Re: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind'

2018-12-08 Thread Eugene Halton
John characterized Aristotle: “5. Rational psyche of an animal having logos (zôon logon echein). Each psyche inherits all the abilities of the more primitive psyches. For Aristotle, the rational psyche of humans is the most advanced.” I prefer “Rational psyche of an animal having

RE: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind'

2018-12-08 Thread gnox
Gary R, Jon, list, Gary, to answer your question first: If matter corresponds to 1ns in this selection, what corresponds to 2ns seems to be experience, or perhaps more specifically, experience of the unfamiliar. Or we might say that 2ns is the force of determination. Read the whole selection

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind'

2018-12-07 Thread Gary Richmond
Jon, list, Thanks for this post as it appears to me from these passages (and many other which I'm sure could be cited and which I vaguely recall) that I will *not* have to revise/upend/reverse everything I've ever thought about how Peirce viewed form and matter; and that I can continue to safely

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind'

2018-12-07 Thread Jon Alan Schmidt
Gary F., List: Here is what Peirce actually wrote at EP 2:373 (1906). CSP: *The idea of growth,*--the stately tree springing from the tiny grain,--was the key that Aristotle brought to be tried upon this intricate grim lock. In such trials he came upon those wonderful conceptions, *δύναμις *and

Re: RE: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind'

2018-12-07 Thread Edwina Taborsky
with the rest of his philosophy. Gary f. -Original Message- From: John F Sowa Sent: 6-Dec-18 13:30 To: peirce-l@list.iupui.edu Subject: Re: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind' In discussing quasimind, it's important to consider Aristotle's hierarchy

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind'

2018-12-07 Thread Gary Richmond
ut I’ll > try to clarify if necessary. I do find it significant in that this same > period saw the publication of Peirce’s “Prolegomena to an Apology for > Pragmaticism,” his most elaborate attempt to connect his EGs with his > “proof” of pragmatism and thus with the rest of his philosophy.

RE: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind'

2018-12-07 Thread gnox
” of pragmatism and thus with the rest of his philosophy. Gary f. -Original Message- From: John F Sowa Sent: 6-Dec-18 13:30 To: peirce-l@list.iupui.edu Subject: Re: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind' In discussing quasimind, it's important to consider Aristotle's hierarchy

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind'

2018-12-06 Thread John F Sowa
In discussing quasimind, it's important to consider Aristotle's hierarchy of psyches in _De Anima_. Since Peirce was familiar with Aristotle, that hierarchy may have had some influence on his views: 1. Vegetative psyche of plants. 2. Sensitive psyche of sessile animals like sponges and

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind'

2018-12-05 Thread Gary Richmond
Edwina, list, You wrote: ET: I'd say that 'resonance' can be equated with 'semiosis', which in my view, is a constant ongoing reality in our material world. As the article says ' all things are constantly in motion, vibrating'. I'd say that all things are in a constant process of semiosis. I

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind'

2018-12-05 Thread Gary Richmond
Mike, Jon, Gene, list, I'm not sure the article has much--if anything--to do with 'quasi-mind' as Peirce conceived of it, Mike, but I am intrigued, as I have been for some time, by the idea of 'panpsychism', to which the article's author's 'resonance theory of consciousness' suggests, perhaps, an

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind'

2018-12-05 Thread Edwina Taborsky
BODY { font-family:Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;font-size:12px; }Thanks for the article - and yes, although it doesn't mention Peirce, it fits right in with his more exact theory. A few points: I'd say that 'resonance' can be equated with 'semiosis', which in my view,

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind'

2018-12-05 Thread Eugene Halton
Thought provoking article I can ... resonate ... with. Thanks for sending, Mike. Gene Halton On Wed, Dec 5, 2018 at 11:59 AM Mike Bergman wrote: > List, > > Speaking of quasi-minds, this reference is very thought provoking, > though the author does not mention Peirce: > > >

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Another Perspective on 'Quasi-Mind'

2018-12-05 Thread Jon Alan Schmidt
Mike, List: According to Peirce, consciousness is not logically necessary for something to be a Quasi-mind involved in semiosis. CSP: For the purpose of this inquiry a Sign may be defined as a Medium for the communication of a Form. It is not logically necessary that anything possessing