Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread John Freer
On Tue, Dec 2, 2008 at 10:10 PM, John Robbins [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: John Freer wrote: That's a good idea Allan. Also helps keep the carbon buildup at bay. I miss that feature on the CDI. At 35 mph around town and I want to shift down to 4th, it goes right down to 2nd as I have no control

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Donald Snook
Kaleb wrote: do they not make olds anymore? I assume you are kidding. Otherwise, you can't possibly claim to be knowledgeable in the car business. In case you are not kidding, yes, GM ended the Oldsmobile division in December of 2000 (which precipitated my desire to go to Law school).

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Donald Snook
Rusty wrote: They are killing Pontiac next. I have heard that rumor since they killed Oldsmobile. If GM were to shut down one of its divisions, my opinion is that it would be Buick not Pontiac. Donald H. Snook ___ http://www.okiebenz.com For new and used

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Allan Streib
Donald Snook [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Rusty wrote: They are killing Pontiac next. I have heard that rumor since they killed Oldsmobile. If GM were to shut down one of its divisions, my opinion is that it would be Buick not Pontiac. My opinion is that all those divisions are part of their

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Loren Faeth
If they shut down Buick, what would all the greyhairs drive? I see a LOT more Bricks on the road than Ponchos. If I were running GM, I'd close Brick, Poncho and Jimmy At 08:20 AM 12/3/2008, you wrote: Rusty wrote: They are killing Pontiac next. I have heard that rumor since they killed

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Loren Faeth
I agree, then when the economy rebounds, they could do like Toada, and take a chevy, put a gold colored logo on it and change the interior a little and call it a luxury Chevus, and sell them for $5000 to $10,000 more. Or they could call it a Lexolet My opinion is that all those divisions

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Mitch Haley
Allan Streib wrote: My opinion is that all those divisions are part of their problem. They should have one car/truck division, Chevrolet, and one luxury division, Cadillac. I think Buick should have been the first to go. Pontiac has been the excitement division, with Firebird, Fiero,

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Allan Streib
Mitch Haley [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: GMC has been pointless for years, Chevy trucks have plenty of trim levels to choose from. In the light truck market I agree, though I think GMC has a heavy/commercial market that I'm not sure Chevy competes in. Allan

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Mitch Haley
Allan Streib wrote: In the light truck market I agree, though I think GMC has a heavy/commercial market that I'm not sure Chevy competes in. I'm not sure what the entire lineup includes, but a Chevy Kodiak and GMC Topkick are still the same thing, and they both have W-series and T-series

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Allan Streib
Mitch Haley [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: I'm not sure what the entire lineup includes, but a Chevy Kodiak and GMC Topkick are still the same thing, and they both have W-series and T-series medium duty truck lines. http://www.chevrolet.com/mediumduty/ http://www.gmc.com/mediumduty/index.jsp

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Loren Faeth
GMC Truck was merged with White years ago. Volvo bought White GMC. White used to make Freightliner, and when Freightliner went independent, White struggled. DB courted White for a while, but failed to buy White. White then merged with GMC. Ford sold the Louisville line to DB, and it was

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Curt Raymond
spin off or be sold, but who would buy it? -Curt Date: Wed, 3 Dec 2008 08:17:21 -0600 From: Donald Snook [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper To: 'Mercedes Discussion List' mercedes@okiebenz.com Message-ID:     [EMAIL PROTECTED] Content-Type: text

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Curt Raymond
Gotta have a hip and trendy line too, Scion has made Toyota a bunch of money. Saturn used to be hip and trendy... -Curt Date: Wed, 03 Dec 2008 09:27:30 -0500 From: Allan Streib [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper To: Mercedes Discussion List

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Donald Snook
Loren wrote: If I were running GM, I'd close Brick, Poncho and Jimmy By jimmy do you mean GMC Truck? That would be a HUGE mistake. GMC and Chevy trucks have been one of the few bright spots for GM in the last decade or so. The GMC trucks are more profitable than Chevy. The trucks and SUV's

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Donald Snook
Mitch wrote: Now that it's GMC, Chevy, Caddy, Buick and Pontiac, I'd say dump Buick, let the fogies decide if they want to buy downmarket Chevy or upmarket Caddy. Keep Pontiac, concentrating on keeping the styling fresh and try to give the Pontiacs a bit more performance than the Chevys. Don't

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Allan Streib
Curt Raymond [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Gotta have a hip and trendy line too, Scion has made Toyota a bunch of money. You really think the name, and not the vehicle, is what made the difference? The box on wheels thing would not have done well if it had a Toyota badge? Allan -- 1983 300d

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Allan Streib
Donald Snook [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Don't forget about Saturn. The new Aura (really just a Us version of the Opel) was supposed to rejuvenate GM. Is that what that is? Why not say so? Invent a new name, nobody knows WTF it is. I drove an Open Corsa in Denmark last time I was there, a very

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread pm7088
Anybody remember what the functional difference between a Chevy and GMC truck was 60 years ago? Hint; What made GMC a 'Premium' Chevrolet? Pete -- Original message -- From: Loren Faeth [EMAIL PROTECTED] GMC Truck was merged with White years ago. Volvo bought

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Donald Snook
Loren wrote: the light and medium Chev/GMC trucks are the same except the badges. That is not quite true. There are some GMC only features and options. But, you are right for the most part, they are identical. One other difference is the dealership. When we had GMC, we had customers who

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Curt Raymond
suspect loads of the hipsters buying the TC would never buy a Camry. -Curt Date: Wed, 03 Dec 2008 11:44:04 -0500 From: Allan Streib [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper To: Mercedes Discussion List mercedes@okiebenz.com Message-ID: [EMAIL PROTECTED

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-03 Thread Alex Chamberlain
On Wed, Dec 3, 2008 at 8:33 AM, Donald Snook [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Also, I think GM owns Saab. Of course, the market presence here in the US is minimal, You're kidding, right? Been to the Pacific Northwest or New England lately? I see as many older Saabs here as older BMWs or Benzes,

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Donald Snook
Loren wrote: I have yet to see an American car go over 400k without the engine being worn out. When I was at the dealership, my wife worked at a local wholesale pharmacy. They delivered drugs to hospitals/clinics/labs etc. all over the Midwest. I convinced them that they should get their cars

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Donald Snook
Ok Don wrote: I might find out if they wil go the distance - one of them has over 330,000 miles already, but sure doesn't act like it. The other one has got to be getting close. I am convinced that those are the MB diesels that will set the mileage marks. And they are such fun to drive, it

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Mitch Haley
Donald Snook wrote: We did replace 1-2 transmissions, and of course, alternators, water pumps, and various other bits. How much did a water pump on a quad 4 run, $700? Did they have any 2.4 Twin Cams before they started buying V6s? Mitch. ___

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Allan Streib
Donald Snook [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Your 300D 2.5 also proves one of Marshall's old mantras wrong. He said Mercedes diesel auto trannys only lasted 150-200,000. I know at least one of yours has (at least) 250,000 on the original tranny. I wonder how much of that statistic is influenced by

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Loren Faeth
It sounds like they racked up a lot of highway miles. over the road fleet usage is different than ordinary usage too. What was the average mileage of all cars in your service dept? At 08:33 AM 12/2/2008, you wrote: Loren wrote: I have yet to see an American car go over 400k without the

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Tom Hargrave
PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Donald Snook Sent: Tuesday, December 02, 2008 8:34 AM To: 'Mercedes Discussion List' Subject: Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper Loren wrote: I have yet to see an American car go over 400k without the engine being worn out

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Allan Streib
Tom Hargrave [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Years ago, the local Dominos franchise maintained a fleet of delivery cars. We settled on trucks bought Toyotas, Fords Nissans over the years. Of all of them, the Fords lasted ran the longest with many of them going well over 300,000 miles! Some ran

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Tom Hargrave
Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Allan Streib Sent: Tuesday, December 02, 2008 9:05 AM To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper Tom Hargrave [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: Years ago, the local Dominos

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Mitch Haley
Tom Hargrave wrote: Years ago, the local Dominos franchise maintained a fleet of delivery cars. We settled on trucks bought Toyotas, Fords Nissans over the years. Of all of them, the Fords lasted ran the longest with many of them going well over 300,000 miles! I guess somehow the

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Tom Hargrave
Of Mitch Haley Sent: Tuesday, December 02, 2008 9:32 AM To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper Tom Hargrave wrote: Years ago, the local Dominos franchise maintained a fleet of delivery cars. We settled on trucks bought Toyotas, Fords Nissans

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Donald Snook
Mitch wrote: How much did a water pump on a quad 4 run, $700? Did they have any 2.4 Twin Cams before they started buying V6s? I don't think the water pump was that much. I would guess more like $400. I don't remember any of the 2.4 engines. I liked the Quad 4 and the 3.1 V6, so usually

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Donald Snook
Loren wrote: What was the average mileage of all cars in your service dept? I have no idea. We had such a broad spectrum of vehicles. We had practically new GMC pickups (we used to be the GMC dealer and the factory authorized us to do warranty work for 2 years after we sold the cars), we also

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Curt Raymond
buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper To: 'Mercedes Discussion List' mercedes@okiebenz.com Message-ID: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Content-Type: text/plain;    charset=windows-1250 Years ago, the local Dominos franchise maintained a fleet of delivery cars. We settled on trucks bought Toyotas, Fords

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Kaleb C. Striplin
do they not make olds anymore? Donald Snook wrote: Loren wrote: What was the average mileage of all cars in your service dept? I have no idea. We had such a broad spectrum of vehicles. We had practically new GMC pickups (we used to be the GMC dealer and the factory authorized us to do

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Mitch Haley
Donald Snook wrote: I don't think the water pump was that much. I would guess more like $400. OK, thanks for the info. When I bought my 2.4L 1997 Achieva I had assumed the water pump would be a 20 minute job like a twin cam Saturn, then after I owned it I started hearing stories like after

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Mitch Haley
Kaleb C. Striplin wrote: do they not make olds anymore? IIRC, the 2004 model year was the end of the line. I'd kind of like to have a 4 cylinder, five speed 2004 Alero, but the 4cyl is kind of rare, and the 5sp are as common as hen's teeth. Mitch. ___

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Rusty Cullens
Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper Kaleb C. Striplin wrote: do they not make olds anymore? IIRC, the 2004 model year was the end of the line. I'd kind of like to have a 4 cylinder, five speed 2004 Alero, but the 4cyl is kind of rare, and the 5sp are as common as hen's teeth. Mitch

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread John Freer
On Tue, Dec 2, 2008 at 6:39 AM, Donald Snook [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Ok Don wrote: I might find out if they wil go the distance - one of them has over 330,000 miles already, but sure doesn't act like it. The other one has got to be getting close. I am convinced that those are the MB

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Allan Streib
John Freer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I think what Marshall said was that the life of a transmission was directly tied to the number of shifts it had to make during its life time. This is why I keep mine in S around town. Eliminates the frequent shifting in and out of 4th gear. Allan --

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Alex Chamberlain
-800-741-5252 Fax 770-454-9745 - Original Message - From: Mitch Haley [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Mercedes Discussion List mercedes@okiebenz.com Sent: Tuesday, December 02, 2008 1:40 PM Subject: Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper Kaleb C. Striplin wrote: do

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread John Freer
On Tue, Dec 2, 2008 at 7:54 PM, Allan Streib [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: John Freer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I think what Marshall said was that the life of a transmission was directly tied to the number of shifts it had to make during its life time. This is why I keep mine in S around town.

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Steve MacSween
PROTECTED] To: Mercedes Discussion List mercedes@okiebenz.com Sent: Tuesday, December 02, 2008 1:40 PM Subject: Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper Kaleb C. Striplin wrote: do they not make olds anymore? IIRC, the 2004 model year was the end of the line. I'd kind

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread John Robbins
John Freer wrote: That's a good idea Allan. Also helps keep the carbon buildup at bay. I miss that feature on the CDI. At 35 mph around town and I want to shift down to 4th, it goes right down to 2nd as I have no control over the gear selection at low speed. You don't have the tip tronic or

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-02 Thread Tom Hargrave
@okiebenz.com Sent: 12/2/08 9:54 PM Subject: Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper John Freer [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I think what Marshall said was that the life of a transmission was directly tied to the number of shifts it had to make during its life time. This is why I keep

[MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-01 Thread Donald Snook
Loren wrote: It is all in perspective. A 50k mile caddy is 1/3 spent, if the average lifespan of a caddy is 150k miles. That would leave you 100k useable miles. An SDL with 250k and no rust is 1/4 spent, figuring a lifespan of 1 million. That leaves 750k to go. The cost of ownership of the

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-01 Thread John Robbins
Loren wrote: It is all in perspective. A 50k mile caddy is 1/3 spent, if the average lifespan of a caddy is 150k miles. That would leave you 100k useable miles. An SDL with 250k and no rust is 1/4 spent, figuring a lifespan of 1 million. That leaves 750k to go. The cost of ownership of the SDL

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-01 Thread E M
I think a million miles is being a bit generous. Even if the engine does make it, how many transmissions will it cost you, not to mention all the other bits that fail with age and miles. I've read where cars have a million on them, and had the engine freshened a few times. That's not going a

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-01 Thread Tom Hargrave
256-656-1924 -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of E M Sent: Monday, December 01, 2008 6:21 PM To: Mercedes Discussion List Subject: Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper I think a million miles is being a bit generous

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-01 Thread Loren Faeth
Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper I think a million miles is being a bit generous. Even if the engine does make it, how many transmissions will it cost you, not to mention all the other bits that fail with age and miles. I've read where cars have a million on them, and had the engine freshened

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-01 Thread Kevin Kraly
I only have whatever money I got from the previous car. If you can keep that going, you're lucky! I've been doing that with my RC fixers lately. Hopefully, I can keep things going for quite a while and basically have a self-sustaining hobby. It would take way more luck to do it with

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-01 Thread Kaleb C. Striplin
and now its in my junkyard. Still trying to decide what to do with that car, fix it or part it Loren Faeth wrote: My observation is that few American cars are driven until worn out. they end up in the junkyard with around 150k miles, or sooner if wrecked. To be fair, the average MB ends up

Re: [MBZ] Car buying Calculus was Re: OT 87 Isuzu trooper

2008-12-01 Thread OK Don
My observation is that a lot of car's drive trains will last longer than the rest of the car if they receive proper maintenance. The rest of the car will fall apart around the drive train. The MB seems to be the exception to that - in my limited experience. I agree with Loren on the SDL - it's an