
/roadtest/ . - Original Message - From: Allan Streib [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Mercedes Discussion List mercedes@okiebenz.com Sent: Friday, June 08, 2007 9:55 AM Subject: Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost LarryT [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Am I being unreasonable? Shouldn't

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread dave walton
/ . - Original Message - From: R A Bennell [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Mercedes Discussion List mercedes@okiebenz.com Sent: Thursday, June 07, 2007 5:38 PM Subject: Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost Let us just hope that they did a good job of it. I had a Chevy tranny rebuilt to the tune

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Loren Faeth
if an improvement cannot be measured then it cannot be an improvement. That is in direct conflict with the founders and foundations of TQ. Dr. Deming said, Some things are unknown and unknowable. This means that some things should be done, even though they can't be measured.

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Alex Chamberlain
On 6/8/07, Loren Faeth [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: In Wilton's position in life, the peace of mind of rebuilding the trans outweighs the cost. The good news is that he sees a noticeable improvement. Lets hope the 350SDL serves him as well as he has served us. Hear, hear! Alex Chamberlain

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread R A Bennell
To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost You wrote:I don't mind paying good money for something so long as I get what I pay for. Couldn't agree more. You know, ATs have been built in the same basic configuration for something like 60-75 years. I

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread LarryT
mercedes@okiebenz.com Sent: Friday, June 08, 2007 10:38 AM Subject: Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost if an improvement cannot be measured then it cannot be an improvement. That is in direct conflict with the founders and foundations of TQ. Dr. Deming said, Some things

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread ned kleinhenz
Blaming eco-nazi's is just a cop-out. I still blame Damlier-(whatever) for the self destructing wiring. With their large engineering staff, someone at MBZ had to know the characteristics of the selected wiring. And MBZ decided that they did not care, or maybe they realized the oportunity to

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread LarryT
AM Subject: Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost Jim Cathey [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Blame the eco-nazis for this one. They _had_ good wire that lasted and lasted, but somebody legislated a biodegradable wiring harness. Same problem with paints, and, I'm told, galvanization

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread andrew strasfogel
This sounds like another one of those urban myths - and I also object ot the trivialization of the term nazi and all the heinous acts they committed. Government regulators are NOT nazis in ANY sense of the word. If your allegation were true, than why don't ALL wiring harnesses degrade rather

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Alex Chamberlain
Somebody here probably knows RWD Volvos better than I, but I believe that early-'90s 240s have the same problem, so it's not just Mercedes. On 6/8/07, andrew strasfogel [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: This sounds like another one of those urban myths - and I also object ot the trivialization of the

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Terry Geiger
Subject: Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost Somebody here probably knows RWD Volvos better than I, but I believe that early-'90s 240s have the same problem, so it's not just Mercedes. On 6/8/07, andrew strasfogel [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: This sounds like another one of those

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Allan Streib
Terry Geiger [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: It didn't seem to be a problem anywhere else, only on wiring under the hood. I believe it was the heat of the engine compartment that triggered the self-destruction. Probably the insulation was designed to degrade in the sunlight (UV light) like trash

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Marshall Booth
andrew strasfogel wrote: This sounds like another one of those urban myths... SNIP If your allegation were true, than why don't ALL wiring harnesses degrade rather than jsut some Mercedes models?? Not a myth at all. The biodegradable wiring harnesses were required on all NEW (redesigned)

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Dwight E. Giles, Jr
Marshall, Welcome back. Do I read this correctly that no diesels had biodegradable wiring? Thanks, Dwight Dwight E. Giles, Jr. 1979 240D-250K + miles 1990 300D 2.5t 135K miles Wickford, RI -Original Message- The biodegradable wiring harnesses were required on all NEW (redesigned)

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread dave walton
I had to replace the engine and glow plug harness on my 94 S350 (W140 diesel). The failure is not subtle. The insulation first cracks and then flakes away leaving exposed copper. While the German Government may have mandated the use of unproven technology, it did not prevent Mercedes from

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Marshall Booth
Dwight E. Giles, Jr wrote: Marshall, Welcome back. Do I read this correctly that no diesels had biodegradable wiring? The late '94 and all '95 124 E300Ds (with OM606 engines) and the 140 diesels had defective wiring harnesses. Marshall -- Marshall Booth Ph.D. Ass't Prof. (ret.) Univ of

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Marshall Booth
dave walton wrote: I had to replace the engine and glow plug harness on my 94 S350 (W140 diesel). The failure is not subtle. The insulation first cracks and then flakes away leaving exposed copper. While the German Government may have mandated the use of unproven technology, it did not prevent

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread Dwight E. Giles, Jr
Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost Dwight E. Giles, Jr wrote: Marshall, Welcome back. Do I read this correctly that no diesels had biodegradable wiring? The late '94 and all '95 124 E300Ds (with OM606 engines) and the 140 diesels had defective wiring

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-08 Thread John Freer
On the VMI for my 92 W140, there is the following entry which takes this particular MB way out of the original warranty time/mileage. I always wondered about this. Wiring Harness $2,800.00 90K May-01 John Freer On 6/8/07, Marshall Booth [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: dave

Re: [MBZ] WAS 91 350SDL SEEMS TO BE AT Repair Cost

2007-06-07 Thread R A Bennell
Let us just hope that they did a good job of it. I had a Chevy tranny rebuilt to the tune of $1200 (incl r r) and it didn't last 50K miles before it needed it again. I don't mind paying good money for something so long as I get what I pay for. If you get someone who knows what they are doing