Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-10-18 Thread Mathieu Bouchard
On Sat, 17 Oct 2009, Jonathan Wilkes wrote: --- On Sat, 10/17/09, Mathieu Bouchard ma...@artengine.ca wrote: in the end, people still choose to spend their time with certain art and not certain other art, and this is implicitly a judgement of value. those judgements are both relativables and

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-10-17 Thread Mathieu Bouchard
On Wed, 7 Oct 2009, Fernando Gadea wrote: Mathieu Bouchard escribió: Is it because it makes the music any better, or because what musicians are after is not just the music but also the dance that a musician makes with the instrument? In a physical instrument the position of the body when

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-10-10 Thread Fred Smith
I am not qualified to comment on this discussion, but I still will. Years ago I read the Ostertag article (saw him in Berkeley in '95 at Bean Benders and he was amazing), and this line stuck out: Of all the ways that computers have been applied to music, sampling has had the most radical impact.

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-10-06 Thread Fernando Gadea
Sory for the big delay, but I was really busy. I will try to answer in between lines: Mathieu Bouchard escribió: On Tue, 8 Sep 2009, Fernando Gadea wrote: So they say that good piano players play with the whole body (same for guitar or any physical instrument, I guess). Is it because it

[PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-21 Thread Mathieu Bouchard
On Tue, 8 Sep 2009, Fernando Gadea wrote: So they say that good piano players play with the whole body (same for guitar or any physical instrument, I guess). Is it because it makes the music any better, or because what musicians are after is not just the music but also the dance that a

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-21 Thread Jaime Oliver
On Mon, Sep 21, 2009 at 1:52 PM, Mathieu Bouchard ma...@artengine.cawrote: On Tue, 8 Sep 2009, Fernando Gadea wrote: So they say that good piano players play with the whole body (same for guitar or any physical instrument, I guess). Is it because it makes the music any better, or because

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-09 Thread fred-ordi
of course music has to do with body and feedbacks ; knowing that the arbitrary distance between body and mind is quite cultural, what about cyborgs and cyborg's bodies ? fred chris clepper wrote: On Tue, Sep 8, 2009 at 10:39 PM, ydego...@gmail.com mailto:ydego...@gmail.com ydego...@gmail.com

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-09 Thread babsyco babsyco
Hey guys, I just wanna say that in terms of live computer music, to me lack of physical interaction makes it totally boring for me. When I've mentioned this to some artists who's 'live performance' consists of them staring at a computer screen hitting buttons-maybe there'll be some arbitrary

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-09 Thread Andy Farnell
On Wed, 9 Sep 2009 14:43:49 + babsyco babsyco babs...@hotmail.com wrote: If that's your attitude fine, but in that case what's the point of a live performance at all It's an fair question. The answer to that, for those of us that do livecoding type perfomances, is the accompanying visual

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-09 Thread Fernando Gadea
john saylor escribi: hola hola john thx for your thoughtful post. thankyou for reading :) On Tue, Sep 8, 2009 at 10:09 PM, Fernando Gadea fga...@gmail.com wrote: 1- physical instruments well, yes; body, rhythm,

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-09 Thread Gabriel Vinazza
She writes continually like a long nozzle spraying the air, and she argues continually; theres is nothing I can say that is really not something else, so, I stop saying and finally she argues herself out the door saying something like — I´m not trying to impress my self upon you. Charles

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-09 Thread Daniel Wilcox
Message: 2 Date: Wed, 9 Sep 2009 16:19:09 -0300 From: Gabriel Vinazza gabevina...@gmail.com Subject: Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC To: pd-list@iem.at Message-ID: 5d782c50909091219m50188513ga6a1babecab29...@mail.gmail.com Content-Type:

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-08 Thread Fernando Gadea
I have been reading, silently, the discussion, which I have really enjoyed. Here are some thoughts: 1- physical instruments What I see in hardware/hands-in-stuff/instrumental music is what I learned at school as "haptic" knowledge: Something like body/muscles memory, that makes it possible

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-08 Thread ydego...@gmail.com
i really don't remember who brought that thing of 'end of computer music' on that list, i would mainly say, it's no good to limit oneself to computer music, and generally for me, it's not enough. i'm glad you quote Tarkowski and not another *kowski... i like pan sonic i like luc ferrari i

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-08 Thread chris clepper
On Tue, Sep 8, 2009 at 10:39 PM, ydego...@gmail.com ydego...@gmail.comwrote: i like luc ferrari About 10-12 years ago I took Luc to a Chicago house club. He was really into dance music in the 90s, and not so much into 'computer music'. He was getting more inspiration from going to clubs than

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-05 Thread Roman Haefeli
On Fri, 2009-09-04 at 12:44 -0400, Hans-Christoph Steiner wrote: On Sep 4, 2009, at 12:09 PM, glerm soares wrote: 2009/9/4 glerm soares organi...@gmail.com I have yet to see any computer or electronic music

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-05 Thread ydego...@gmail.com
Chris McCormick wrote: On Fri, Sep 04, 2009 at 03:40:20PM +0200, ydego...@gmail.com wrote: Chris McCormick wrote: On Fri, Sep 04, 2009 at 02:35:00PM +0200, ydego...@gmail.com wrote: as far as noise is concerned, my favs all use analog equipment : wolf eyes, incapacitants,

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-04 Thread ydego...@gmail.com
ola, Trying to think of a few releases that do it for me, that don't go for the quantized clubstep grid or the usual academic Fast Fourier Tropes, use computers and related technologies in a refreshing way and sound really visceral and alive, off the top of my head I'd say: Kevin Drumm -

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-04 Thread Andy Farnell
Analog - kinda... I saw Merzbow at Highbury Islington back in 1992/3. His stage act was a chain of fx pedals and guitar, and electric drill/grinder wheel. On Fri, 04 Sep 2009 14:35:00 +0200 ydego...@gmail.com ydego...@gmail.com wrote: ola, Trying to think of a few releases that do it

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-04 Thread chris clepper
On Fri, Sep 4, 2009 at 8:35 AM, ydego...@gmail.com ydego...@gmail.comwrote: as far as noise is concerned, my favs all use analog equipment : wolf eyes, incapacitants, macronympha, to live and shave in L.A., kk null, ... 'The King of Noise' Boyd Rice made some of the best noise records

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-04 Thread Chris McCormick
On Fri, Sep 04, 2009 at 02:35:00PM +0200, ydego...@gmail.com wrote: as far as noise is concerned, my favs all use analog equipment : wolf eyes, incapacitants, macronympha, to live and shave in L.A., kk null, ... Pretty sure I saw two kaoss pads on stage when kk null was playing. Chris.

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-04 Thread ydego...@gmail.com
Chris McCormick wrote: On Fri, Sep 04, 2009 at 02:35:00PM +0200, ydego...@gmail.com wrote: as far as noise is concerned, my favs all use analog equipment : wolf eyes, incapacitants, macronympha, to live and shave in L.A., kk null, ... Pretty sure I saw two kaoss pads on stage when

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-04 Thread Chris McCormick
On Fri, Sep 04, 2009 at 03:40:20PM +0200, ydego...@gmail.com wrote: Chris McCormick wrote: On Fri, Sep 04, 2009 at 02:35:00PM +0200, ydego...@gmail.com wrote: as far as noise is concerned, my favs all use analog equipment : wolf eyes, incapacitants, macronympha, to live and shave in L.A.,

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-04 Thread Hans-Christoph Steiner
This is the band I most enjoy recently: http://www.slavicsoulparty.com/ I have yet to see any computer or electronic music show that can hold a candle to the feeling of being packed into a room of people dancing face-to-face with 9 musicians pouring their guts into completely physical

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-04 Thread glerm soares
I have yet to see any computer or electronic music show that can hold a candle to the feeling of being packed into a room of people dancing face-to-face with 9 musicians pouring their guts into completely physical instruments. same for satanique samba trio:

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-04 Thread glerm soares
2009/9/4 glerm soares organi...@gmail.com I have yet to see any computer or electronic music show that can hold a candle to the feeling of being packed into a room of people dancing face-to-face with 9 musicians pouring their guts into completely physical instruments. we don't even need

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-04 Thread Hans-Christoph Steiner
On Sep 4, 2009, at 12:09 PM, glerm soares wrote: 2009/9/4 glerm soares organi...@gmail.com I have yet to see any computer or electronic music show that can hold a candle to the feeling of being packed into a room of people dancing face-to-face with 9 musicians pouring their guts into

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-04 Thread Derek Holzer
When there's finally a computer that sounds its best after I've pounded the living hell out of it and sweat all over it for at least 4 hours, then I might get more interested in live computer music again. Hunting and pecking at the keyboard while you IRC with your coding buddies is a poor

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-04 Thread Mathieu Bouchard
On Fri, 4 Sep 2009, Chris McCormick wrote: On Fri, Sep 04, 2009 at 03:40:20PM +0200, ydego...@gmail.com wrote: classification analog/digital is very arbitrary, as all use both, like pan sonic uses a lot of electronics, i don't know why they will still be classified in computer music, maybe the

[PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-03 Thread Derek Holzer
So let's see, it was 1996, and Bob's making noises like Jungle, DrumBass or some other megatrend crowdpleaser just arrived to save him from the avant-hegemony of the elbow patch professor crowd's software diddlings. About the same time, Paul Miller aka DJ Spooky was lamenting how jazz has been

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-03 Thread Lorenzo
http://bobostertag.com/writings-articles-computer-music-sucks.htm (this link does not necessarily represent the views or opinions of the sender) Could someone please write an article All-of-these-[something]-sucks-articles-really-suck? I find them so boring, superficial and unproductive.

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-03 Thread Chris McCormick
On Thu, Sep 03, 2009 at 03:23:17PM +0200, Lorenzo wrote: http://bobostertag.com/writings-articles-computer-music-sucks.htm (this link does not necessarily represent the views or opinions of the sender) Could someone please write an article

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-03 Thread chris clepper
On Thu, Sep 3, 2009 at 5:17 AM, Derek Holzer de...@umatic.nl wrote: (No I'm not anywhere near being banked by Mego, these just happened all to be sitting near the top of the pile due to repeated listening...although finding much computer music at all around my house is a bit of a challenge!)

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-03 Thread ydego...@gmail.com
what is that obsession of winning and loosing, failing and suceeding ? we were only speaking of the impact of computer music in the western culture, i don't see the point or do you call bob ostertag a looser? anyway, that video about 'thinking positive' is really like wasp propaganda, why not a

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-03 Thread Andy Farnell
loser? Or looser, like less up-tight? On Thu, 03 Sep 2009 16:44:15 +0200 ydego...@gmail.com ydego...@gmail.com wrote: what is that obsession of winning and loosing, failing and suceeding ? we were only speaking of the impact of computer music in the western culture, i don't see the

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-03 Thread Chris McCormick
Yves: good point! I haven't seen the video because I can't play flash videos. Sorry if I subjected you to something awful. Developersdevelopersdevelopers, Chris. On Thu, Sep 03, 2009 at 04:44:15PM +0200, ydego...@gmail.com wrote: what is that obsession of winning and loosing, failing and

Re: [PD] computer music WAS: Re: Pd at a livecoding event on the BBC

2009-09-03 Thread Mathieu Bouchard
On Thu, 3 Sep 2009, Derek Holzer wrote: (I might argue that something called the 1980's killed it already...who actually listens to the last couple drum machine- and sampler-plagued Miles Davis records? Bob O?). The high culture vs low culture thing was very big that decade if I remember